Mini 1670 - WTF MAFIA

[Ricastle]

I only have one vote. Does it matter which Menno pusher I vote?

[Ricastle]

^That's to Flubber. Damn pagetops...

[Derangement]

I only have one vote. Does it matter which Menno pusher I vote?

I know the question's not meant for me, but if you don't have a personal preference, then voting for the one who already has more votes on them is usually a good way to force them to react.

[Ricastle]

Oh, your reaction's been just fine, pal.

[Flubbernugget]

I only have one vote. Does it matter which Menno pusher I vote?

Yeah you should probably push the scummier of the two

[McMenno]

If I self-hammer I auto-lose. :'(

[Derangement]

If I self-hammer I auto-lose. :'(

This is understandable.
And if a

different

third-party (non-town, non-scum) hammers you?

[McMenno]

2. Third Party is a faction.

[Ricastle]

Yeah you should probably push the scummier of the two

I am. Derangement seems worse because they're prolonging the topic, doomsaying to breed apathy, and generally seem ingenuine.

If a 3rd party kills Menno then his goal would be to kill that player. That should be obvious shouldn't it?

[Flubbernugget]

Okay so why is elusive townier than derangement?

I never said that.

[Flubbernugget]

This has to be the case though because you're voting derangement, right?

I think the lurking is less productive than the active participation and therefore scummier

[Derangement]

Derangement seems worse because they're prolonging the topic, doomsaying to breed apathy, and generally seem ingenuine.

My intent is not to breed apathy: quite the contrary.
I want to nuke McMenno from orbit, and would like to find out what the best way to do it is, and do that as soon as possible.

You're not the first person to reads me as ingenuine, so I'm afraid I can't help with that part.

If a 3rd party kills Menno then his goal would be to kill that player. That should be obvious shouldn't it?

I thought so too, but he's calling third-party a faction in and of itself, which strikes me as more lies to make things harder to understand (or just to save his bacon).

[McMenno]

I want to nuke McMenno from orbit

You're so subtle~

If a 3rd party kills Menno then his goal would be to kill that player. That should be obvious shouldn't it?

I thought so too, but he's calling third-party a faction in and of itself, which strikes me as more lies to make things harder to understand (or just to save his bacon).

Is it not?

[Ricastle]

This has to be the case though because you're voting derangement, right?

I think the lurking is less productive than the active participation and therefore scummier

I don't find elusive 'townier' because she's done nothing so far to seem town. Am I supposed to be simultaneously voting all suspicious players? Wth.

It's the content derangement puts out that gets me. But both of them could easily be scum as far as I'm concerned.

[ika]

@Moderator: Could you please clarify if a scenario with three mafia , one third party scum, and four town players still alive is game-over (3+1 vs 4) or not (3 vs 1 vs 4)?

In your said scenario the game would go on.

Many things can happen that can reasult in town being back in the game

[shos]

ok after the kung fu I'll be here.

[Derangement]

I thought so too, but he's calling third-party a faction in and of itself, which strikes me as more lies to make things harder to understand (or just to save his bacon).

Is it not?

I never thought it was, and apparently I'm not alone in this.

@Moderator: Could you please clarify if a scenario with three mafia , one third party scum, and four town players still alive is game-over (3+1 vs 4) or not (3 vs 1 vs 4)?

In your said scenario the game would go on.

Many things can happen that can reasult in town being back in the game

This is rather reassuring, actually.
Thanks!

[Bellaphant]

Okay, so it doesn't seem like we are in mylo. I've never played any WTF or bastard, so this a learning experience for me.

What if McMenno is 3rd party to start with? alignment change then kinda makes sense. There is more than 1 set of '3rd party'. Ika's post has also got me worried about zombies!

Currently a little worried about Bins, and I think Drixx is probably town, but should definitely follow-through with the hammer - (is this still a thing?)

[Bins]

I'm not hated in LYLO!

[Bellaphant]

oh?

[BRantz]

We seem to have two camps of people on McMenno here, the camp that is just calling his role bullshit, and the camp that is worried it might be a real thing. My question is, does it matter which of the two it is? I see no problem leaving Menno alive as long as he is helping the town, and lynching him the second that stops, regardless of if he is telling the truth or not.

@Bella: What don't you like about Bins?

[Ricastle]

Why don't we just leave Menno to an investigator?

[Bins]

We seem to have two camps of people on McMenno here, the camp that is just calling his role bullshit, and the camp that is worried it might be a real thing. My question is, does it matter which of the two it is? I see no problem leaving Menno alive as long as he is helping the town, and lynching him the second that stops, regardless of if he is telling the truth or not.

My problem is with the fact we're going to need to have the discussion about who hammers him and I'm not ready to do that yet.

[Bins]

Why don't we just leave Menno to an investigator?

Lying or not, he's scum either way.

[Bellaphant]

True, Brantz: I think scum will have hedged their bets and there is at least one in either camp. My main worry is he doesn't have much incentive to actually scum-hunt, as the odd are in favour of cruising to the end. If we have another townie run up, who claims a useful role, it might be worth lynching him to stop any town with a protective role outing too early

@Brantz: can out with role info straight away (weird when McM did it, weird when she did it), then explained it was only part of a '4 part role', even though at least mine and elusive's were pretty short, and I feel like she's posted a lot without me being able to get an obvious read on her, which was very different to her style in our last game. I'm feeling the same way about Ricastle as well, tbh.

What do you think we should do next, Brantz? Has anything pinged for you, yet?

I'd like a vote-count soon!

p-edit, Ricastle, like a cop? It might come back with roles, not alignment?
pp-edit: he's certainly not town-motivated. I dunno if that makes him flat out scum, or other third party.