Open 595: Elemental Mafia (Town Wins!)

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I think we rely on Bella to be amazing again.

That sounds like a good plan.

[TheReverend]

Here's what we do.

Lynch toffee.

I'll hit farside tonight. I'll enjoy that. Docs leave her alone. If she doesn't die, she's the SK (1x shot BP). If she dies, lynch me and happy hunting.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

You die today, scumbag.

I'm not getting lynched. I already told you this.

[TheReverend]

claim - innocent child

[Plotinus]

VOTE: The Reverend choo choo

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Plotinus, you SK?

[Plotinus]

no, just giddy that we're nailing our third scum on day 2

[Plotinus]

and I know nothing about SK hunting either. I played an offsite game with 3 SKs and no mafia that completed a while ago and the SKs didn't know each other (there was a weird mechanic for picking who would kill each night), and after the game they all said they chose their kill based on whoever couldn't be tied to them: no one who was suspicious of them and nobody they thought could potentially be another of the SKs. it was weird. anyway that's literally all I know about SKs and I'm not even sure it counts.

[TheReverend]

I'm good at hunting SKs.

[Bellaphant]

I think we rely on Bella to be amazing again.

That sounds like a good plan.

I like this! Seriously, though, how did you know? Or you just glory hunting

Haha don't let this fool y'all. I'm near certain that toffee is SK. Don't let him win.

Shame the tracker tagged me. You'd never have got me otherwise.

Nah, you must have done something to make me track ya

Seriously, town, we could win tonight flawlessly. Don't hammer Rev 'til we have a plan. I think Docs can state which protect they are gonna use, cover me, we find scum (this bit we need to work on!) and we win.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I agree.

Now we only have one kill to deal with docs should out and state what protect they will use to make sure Bella is fully covered.

[TheReverend]

I straight up scum slipped earlier in the thread, that's the only reason I did the kill instead of flubber. I was paranoid that would get found eventually. Had flub killed ric, I'd be looking golden right now.

I had to claim VT, not least to ensure SK didn't hit me for a while.

I'll leave you guys to it. Good luck SK, you need it.

[Bellaphant]

@Rev, when did you slip?

[TheReverend]

@toffee - idk, I think we get a lot from people's reactions to these kind of things. Scum would have anticipated this...

This was relating to papi's fakeclaim. Scum wouldn't anticipate town claiming, would they?

[Plotinus]

oh, that's clever. what you'd get from people's reactions is who the other power roles are, isn't it?

[Plotinus]

(my motivation for 1514: my second newbie game just ended and as a town powerrole I derphammered the other town powerrole on day 1. his reaction to something that both of us seem to have interpreted as a crumb for a role that we knew wasn't in our setup could have clued me in that he was the other one, but it didn't. My head is still kinda in that game and I'm thinking about things I could have noticed but didn't)

[Bellaphant]

Hmm, I actually was okay with that. Also, BBT, you are avoiding my question

[BlueBloodedToffee]

What if a PR had a result?

In a sec, far: can you clarify the first bit of your post first? (head-cold, beer, election night = idiot)

Sure, I just wanted to make sure I wasn't missing anything.

I claim PR.

It was obviously much easier once you claimed PR but it looked like you were subtly asking for advice on what a PR should do in particular situations, just hinted that you were tracker.

[Bellaphant]

Cool, I thought you'd spotted my super-sneaky crumb.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

You have one?

[FA_Q2]

Okay, so I asked us not to lynch anyone before I full claimed?

I'm gonna come out with it: I'm the tracker. I got a result on The Reverend. He was tracked to Ricastle last night.

I've kept quiet because I was wondering if he'd claim Doc. But, I now know he is a) scum and b) was SK hunting last night.

Evidence on top:

He was on and off the Papi wagon and his read on him was off (Sen has picked up on this)
662 Calls Ric the SK
919 Is very clever, but he basically just admitted it.

He CAN'T be the doc: 1425

He pushed a bunch of 'scum-reads' who were town. He got lucky/unlucky in the fact most of them claimed PR. He's now pushing BBT, who scum-read him from the start. His day 2 posting looks really good - hell, it made me think I was wrong and he WAS a doc who protected the wrong element and was being clever about it - but it's easy to push scum-reads as scum and a lot of it has been theory.

He's scum and he killed Ric last night.

VOTE: The Reverend

Protect me tonight.

Well that decides that.

Have we reached a lynch yet?

VOTE: the reverend

[Plotinus]

@FA: I think we're still discussing strategy for hunting the SK tomorrow and how exactly the tracker should be protected tonight (what elements the docs should protect to make sure she's fully covered) but the reverend is obviously today's lynch.

[Bellaphant]

We can't lynch untik the docs have agreed how to protect me. Anyone derp hammering is the sk.

[FA_Q2]

You should take seriously that I got scum lynched.

You should take seriously that I was looking for scum off the Papi wagon because I didn't believe scum double bussed.

You should take seriously my cases for both Farside and FA scum.

You should take seriously that I am town. I thought this would be evident enough in my play, obviously I was wrong.

I guess this dies not matter anymore but your 'case' on me was based entirely on me moving off a wagon that was not going to happen. Seems like a rather lame case.

Of course we now know I cannot be scum as we are about to lynch all of them and all bets are off with the SK - the SK looks very much like town.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Something I just thought of with the SK is he still needs to mislynch town (throughout the game, from the beginning)

Might be worth looking at who was on wagons and why. Find the weak link.