13p Normal [TM2015]

[Egg]

Lmao

[Egg]

Pie, cheet wants me to tell you that Boon's last post reminds him of the Burning and Boon probably doesn't believe that's a slip and is trying whatever he can tokeep himself alive

[pieguyn]

agreed. (also, what you pointed out about him no-killing is part of why I thought he'd be likely to be the one who no-killed in this scenario here)

[Boonskiies]

Ffs, my entire game plan for playing the burning was to epicly go to my town meta as much as I could. So that should actually be a town tell play.

[Boonskiies]

Do you know how fucking constantly I say people slip when I'm fucking town. Fucking all the fucking time. It's a fucking slip because he accuses me of slipping for saying something that he misread, and then he confirms it not a slip by saying it's the exact actual reason why it should have been a slip. Lynch fucking Egg toDay, and the game is over. I AM FUCKING TOWN.

[Boonskiies]

Also, Cheetory can't read me for crap, but he can tell you how to mislynch me. Cheetory is just spouting stuff for egg to say that would make a good case on me.

[Boonskiies]

the scum team no killing probably was set up to frame me also.

[Trojan Horse]

Grr. I had just about gotten to the point where I was ready to vote for Egg. Then Boon had to go stick his foot in his mouth again, and make me reconsider.

Sigh...

I'll still do it, but you're not making this easy, Boon...

VOTE: Egg

[pieguyn]

ehhhh

vote: Boon

I'm not ready for day to end yet, but this is where I will likely want to vote; I'd still like to hear potential arguments for scum outside egg/Boon to make sure I'm not just missing smth here.

[Trojan Horse]

Egg's 1st post:

Vote Sleepykrew

Also I'm V/LA. Don't know until when. Shooting for about April 6th.

Mala's 1st post:

GET HYPED.

VOTE: SLEEPYKREW

Thor's 3rd post (emphasis mine):

Oh yeah, I actually misread who was being speed wagoned there.
Eh, I'm good with the 'Sleepy is useless' case also, though it is spearheaded by a derp vote whom I would also be fine voting.

Mala and Egg were good voters.

@Save - what part of his actions is protected by the "sanctity" of RVS?

Egg's 5th post (emphasis mine):

Mala, what is your read on Thor?

Not sure I like STD's... would you call it pre-OMGUS? He basically implies that if Thor votes him soon, he's scum.

The high percentage of dice talk in Fenchurch's posts feels weird too.

Would scum have connected themselves together like that so early in the game? I wonder...

[Boonskiies]

Holy fuck. People putting emotion as being scum. It's so obviously Egg. Good to know I was wrong about Pie being able to read me correctly.

[Boonskiies]

ehhhh

vote: Boon

I'm not ready for day to end yet, but this is where I will likely want to vote; I'd still like to hear potential arguments for scum outside egg/Boon to make sure I'm not just missing smth here.

Egg is seriously obviously scum. Trojan confirmed himself as town with his latest posts.

[Boonskiies]

And Delta confirmed himself earlier.

[Boonskiies]

Alright, I checked one of my town games with Egg, and lookie here!!! That thing Egg is saying is a scum thing...is something I did THREE SEPARATE TIMES IN ONE GAME. In a game where he was alive for most of that. Egg is fucking scum.

All 3 of these have me accusing people of scum slipping. One game. Was town. Egg was in this game.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 0#p6433000

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 7#p6572587

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 7#p6573377

[Egg]

Two things Cheet wants:
-Pie. Can you make two bullet points why everyone is town? (I'm guessing he means your town reads)
-Trojan. Reasoning for your vote.

Boon, I legit don't understand how acknowledging another possibility is a slip.

the scum team no killing probably was set up to frame me also.

If scum was sitting on your GTKAS looking for this, why did it not come out before now?

Trojan, I think something prompted my last post you quoted. Let me see if I can find it. Hard to remember something from almost 2 months ago but I vaguely do.

Preview edit: something like calling out a slip isn't something I can see someone ONLY doing as town. Stop trying to paint that as a lie from Cheet.

[Boonskiies]

Oh. I guess the last time was me just being annoying. Still.

[Egg]

Ehhh I can't find it. I think it came from when she said he brought us to the meat of the game or whatever but didn't call it a town tell or anything and I just wanted her read on record but then I forgot about it

[Boonskiies]

Funny how you are the one bring my GTKAS thing. Looks like you guys were planning it. I'm not trying to paint that as a lie from Cheet. I'm pointing it out as an inconsistency on your part. You were calling me scum because of it; I'm proving you wrong, and you are changing your wording now. And now, you are hung up and flailing and doing whatever you can to stay alive.

