Mini 1717 Alfred Hitchcock UPick [GAME OVER]

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

logical reasoning from sakura?

From what I understood it's not confirmed town.
We know he was targetted.
But Sakura said if he shot night 1 he maybe still guilty.

Maybe I misunderstood the role??

I'm also looking at Nacho as scum

You didn't misunderstand anything, that's exactly what it means, which is why i said, we can get guilties but not innos (dunno if i actually said that yesterday, but that is my impression of the role).

~Sakura

[Vedith]

So out of my scum reads of Cataphant, Pistachio and Ank two are voting for the others.

Yeah I can see a bussing technique going on here.

[farside22]

So out of my scum reads of Cataphant, Pistachio and Ank two are voting for the others.

Yeah I can see a bussing technique going on here.

Why anka?

[Davsto]

If I were to make an assumption on who scum was if they chose a Wingback kill for suspect reasons, I'd lean Cataphant or Concrete Angels.

[Vedith]

Because of his day 1. I still don't like the way he just tried to buddy around and agree any where. Most people seem to have ignored that part though.

[farside22]

If I were to make an assumption on who scum was if they chose a Wingback kill for suspect reasons, I'd lean Cataphant or Concrete Angels.

No way do I see CA as scum. I was pretty null with cats. I like bella when she isn't in a hydra and I can't read hippy he gets so lazy sometimes.

[farside22]

Because of his day 1. I still don't like the way he just tried to buddy around and agree any where. Most people seem to have ignored that part though.

I don't remember seeing that. I see him agreeing with others which is null.
Where did he buddy?

[Davsto]

Reason I'd assume those two going by the nightkill target is this...

Absolutely not. You need a lesson in reading comprehension. I asked you questions aimed at getting you to support your arguments. No where did I say they did or didn't do anything, nor did I say that I thought they did.

The way you phrased your questions looked like you were asking me to prove a negative.

This is also an error on your part - why are you unable to understand what I said there?

You said that whether or not I agree with their read on me was irrelevant. That wasn't my point. I said that their read of me looked fake.

Let me rephrase - You said they had no reads, then said they had a read. You saying they are right or wrong - that is irrelevant to the fact that the read exists, which was what I was getting at. You made a statement, I asked you to support it, and when you didn't do so satisfactorily, I asked you to explain further.

What I said was that they had no strong reads elsewhere besides Thor and they spent 90% of their time tunneling Thor instead of developing reads elsewhere. When asked for a readslist, they listed out a bunch of reads of which I felt that their read on me looked fake.

Not logging across, anti can deal with it. Go over wing and Thor with a fine toothed comb. Sakura's result tonight is trustworthy. JK, aim for scum. If you hit the ninja you're golden.

Not super disappointed about being the lynch, tbh. It was gonna be a struggle to keep my head in the game and I'm probably taking a break from mafia for a while, so...

And there's a clear reason I didnt full claim. I didn't want the scum to know who was the most valuable no target. Confirmable in less than 1 phase should be enough

Okay, so I was wrong on Lying Cat.

Cataphant is almost certainly scum. After that, I'd look at ETL.

However, I've just realised it could have been for his claim. I'm just gonna come out of my pitiful attempt at NKA with a null result. Worth a try.

[Vedith]

I don't remember seeing that. I see him agreeing with others which is null.
Where did he buddy?

In the early game. When he started to defend me with nothing to go on.
I mean, I've made a few posts over him in day 1.

What's your views on his votes, and his follow up on those votes?

[farside22]

Reason I'd assume those two going by the nightkill target is this...

Absolutely not. You need a lesson in reading comprehension. I asked you questions aimed at getting you to support your arguments. No where did I say they did or didn't do anything, nor did I say that I thought they did.

The way you phrased your questions looked like you were asking me to prove a negative.

This is also an error on your part - why are you unable to understand what I said there?

You said that whether or not I agree with their read on me was irrelevant. That wasn't my point. I said that their read of me looked fake.

Let me rephrase - You said they had no reads, then said they had a read. You saying they are right or wrong - that is irrelevant to the fact that the read exists, which was what I was getting at. You made a statement, I asked you to support it, and when you didn't do so satisfactorily, I asked you to explain further.

