Newbie 1656 : Game Over

[Sakura Hana]

your scumread on Ether

It's actually a leftover read based on my analysis, the reads are pretty much explained along all of my posts this day phase, the left over reads is the ones i haven't analysied yet.

[Sakura Hana]

In case it wasnt obvious Leftover =/= Scumread.

I'm analysis each people's posts and interactions from D1 and arranging them from most townie to least townie, with the exception of the first 3 which are pretty bunch bank townreads, once im done analysing, obviously the one that is the "least townie" out of all my reads will also likewise be the "most likely to be scum" and i'll probably vote it at that point.

[Sakura Hana]

Actually i guess i should've put moosy as not analyzed, i'll revise that later, i only put it there because i saw that post being unlikely to be done from a Roleblocker > Goon interaction, but what Ether said makes sense too.

[Sakura Hana]

In either case the rest of my analysis will have to happen tomorrow, it's getting late and stuff.

[Sakura Hana]

I just went and double checked the lordj wagon and...
Yeah literally both GM and Moosy voted lordj right after your case on lordj, i gotta admit it's hard to see anyone else as GM's partner, anyway, i'll see what i come up when i check overall interactions tomorrow, but im currently leaning on Moosy now too.

[SilverWolf]

IMO, lordj was a counterwagon to scum and is most likely town. I believe LoHa's claim and is most likely town. Sakura was pushing GM for a lot of the time and is a townread anyway. Ocean Wind I'm feeling better about due to GM push and overall a townread but not as strong. Ether is a townread but also not as strong. MightMandarin never voted but came off sort of townie and but not as strong again. MosyDosy voted lordj right after I said I would vote lord as a compromise. I think MosyDosy is GM's partner. There are a few things that were said by the person he replaced and by him that make me question that but that's my best guess.

Let's not quite L-1 yet thought until EVERYONE has had a chance to speak.

IF there's a jailkeeper, IMO I think it would be best if they told us who they jailed IF they were jailing someone who they think was scum. We can discuss this but this confirms LoHa as legitimate and means whoever they jailed is most likely scum due to being jailed. If you protected someone I'm less sure.

LoHa is still most likely town due to GM and Mosy (if scum) pushing for his lynch so hard.

[SilverWolf]

We should also ISO GM, Mosy and maybe a couple others to be sure but I have to go to work so not as sure on this.

[SilverWolf]

We should also ISO GM, Mosy and maybe a couple others to be sure but I have to go to work

so not as sure on this.

so don't have time right now

EBWOP

Also, let everyone speak before hammering please or even L-1ing.

I think we will win regardless but no need to rush it.

[LoHa]

@Mod: Hello. Thank you for stepping in.

IF there's a jailkeeper, IMO I think it would be best if they told us who they jailed IF they were jailing someone who they think was scum. We can discuss this but this confirms LoHa as legitimate and means whoever they jailed is most likely scum due to being jailed. If you protected someone I'm less sure.

I agree. We should play to our strengths with two PR innocent children (I'm most likely still bulletproof), and try to perfect win this.

[MoosyDoosy]

Meh, me being around will just be a distraction later down the line so it's best to get me over with as fast as possible. :3

VOTE: MoosyDoosy

[MoosyDoosy]

Oh shoot, well killing me may be a bad idea lol.

This puts me in an awkward spot. I may or may not have extended night for all of us by accident. >.<

[MoosyDoosy]

Wait was there no night kill?

[MoosyDoosy]

ok lol no night kill is really strange then. Mafia probably just didn't kill anyone or they went after LoHa. Are there notifications if bulletproof vest is used?

[MoosyDoosy]

Meh, whatever.

I'm hard claiming Town Jailkeeper. I completely forgot my role tbh and didn't use it lol. Which makes no sense considering there was no night kill. This either means Mafia gave up and didn't kill or they targeted LoHa. mmm...but does LoHa get a notification if bulletproof vest is used?

[MoosyDoosy]

Can the Mafia Roleblocker kill if they use their action? mmm...that's the only set up that's possible if LoHa is bulletproof person.

Wow I just realized LoHa should have been confirmed town to me earlier through set up knowledge but I never checked the OP properly. eh. :/

[MoosyDoosy]

Actually, this makes no difference. This should be really simple for town to figure out if there's only one Mafia left. Continue with the lynch~~

[SilverWolf]

JFC If you are the JK then unvote and help us catch the last scum.

If there is a cc do it now.

[Sakura Hana]

@All the questions: No Bulletproof is not notified if they get shot, Yes mafia roleblocker can do both actions:

You share a factional kill each night. You must choose which of you will commit the kill. Y

ou may commit the kill and perform a roleblock in the same night phase.

From the sample role PMs.

[MoosyDoosy]

I mean, gut reaction says that it's probably someone voting for me. So....OceanWind, Mightymandarin, lordj210, Ether.

mmm...out of these four, the person who looks worse off is Mightmandarin.

[LoHa]

Meh, whatever.

I'm hard claiming Town Jailkeeper. I completely forgot my role tbh and didn't use it lol. Which makes no sense considering there was no night kill. This either means Mafia gave up and didn't kill or they targeted LoHa.

If that is the case the last mafia is probably lordj or Mandaring. They seem to be the only ones noobish enough to do such a thing.

[OceanWind]

This makes things a bit harder. I thought the game was in the bag but someone's playing well as scum.

UNVOTE: MoosyDoosy
VOTE: Lordj

My townread here is the weakest. Everyone who were voting Lordj is a townread, claimed JK, or was the counterwagon and there were also a lot of people willing to switch either way (SilverWolf, Sakura). GoodMorning and Lordj crossvoting isn't out of the question and scum-scum wagons are good for scum to get them out of a sticky situation if both are caught.

[Ether]

No counterclaim. Anyone who's either a tracker or jailkeeper should speak up now.

unvote

I'm still in the "lordj or Mightymandarin" camp too. I don't think lordj being the counterwagon really means anything, since goodmorning made no effort to even vote him until the wagon was already in front of her, when he and LoHa were supposedly her top scum reads. And Mightymandarin's vote today still just feels weird to me.

I should reread if there are no counterclaims and I suddenly have a splitting 1 in the afternoon headache, so that's fun.

[MoosyDoosy]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Mightymandarin

Just for the counterwagon.

[SilverWolf]

I actually withdraw my statement that lordj is the counterwagon to scum because I saw it in my last newbie IC game where we called one guy town most of the game for being a scum counterwagon and they both turned out to be scum. I question whether GM would vote him though considering if lordj is scum, he's the RBer and she was just a goon.

I'm gonna have to ISO GM and lordj together. I don't think I'm gonna get anything from MightyMandarin since he didn't vote at all.

Moosy-The fact that you tried to lynch LoHa after his claim was really bad considering your role. You should of jailed who you thought was the other scum last night instead of doing nothing. It's annoying.

If scum shot LoHa which they clearly did, then they don't have much experience because LoHa is a BP and it's not a very good shot.

I'll have to think about this a bit.

[Sakura Hana]

I still doubt Lordj's scum, GM's vote came in too quick after the case that looks more like a mislynch opportunistic vote.