Mini Normal 1719 - Flavorless Fun! [Game Over!]

[Hieirama]

Looks like a Dierfire + Hieirama scumteam. Now if only we can figure out the third...

You can build a scumread based on one post?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

VOTE: Dier

Wagon!

[Dwlee99]

Town read on BBT for being BBT. lol
I think implosion plays like I do offsite with tunnelling people and getting reads so I am town reading them, too.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Town read on Dwlee for town reading me.

[Dwlee99]

I'm waiting for someone to bring up meta so we can all stare at BBT's signature.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

In all seriousness though, are you actually town reading both implosion and myself?

[Dwlee99]

Yea, I actually am. Why would I say I am if I wasn't? I mean, my town read on you was kind of a joke but it still stands as a gut feeling.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

You accompanied it with an 'lol', hard to discern if you're joking or being serious. The fact you just mentioned it was 'kind of a joke' means you just answered your own question, no?

[Dwlee99]

You asked about my town read on you and implosion. The first part was more about implosion and the second part is about you. Even though it was "Kind of a joke" I'm still town reading you. (especially for your last few posts)

[mykonian]

VOTE: Dier

Wagon!

wrong one.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

It is?

[Dwlee99]

How can there be an incorrect RVS wagon?

[mykonian]

we could be out of rvs right now.

You know, why not.

Garmr already committed a scumtell trying to call someone town. There's no need for the word "honestly" there, it only makes sense from a point where scum is trying to think like town. The word "honestly" implies that he comes from a setting where he was prepared to lie this game, then found a situation where it wasn't necessary. Add to this that he's stepping in to protect someone from an accusation and that little sentence becomes quite damning. Buddying and at the same time showing off his mindset is scummy.

So dwlee, are we out of rvs?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

But you're voting Herrcombs...

[Dwlee99]

Okay, we're out of RVS. Fine.
But let's look at Garmr's ISO -
21 - RVS
24 - "Honestly don't see anything scummy so far"

Garmr already committed a scumtell trying to call someone town.

So saying he doesn't see anything scummy is a scum tell? Okay, totally.

[herrcombs]

Okay, we're out of RVS. Fine.
But let's look at Garmr's ISO -
21 - RVS
24 - "Honestly don't see anything scummy so far"

Garmr already committed a scumtell trying to call someone town.

So saying he doesn't see anything scummy is a scum tell? Okay, totally.

Why did you clip out the rest of what he said, about why it's a scumtell to him?

(Even though frankly, I don't agree with mykonian's premise... I don't think the phrase "to be honest" or its derivatives is alignment indicative, I've seen townies use the phrase and I tend to use it too out of habit.)

[herrcombs]

VOTE: bluewaffle

Because I like you

Wait... Who's bluewaffle? Did you mean BBT? Or are you voting someone who's not in this game?

[Keyser Söze]

mykonian's posts look like they're trying to provoke players (I do not see the town-motivation?):

ooooh someone is lying here. Fun!

Lynch all Liar's

I also wanted to flag Hieirama's reaction. I feel like implosion was joking about a 'Dierfire + Hieirama scumteam' - but Hieirama's jumps in acting very serious/defensive:

Looks like a Dierfire + Hieirama scumteam. Now if only we can figure out the third...

You can build a scumread based on one post?

Dwlee99 gives out two (serious?) easy/early town-reads (I do not like people giving out easy/early town/scum reads):

You asked about my town read on you and implosion

. The first part was more about implosion and the second part is about you. Even though it was "Kind of a joke" I'm still town reading you. (especially for your last few posts)

UNVOTE: BlueBloodedToffee
VOTE: Dwlee99

[Keyser Söze]

I do not understand this question :

what were you trying to do there, soze?

[Dwlee99]

My town read on implosion was serious, my one on BBT was more joke-y but based on his posts afterwards I'm town reading him. I don't understand how that makes me scum? You say that you don't like early town or scum reads but you don't flag implosion as suspicious although he did it even earlier than me.

I also wanted to flag Hieirama's reaction.