What I said was that they had no strong reads elsewhere besides Thor and they spent 90% of their time tunneling Thor instead of developing reads elsewhere. When asked for a readslist, they listed out a bunch of reads of which I felt that their read on me looked fake.

Not logging across, anti can deal with it. Go over wing and Thor with a fine toothed comb. Sakura's result tonight is trustworthy. JK, aim for scum. If you hit the ninja you're golden.

Not super disappointed about being the lynch, tbh. It was gonna be a struggle to keep my head in the game and I'm probably taking a break from mafia for a while, so...

And there's a clear reason I didnt full claim. I didn't want the scum to know who was the most valuable no target. Confirmable in less than 1 phase should be enough

Okay, so I was wrong on Lying Cat.

Cataphant is almost certainly scum. After that, I'd look at ETL.

I got where you were coming from. I'm a type that doesn't always look at what people say when they are killed.
There is so much WIFOM and I have been framed by it in the past.


However, I've just realised it could have been for his claim. I'm just gonna come out of my pitiful attempt at NKA with a null result. Worth a try.

I don't remember seeing that. I see him agreeing with others which is null.
Where did he buddy?

In the early game. When he started to defend me with nothing to go on.
I mean, I've made a few posts over him in day 1.

What's your views on his votes, and his follow up on those votes?

That isn't buddying. If you looked he was talking about the case on you. He thought it was crap (basically) because all it was based on was you not posting in the game.

I find his votes were pretty fluid. I don't know if Anka recalls us playing scum together but I recall he tends to hold his votes more on one player as scum and tunnel.
Plus Anka buddies way more as scum.

[farside22]

My comment to Dav is in his post.

I state:

I got where you were coming from. I'm a type that doesn't always look at what people say when they are killed.
There is so much WIFOM and I have been framed by it in the past.

[Ankamius]

I don't know if Anka recalls us playing scum together

Wait, what? Were you on an alt?

[farside22]

I don't know if Anka recalls us playing scum together

Wait, what? Were you on an alt?

No

[Ankamius]

I remember which one now. Never mind.

[Vedith]

Can I have a link to it?

[Ankamius]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?t=59850

[massive]

Phonereading. Getting on a plane in a min so it may not last.

[Vedith]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?t=59850

Fair enough... Although Persona 4 you were scum and did more or less the same thing as on here...

For now I'd like to
VOTE: Cataphant

[Ankamius]

How so?

[Vedith]

With the defending me as town posts in the game?

[Ankamius]

...So?

I don't qualify direct actions as good meta. Make a correlation between why I did it there and what I'm doing here, then we'll talk about it.

[Vedith]

That's fair enough, and the fact of your other scum game suggests otherwise anyway.
I'm not going to put you as town for it or any of your plays this game but I think looking at Cata or Pist will be more beneficial at this point for myself.

[Antihero]

Okay, we'll tell 'em, then. I can't read the rest of the speech I had, because the lights have gone out, so I'll just have to talk off the cuff. All that noise you hear isn't static - it's death, coming to London. Yes, they're coming here now. You can hear the bombs falling on the streets and the homes. Don't tune me out, hang on a while - this is a big story, and you're part of it. It's too late to do anything here now except stand in the dark and let them come... as if the lights were all out everywhere, except in America. Keep those lights burning, cover them with steel, ring them with guns, build a canopy of battleships and bombing planes around them. Hello, America, hang on to your lights: they're the only lights left in the world!

Foreign Correspondent

Vote Count 2.1

Cataphant - 3 (Thor665, Ankamius, Vedith)
pistachi0n - 3 (Davsto, Cataphant, farside22)

Not Voting: Concrete Angels, Hecatia Lapislazuli, massive, Nachomamma8, pistachi0n

6 to lynch
Deadline: (expired on 2015-11-04 17:52:11)

[Concrete Angels]

please don't quicklynch. I'd like to hear from everyone. thoughts on yesterday's lynch would be grand too. any ideas on the LC wagon specifically is what I'd like to hear.

[Concrete Angels]

^ ETL