Mini Normal 1707 - Frog Mafia! - GAME OVER - TOWN WIN!

[notscience]

What do you think fits a role with two investigatives, a jk, and a named townie?

[zakk]

godfather

[AxleGreaser]

I for one think gunsmith/amnesiac cop sounds too OP to both be in the setup, whichi s why I'm voting shadowez.

2 Full investigatives. vs a matching pair of odd even split = 1 investigative worth of checks that is less swingy.

4 claimable roles is what I am dubious about.

and the dubious one is Zakk,

and then there is the small matter of him getting a scum PM.

[pistachi0n]

VOTE: Shaddowez

A no lynch is a bad idea.
I trust Metal more, his refusal to claim until anyone else went seems genuine.
Shadow's claim was fishy.

[Fro99er]

(expired on 2015-09-18 16:00:00)

(Fri Sep 18 @ 4:00:00 PM EST)

VOTECOUNT 4.03

• (0)

  Malakittens

  —
  
  
  (1)

  ika

  —
  singersigner
  
  (0)

  Metal Sonic

  —
  
  
  (3)

  shaddowez

  —
  Metal Sonic, notscience, pistachi0n
  
  (0)

  AxleGreaser

  —
  
  
  (0)

  Scorpious

  —
  
  
  (0)

  notscience

  —
  
  
  (4)

  zakk

  —
  Malakittens, AxleGreaser, Scorpious, shaddowez
  
  (0)

  pistachi0n

  —
  
  
  (0)

  singersigner

  —
  
  
  
  (2)

  (NOT VOTING)

  —
  ika, zakk
  
  With
  10

  alive
  , it takes
  6

  votes
  to lynch.
  

[Metal Sonic]

Godfather is useless to my gunsmith check so nada

[Metal Sonic]

Do you think Shaddowez wouldn't have thought so and felt comfortable claiming something that could get them lynched?

I think it's a perfectly reasonable balance with day talk and who knows what the third scum role is.

Odd night is towny but you actually have him the idea before he claimed it. That's... Spoiling it.

His ascetic modifier is very fishy because it has lots of scum utility but I don't see any way it actually hinders town, as in Mala can't jail him if he is actually scum

[Metal Sonic]

The good news of this lynch is that if shadow is town, his two clears can be trusted. And we are getting a confirmed investigative out tonight as well. Mala either jails, or I get my action in. One of us does though, but that's no big deal.

[Metal Sonic]

Dies

[AxleGreaser]

Odd night is towny but you actually have him the idea before he claimed it. That's... Spoiling it.

While true,
if you peer back further.

why else had he conveniently held back one check?

[Metal Sonic]

I saw it... I dunno man

I just feel sooooooo drowZyyyy

[AxleGreaser]

The good news of this lynch is that if shadow is town, his two clears can be trusted. And we are getting a confirmed investigative out tonight as well. Mala either jails, or I get my action in. One of us does though, but that's no big deal.

The bad news is no matter who you lynch you get that utility of one more clear tonight. So that is not an advantage specific to this plan.
It is however only a gunsmith clear and scum has not been concerned about stopping your clears on any other night.

I already suspect the no kills mean scum is not afraid of your checks.

[Metal Sonic]

Dude I only got a guilty on zakk once will you stop being a party pooper

[singersigner]

Let's lynch one of the not PRs and not soft innocents and see what happens either today or tonight. Ika or pistachio. Pick one.

[Metal Sonic]

You can pick for me and I will sheep you queen singer

I like ika so probably pistachio dude

[singersigner]

Also I'm apparently really bad at forgetting about things I need to go V/LA for. >_>

V/LA through Saturday.

[Fro99er]

Also I'm apparently really bad at forgetting about things I need to go V/LA for. >_>

V/LA through Saturday.

V/LA acknoweldged

[shaddowez]

The good news of this lynch is that if shadow is town, his two clears can be trusted. And we are getting a confirmed investigative out tonight as well. Mala either jails, or I get my action in. One of us does though, but that's no big deal.

Unless one of them is a godfather, which is the same dilemma we have right now. Also, is there some scum role that wouldn't have a gun, hence the no kill? If so, neither of your nor Mala's roles would actually net us anything.

Odd night is towny but you actually have him the idea before he claimed it. That's... Spoiling it.

While true,
if you peer back further.

why else had he conveniently held back one check?

Axle's got it. I picked up on you (MS) being even night in 1347. If we didn't full claim here and scum decided to target one of us, I figured if they didn't pick up on me being odd night they would target me tonight.

Let's lynch one of the not PRs and not soft innocents and see what happens either today or tonight. Ika or pistachio. Pick one.

I've heard Ika has a scum-meta of not posting much. Does anyone who's played with him more know if this fits in with that?

[AxleGreaser]

IMO
People need to from here on, treat the game more or less as moutainous (with named townies).
So yes people claimed stuff and it puts them in the claimed or not claimed pile.
Yes its possible, The Jk can block kills but as scum have no killed several times it will always be wifom whether they no killed again or not. So even that is an inactive (non investigative) power role.

Scum no killing means they either think/thought they have nothing to fear from the town PRs, or they kinda messed up and acted against wincon accidentally. OR they just love wifom? + some mumble mumble that I wont say.

Anyway my conclusion is we ought lynch the scummiest guy, rinse and repeat until the game ends.

So as for me Zakk has been the scummiest guy, lynch Zakk ftw.

Spoiler: zakks claim

If you are Zakk and a godfather, what do you claim when someone indicates, they may have role copped or tracked you.

Well if they were role cop with a check on you you can claim you are a

town Godfather

.. no wait what. Zakk knows they CANNOT have rolecopped Zakk if hes a GF.
So they(MS) are something else, (not role cop)
As Zakk in fact no killed the night before, the tracker part is easy tell the truth.
As they are not role cop, what else can they be? So claim backup RoleCop, so any gunsmith check would make sense.
and if it was all a bluff no worries. Just wifom that an extra useless backup rolecop was required for "balance".

There is nothing about Zakks claim that makes it unlikely he is godfather.
There is also nothing about the VT claims.

Ergo: Wanna lynch Zakk, dont wanna lynch Shadowez

[notscience]

VOTE: ika

[Metal Sonic]

VOTE: ika

[Metal Sonic]

UNVOTE:

[zakk]

Prodge

[Scorpious]

lol...

this game..

[zakk]

yeah i'm ready for it to be over but i don't want to take any responsibility to get it there. lol