I feel like implosion was joking about a 'Dierfire + Hieirama scumteam'

- but Hieirama's jumps in acting very serious/defensive:

Looks like a Dierfire + Hieirama scumteam. Now if only we can figure out the third...

You can build a scumread based on one post?

Dwlee99

gives out two (serious?)

easy/early town-reads (I do not like people giving out easy/early town/scum reads):

You asked about my town read on you and implosion

. The first part was more about implosion and the second part is about you. Even though it was "Kind of a joke" I'm still town reading you. (especially for your last few posts)

UNVOTE: BlueBloodedToffee
VOTE: Dwlee99

Yea, no.
UNVOTE: Dierfire
VOTE: Keyser

Okay, we're out of RVS. Fine.
But let's look at Garmr's ISO -
21 - RVS
24 - "Honestly don't see anything scummy so far"

Garmr already committed a scumtell trying to call someone town.

So saying he doesn't see anything scummy is a scum tell? Okay, totally.

Why did you clip out the rest of what he said, about why it's a scumtell to him?

(Even though frankly, I don't agree with mykonian's premise... I don't think the phrase "to be honest" or its derivatives is alignment indicative, I've seen townies use the phrase and I tend to use it too out of habit.)

I clipped it out because the rest was gibberish about him saying the word "honestly". He did say some stuff about it being him buddying and "Add to this that he's stepping in to protect someone from an accusation and that little sentence becomes quite damning." but it's a weak case that relies on saying the word "honestly" being a scum tell, which, like you said, isn't one.

[Keyser Söze]

Garmr already committed a scumtell trying to call someone town

. There's no need for the word "honestly" there, it only makes sense from a point where scum is trying to think like town. The word "honestly" implies that he comes from a setting where he was prepared to lie this game, then found a situation where it wasn't necessary. Add to this that he's

stepping in to protect someone from an accusation

and that little sentence becomes quite damning.

Buddying and at the same time

showing off his mindset is scummy.

So dwlee, are we out of rvs?

Gamr didn't call anyone/someone town though:

Honestly don't see anything scummy so far

We were in RVS:

who is the "someone" you think he called town/was trying to buddy up with/stepping in to protect?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Dwlee is town.

[Dwlee99]

Now now, you shouldn't make "easy random town/scum reads".

[Felissan]

Looks like a lot has happened already.
VOTE: mykonian
I just don't get a town vibe from you, myko - let me do a breakdown of your ISO:
8: instead of starting straight away with a RVS, you question the flavor in Keyser's. Not starting with RVS is weird, questioning something as insignificant as the reason for a RVS is weird too. Nothing read-worthy by this point, still.
12 and 16: that's your RVS. A bit convoluted and arbitrary, but hey, that's a RVS.
20: you admit to your vote originally being a joke. That's perfectly normal. But then, you say "lolwut is going on" is a scum slip from herrcombs? I just don't get it.
34: you provoke BBT about not following on your wagon. Now that's just weird: the reasons behind a RVS aren't the kind of thing worth questioning, and that's the second time you do it. Again, not alignment-indicative, but giving me a scum vibe.
37: everyone's favorite post! You answer Dwlee who was saying it was too early to have an actual read, by showing him an "actual" reason for a read - but first, the reasoning behind that read just doesn't hold together (this post has already been shot down for that by Dwlee, herrcombs, Keyser - nothing to add to what they already told), and second, if you actually read Garmr for that, why would you keep your vote on herrcombs? Your vote on herrcombs was originally based on a joke and an ethereal scumslip, so how would that be less scummy than an actual point?

Before anything else, I have a few questions for you: what was the point asking people about RVS? What was herrcombs's scum slip? And also, everything ever said about 37.

[Hieirama]

I also wanted to flag Hieirama's reaction. I feel like implosion was joking about a 'Dierfire + Hieirama scumteam' - but Hieirama's jumps in acting very serious/defensive:

Looks like a Dierfire + Hieirama scumteam. Now if only we can figure out the third...

You can build a scumread based on one post?

I'm not very good at catching joking tones through text.
Hm, reads without good evidence concerns me.