Look at how he's talking to Pie. He's 'trusting' pie because she's voting me, and she is his best chance at getting a mislynch. Night happens, he kills Pie, and feels he can somehow get another mislynch tomorrow.

Also look at how he talks to Trojan. He's trying to subtly change TH mind about it, and at the same time, trying to look as townie as possible for the others while doing so.

[Boonskiies]

@Sthar - Get Antihero or TellTaleHeart to read me. If you are town, they'll surely see this as my town game.

[Boonskiies]

Also, Trojan's 2159 is a beautiful find, and I don't see why we would lynch anyone else besides Egg toDay.

[Boonskiies]

what do you make of the point that scum knew there was a town RB in the game after N1? you think they'd bus anyway and leave only one scum left when one scum vs. a town RB is essentially autoloss for them?

or am I just going wrong here

What makes you think they knew about an rb?

Maybe Boon just slipped that their role cop checked STD.

what do you make of the point that scum knew there was a town RB in the game after N1? you think they'd bus anyway and leave only one scum left when one scum vs. a town RB is essentially autoloss for them?

or am I just going wrong here

What makes you think they knew about an rb?

Mala was given a No Result on her role cop investigation.

Oh. Or that

'
Seriously, though. If Egg really had any thought of that being a slip, how would me saying, "Mala was given a No Result on her role cop investigation", clear it up in any possible way?

[Boonskiies]

Votecount 2.10:

Malakittens (6-LYNCH)-

pieguyn,

SleepyKrew

, Egg,

Save The Dragons

, sthar8, Trojan Horse,

DeltaWave (3)-

Boonskiies,

Malakittens

,

jasonT1981

,

Boonskiies (1)-

DeltaWave,

Not voting (1)-

Bins

,

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Deadline is at 6pm on the 30th April 2015. (expired on 2015-04-30 13:00:00)

STD is v/la until Sunday 3rd May.

Malakittens has been lynched. Flip incoming...

If Boonskiies was scum, that would mean the entire Malakittens wagon was town-driven and nobody was bussing her. I'm not saying it's impossible but I would expect a busser at that stage of the game. This does sort of call TH into question.

Egg is on that wagon as well.

[Boonskiies]

agreed. (also, what you pointed out about him no-killing is part of why I thought he'd be likely to be the one who no-killed in this scenario here)

The difference is I no-killed in that game because it was the absolute safest thing to do. I try to play very safe as scum, as you saw in Pokemon Gen 1 Theme game. That would not be a safe gambit coming from my slot.

[Boonskiies]

Also, think of it this way, you lynch incorrectly toDay, Egg will be much stronger and keeping away from being lynched tomorrow. If Egg was town and I was scum, even if we lynch Egg toDay, you'd lynch me tomorrow. Lynch me toDay, and Egg can potentially talk his way out of a lynch. I can't. If I'm scum, I already lose. Please....lynch Egg toDay.

[Trojan Horse]

-Trojan. Reasoning for your vote.

Let me quote one of my earlier posts:

Alright, let me take a shot at this.

I'm going to make a (probably stupid) assumption, and guess that scum would not have bussed each other during day 2. (Unless both scum came under pressure; then they'd pretty much have no choice but to do some bussing.) It would've been a risky move, with one scum lynched Day 1; top priority is keeping both remaining scum alive. They could do some bussing later, but not right then.

Under my horrible assumption, pie, SK, and Egg are all town. (I'm not counting sthar here, who fought against Mala's lynch until right before she claimed.) Let's also assume jason/Zach is scum, due to play balance and all that. That leaves Boon, sthar, and Delta.

I still think that scum would've tried as best they could to avoid a scumlynch during day 2. However, looking back at that day, I see that Mala already had 3 votes when Egg voted for her, and I had already said that I might be a 4th. Perhaps Egg's vote wasn't a bus, but an attempt to avoid suspicion himself.

There was also the fact that Mala called both Delta and Egg likely scum, and then voted for Delta. Considering the danger Mala was in at that point, I don't think she would've said that she had a solid townread on her scummate. That would just be setting up her scummate to be lynched as well. (So, Boon is probably not the last scum.) But calling her scummate a likely scum, while going for someone else... that makes total sense.

I could dig up some more things, but really, it's a general scumvibe I get from Egg's iso. (Oversoul is saying the same thing.) And since I no longer think Egg's vote of Mala is evidence that Egg is town, I think Egg is the likeliest to be scum.