You Could Be Anyone III GAME OVER

[StrangerCoug]

So what do you think when someone who is experienced like Elyse who has a strong personality responds poorly to pressure (early game and the aj situation).

It would depend on a couple of factors, and I think experience would really only be much of a factor with newer players (in which case poor response to pressure can be attributed to that and not necessarily be a scumtell). After you're in the swing of things, the story becomes a lot more complex, and I don't feel like I can offer a simple answer. It's hard to tell if Aunt Jemina was on to something when we don't have a scumflip to work with, but Elyse's jump to conclusions about the Night 1 kill does seem off on reread.

[Garmr]

So can someone explain why you aren't at least letting me use my last shot to get town as much info as possible if you're going to lynch me no matter what to verify my info?

Kthx is scum. If you think it's me and not him, then fine. I'm willing to compromise on Boon because when I do eventually flip town, it will at least implicate the actual scum.

And if your a scum power role keeping you alive another day is giving them information. Even if your not a scum power role you'll be just a distraction.
There's plenty of scenarios here. Also did you crumb tracker anywhere or who you tracked and the results?

[MonkeyMan576]

I've played with Elyse as town and modded for her as scum, she can be pretty clever when she wants to be, but there are probably five scum out there so I don't see the harm in letting her test her claim one more time, and catching scum elsewhere for today.

[Sky_Paladin]

@Elyse

Kthx is scum. If you think it's me and not him, then fine. I'm willing to compromise on Boon because when I do eventually flip town, it will at least implicate the actual scum.

Things like this make me question whether I'd rather lynch you.

The counter wagon to presumed town!Elyse was TSO. You should be willing to compromise lynch TSO. There's been no real pressure to Boon so please explain your reason for saying this.

[Garmr]

Elyse sems more desperade than usual

[Garmr]

Desperate

[MonkeyMan576]

When I modded with her as scum Elyse was much more subtle, that's why I'm thinking her desperation might be townish.

[MonkeyMan576]

Of course, she was never suspected in that game much, so that might be the difference.

[Kthxbye]

Sorry I've been missing, but I'll have to be missing a little more. I'll be able to phone post but don't expect deep thoughts.

MOD: V/LA through 14May

[Elyse]

So can someone explain why you aren't at least letting me use my last shot to get town as much info as possible if you're going to lynch me no matter what to verify my info?

Kthx is scum. If you think it's me and not him, then fine. I'm willing to compromise on Boon because when I do eventually flip town, it will at least implicate the actual scum.

And if your a scum power role keeping you alive another day is giving them information. Even if your not a scum power role you'll be just a distraction.
There's plenty of scenarios here. Also did you crumb tracker anywhere or who you tracked and the results?

No I didn't crumb anything.

@Elyse

Kthx is scum. If you think it's me and not him, then fine. I'm willing to compromise on Boon because when I do eventually flip town, it will at least implicate the actual scum.

Things like this make me question whether I'd rather lynch you.

The counter wagon to presumed town!Elyse was TSO. You should be willing to compromise lynch TSO. There's been no real pressure to Boon so please explain your reason for saying this.

I am also willing to lynch TSO but it does not look like other people are. Boon is someone I have been scumreading for a while now so I will look there if people are unwilling to vote kthx/TSO.

Elyse sems more desperade than usual

Oooh vague blanket statements that are untrue! Fun!

[inte]

elyse u legit have NO OTHER reads besides a lurker vi?

[Elyse]

Yeah I do

[T S O]

You'll basically lynch anyone going, though. Kthx? Check. Boon? Check. TSO? Check again.

[Klingoncelt]

@RMM Sheeping Ank would mean voting for you. You do actually realize this right?

lol

[Klingoncelt]

Anyone who wants to lynch me feel free to do it.

When I flip town and you realize that we were that stupid that we lynched 3 towns and 0 scum so far, I hope you realize that you need to think instead of assuming.

We only lynched 1 Town so far. Assuming the next lynch is Town, that would make 2.

However

, there have been TWO Townies that were

nightkilled.

Did you just scumslip???


You were on the Yakko, wagon.....

UNVOTE:

VOTE: RationalMadman

[jasonT1981]

Official Vote Count

Elyse

(4): Garmr, Kthxbye, T S O, inte

Kthxbye

(3): Jaqen Hghar, Elyse, Boonskiies

RationalMadman

(2): Ankamius, Klingoncelt

T S O

(2): Sky_Paladin, StrangerCoug

Klingoncelt

(1): massive

Boonskiies

(1): MonkeyMan576

ZZZX

(1): RationalMadman

Not Voting

(4): TheWayItEnds, PeregrineV, ZZZX, Fresh

V/LA

(1): Kthxbye (14th)

Day 3 Deadline

(expired on 2015-05-16 19:32:29)
with 18 alive it takes 10 to lynch

[PeregrineV]

Not sure that's a slip exactly, but I want to see where this goes, since everyone else I want to lynch seems to be going nowhere.

Vote: RationalMadman

[T S O]

This is not a fucking slip! How would this be a slip? How would RationalMadman substituting "lynched" for "killed" be a scumslip?

[T S O]

Not sure that's a slip exactly, but I want to see where this goes, since everyone else I want to lynch seems to be going nowhere.

Vote: RationalMadman

And

yet again

Peregrine makes a blatant leap onto a wagon which may gain traction.

This. is. not. Peregrine's. town. play.

[Boonskiies]

elyse always scumreads me when she is scum.

VOTE: elyse

[MonkeyMan576]

smh.


Boon, that is about the definition of OMGUS.

[T S O]

Of course, she was never suspected in that game much, so that might be the difference.

Just, let's clarify what happened with this train of thought, Monkey.

Garmr: Elyse seems desperate this game.
Monkey: She wasn't desperate as scum this other time, though, so I think she's town.
Monkey: On second thought, she was under no pressure that game, though...

Unless you think Elyse would be randomly desperate as scum for no reason,

this reason holds no water.

Please go back and re-evaluate your Elyse read.

[T S O]

Does anyone here have an issue with lynching PeregrineV? Because one scum is the same as the other, it seems more likely to happen right now, and Peregrine's above post is quite literally a fucking scumclaim. He claimed in thread right there.

[Ankamius]

I want to know where PVs scum read comes from before I judge his switch for sure.

[MonkeyMan576]

Of course, she was never suspected in that game much, so that might be the difference.

Just, let's clarify what happened with this train of thought, Monkey.

Garmr: Elyse seems desperate this game.
Monkey: She wasn't desperate as scum this other time, though, so I think she's town.
Monkey: On second thought, she was under no pressure that game, though...

Unless you think Elyse would be randomly desperate as scum for no reason,

this reason holds no water.

Please go back and re-evaluate your Elyse read.

I just did reevaluate. I said she might be town because she's normally not desperate as scum, or she might be desperate because she's under pressure.