Guild of Dungeoneering Mafia (Game Over)

[DrippingGoofball]

I am going to sheep the daycop.

VOTE: Oversoul

[PeregrineV]

With about 12 hours left, we mainly need to lynch someone. I don't necessarily buy Heartless's claim because I think scum would have claims similar to town roles, but even if I did buy it, it's not a terribly town-sided role from what I can tell.

VOTE: Heartless

You don't get it. It isn't similar. It is exactly my role.

vote heartless

I didn't realize deadline is so close.

You claim to have the same role and are voting to lynch him?

[Heartless]

why?

b/c i fussed about tth not helping me
i shouldn't have
that's all i was saying.

[Heartless]

With about 12 hours left, we mainly need to lynch someone. I don't necessarily buy Heartless's claim because I think scum would have claims similar to town roles, but even if I did buy it, it's not a terribly town-sided role from what I can tell.

VOTE: Heartless

right...

ok, link me a game where scum's claim was exactly the same as a town one. go.

also, do you think vezok is scum?

[Papa Zito]

I am going to sheep the daycop.

VOTE: Oversoul

I didn't say nuthin bout no daycops :3

[vezokpiraka]

Do you have another ability you haven"t claimed and an equipment?

oh yeah

equipment is useless, but we have repel which is a doc, stupidity which does nothing

Hmm. I don't have the doc. I have Stage-presence and a useless equipment.

[znitzchel]

Heartless and Oversoul are things because...?

Someone help me out with end of day maintenance, obviously I have been unavailable for quite a bit (and so has ZZZX). I don't understand why Oversoul is scummy and getting votes, and I don't like the composition of Heartless' or Shazam's wagon right now (and also Shazam is probably town).

[Doctor Vahlen]

I think both Heartless and Vezok can go die. I don't like either of them. The whole counterclaim on each other seems staged.

[Papa Zito]

ffs

[znitzchel]

What the miller thing? That means next to nothing and gets into out-guessing the Mod territory. I also claimed Miller, did I stage that too?

I want some in-game reasons. Where was Heartless trying to manipulate anyone? Where were they pushing a scum agenda? Literally two out of three votes on there wagon are from playerslots I wouldn't trust to follow a lynch on right now, so I need more than "i don't like them" and "their claim looks staged", because you didn't demonstrate either thing to me.

[Yosarian2]

I don't understand the train on Oversoul. Like we are voting a person who doesn't have a vote? I mean, I guess WIFOM the scum could do that to their own or OverSoul could be SK or something but I just don't see it that likely for Day 1 them to pull that gambit.

Conversely, do you see scum town-confirming Oversoul by publicly removing his vote?

Meh. Maybe someone had the ability and wanted to try it out. It might not mean much more then that.

[Papa Zito]

Meh. Maybe someone had the ability and wanted to try it out. It might not mean much more then that.

is this real life

[Yosarian2]

With about 12 hours left, we mainly need to lynch someone. I don't necessarily buy Heartless's claim because I think scum would have claims similar to town roles, but even if I did buy it, it's not a terribly town-sided role from what I can tell.

VOTE: Heartless

You don't get it. It isn't similar. It is exactly my role.

vote heartless

I didn't realize deadline is so close.

You claim to have the same role and are voting to lynch him?

This whole thing is weird.

I guess the question here is if roles and alignment are independent in this game.

[Yosarian2]

Meh. Maybe someone had the ability and wanted to try it out. It might not mean much more then that.

is this real life

Is this just fantasy?

...seriously, people overthink these things. One of my rules as a mod is that if you give people a shiny toy to play with or big red button to push as part of their role, there's a significant chance they're going to push it, whether it makes any sense for them to do it or not. (See: the MAD mafia games I ran, where the town very quickly nuked itself back into the stone age both times.) At this point, I don't know if the oversoul vote theft thing means anything at all.

[znitzchel]

I don't understand the train on Oversoul. Like we are voting a person who doesn't have a vote? I mean, I guess WIFOM the scum could do that to their own or OverSoul could be SK or something but I just don't see it that likely for Day 1 them to pull that gambit.

Conversely, do you see scum town-confirming Oversoul by publicly removing his vote?

Meh. Maybe someone had the ability and wanted to try it out. It might not mean much more then that.

So much this.

[Papa Zito]

You claim to have the same role and are voting to lynch him?

This whole thing is weird.

I guess the question here is if roles and alignment are independent in this game.

Well we just discovered that in this particular case their roles aren't identical so that whole thing was just a waste of time.

Let's keep talking about roles on day 1 guys this is gr8. :V

Also if I wanna know what my role does I PM Dram and go "yo hawt owl what does X do?" and he goes "my good man it does Y" and then he calls me a sprinkler. I don't just randomly start casting spells at people wtf.

Anyway Imma hold out hope for a better lynch (aka not a lurker!!!!!!!!!!!!!111!!) but Heartless clearly doesn't give a shit so looks like that's happening yay.

[znitzchel]

I don't know what Oversoul losing his vote has anything to do with his alignment though, unless you think he did it to himself to gain towncred (of which we really don't have the evidence to make that leap in logic anyway). I'm not townreading him by any means, but so far I've seen DGB go "his scum partner must have done it to give him towncred" and "Oversoul isn't playing to his meta wha" both of which are pretty meaningless accusations.

[Kindness]

With about 12 hours left, we mainly need to lynch someone. I don't necessarily buy Heartless's claim because I think scum would have claims similar to town roles, but even if I did buy it, it's not a terribly town-sided role from what I can tell.

VOTE: Heartless

You don't get it. It isn't similar. It is exactly my role.

vote heartless

I didn't realize deadline is so close.

You claim to have the same role and are voting to lynch him?

This whole thing is weird.

I guess the question here is if roles and alignment are independent in this game.

we literally brought this up ages ago

in other news heartless is still more than likely the way to go

[BBmolla]

We have two bulletproof miller vigs?

LMAO

[znitzchel]

Wut?

[BBmolla]

Heartless claimed bulletproof miller vig and vezok says he is too

[vezokpiraka]

We have two bulletproof miller vigs?

LMAO

I was laughing out loud when I read my role.

[znitzchel]

What the fuck did I miss this?

(is this the part where I counter-counter claim?)

[znitzchel]

(no, no it's not don't worry)

[Papa Zito]

SMITE

Role Madness

Guild of Dungeoneering Mafia

guys plz