Mini 1725 - Game Over

[Aristophanes]

I just realized that we are in a good position if we NL!

Scum can't kill me because it will confirm that I was right about Makara.
This frees me up to get another track in tonight, meaning we may get a second success by tomorrow!
We should then be able to solve the game and win!

I want to lynch caught scum today, but the town is split and there is no way we're gonna get all 5 votes on him.

VOTE: No Lynch

[Firesong]

I can't decide between Ari and Makara.

I believe this is hammer, then.

VOTE: No Lynch

[ChaosOmega]

Votecount 3.04

Aristophanes (2) - makara, Maxous
makara (1) - supercool898

No Lynch (5) - Soapbar, Nosferatu, MarioManiac4, Aristophanes, Firesong

Not Voting (0) -

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2015-11-10 11:15:57)

No one was lynched day 3.

It is now Night 3. The deadline for Night 3 is exactly 2 days from this post, or in (expired on 2015-11-04 09:45:12).

[ChaosOmega]

No one died night 3.

It is now Day 4. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. The deadline for Day 4 is exactly 2 weeks from this post, or in (expired on 2015-11-18 10:02:25).

Searching for a replacement for makara.

[Nosferatu]

knew a tracker claim wouldn't go well. Should've no lynched with no one claiming.

[Soapbar]

So, uh, about that Bodyguard claim yesterday:

I have received confirmation from the mod that my bulletproof modifier will go into effect if I protect someone.

The reason I thought otherwise was because the role PM states that I am immune to killing abilities, but it didn't say the kill would be re-directed onto me, it just said I would die.

Unless a Doc or Jailkeeper claims, I'm positive Aristo is scum

VOTE: Aristophanes

[MarioManiac4]

@Soapbar; why? What do you think makara would have done, but nokill?
I don't actually think much has changed for me

[Nosferatu]

I think both makara and aristo are both town.

If scum has a 1-shot strongman and used it on RC n1, it would have gone through makara's protection and wouldn't have notified him. They also would have no killed last night to protect themself from a possible track from aristo. Her claim is too odd to be a fakeclaim. If she really wanted to fake claim, she would've chosen something like a vanilla cop, something she can easily get away with. A protecting PR targeting a dead players as a fake claim doesn't seem logical. It's way too suspicious.

I think a massclaim is appropriate at this time.

[MarioManiac4]

I think both makara and aristo are both town.

If scum has a 1-shot strongman and used it on RC n1, it would have gone through makara's protection and wouldn't have notified him. They also would have no killed last night to protect themself from a possible track from aristo. Her claim is too odd to be a fakeclaim. If she really wanted to fake claim, she would've chosen something like a vanilla cop, something she can easily get away with. A protecting PR targeting a dead players as a fake claim doesn't seem logical. It's way too suspicious.

I think a massclaim is appropriate at this time.

The only problem with that is makara claimed he never used the action.
I think we're all going to claim VT.

[supercool898]

I think both makara and aristo are both town.

If scum has a 1-shot strongman and used it on RC n1, it would have gone through makara's protection and wouldn't have notified him. They also would have no killed last night to protect themself from a possible track from aristo. Her claim is too odd to be a fakeclaim. If she really wanted to fake claim, she would've chosen something like a vanilla cop, something she can easily get away with. A protecting PR targeting a dead players as a fake claim doesn't seem logical. It's way too suspicious.

I think a massclaim is appropriate at this time.

I think either makara or aristo has to be scum. If makara is town, then he wouldn't have targeted RC (otherwise he would have lived) and aristo wouldn't vote him making aristo scum. If aristo is town, then makara with his current claim would be lying, making makara scum.

Honestly, I have started watching makara and aristo's gameplay instead of judging by claim solely at this point. I think I might still be on aristo's side right now, since he immediately voted makara in his first post upon replacing in, but I'm still less sure than I felt before.

[Soapbar]

@Soapbar; why? What do you think makara would have done, but nokill?
I don't actually think much has changed for me

Read what I fucking posted. His role is essentially a doctor going by the name of bodyguard. Considering that scum have no reason at all to no-kill, Makara is town and Aristo is scum.

[Aristophanes]

@Soapbar; why? What do you think makara would have done, but nokill?
I don't actually think much has changed for me

Read what I fucking posted. His role is essentially a doctor going by the name of bodyguard. Considering that scum have no reason at all to no-kill, Makara is town and Aristo is scum.

Except that a No Kill allows Makaraslot to claim they made a successful protection

and

"confirms" their target as town. This is an optimal move for fakeclaiming scum if you ask me.
It also stagnates the game, keeping it at Mylo without giving any extra flip info.

I tracked Super because I suspect there was scum on the wagon with me yesterday, banking on a No lynch to gain townpoints for endgame when we do get a Makara Scumflip.
Of course, I got the message that they didn't target anyone, as scum didn't make a kill. So it was essentially useless for me.

Nos, I wish I could just agree that both of us are town and move on, but there is no way, with the given claims, that we are. One of us has to be scum.
I also think that a massclaim is required either today or D5.

Regardless,
VOTE: Makara
The no kill just goes to reinforce their scumminess.

[Nosferatu]

uhh, maybe scum no killed because of a fucking tracker claim

[ChaosOmega]

Hinduragi replaces makara.

[Firesong]

Hi, Hinduragi!

Bad news, I know that you're scum. Ari tracked the Doc/Bodyguard Makara to the dead RC. If Makara was roleblocked, then she never would have gone to RC,

she would have been blocked at home

.

VOTE: Hinduragi

[Nosferatu]

VOTE: Hinduragi
after thinking over it, if aristo was scum trying to deceive town, he'd probably claim cop over tracker, so I'll believe his claim over makara's.

[ChaosOmega]

Votecount 4.01

Hinduragi (3) - Aristophanes, Firesong, Nosferatu
Aristophanes (1) - Soapbar

Not Voting (4) - MarioManiac4, supercool898, Hinduragi, Maxous

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2015-11-18 10:02:25)

[Hinduragi]

Guys, I have class to get to right now but I have just woken up and seen my role pm. PLEASE UNVOTE. This slot is town. We will lose the game. Please give me time and I will come back. There's no reason to pile on a wagon as lose the game. Anyone trying to lynch me AS I REPLACE INTO THE GAME is scum or dumb. Seriously man, what the fuck? Who does that? Town should at least hear me out. Scum have only motivation to see me dead right now before I've even posted. I will be back and I will be able to give you my thoughts on the game and they will be detailed. Extremely detailed.

[Nosferatu]

you've piqued my interest.

UNVOTE: Hinduragi

[Nosferatu]

L-3 now

[Hinduragi]

Quick update: I've been skimming over my role and this past page while doing my physics homework so I can focus on putting everything down in a post. The dead town QT must be rolling over in their graves after what's happened since N2. I'll fill you all in with my post but this game is pretty black and white right now. There isn't any gray space in this Day 4 and I'm pretty confident we can get this thing down to Day 6 at the least. Just be calm and think about what you're about to do before you do it with these next few days we'll have coming up. This is crunch time.

[Hinduragi]

Oh, and whatever happens, noone else should claim at this point. Noone. Claim. We have a 100% chance of lynching scum right now. I'll be back after I calculate index of refractions, electromagnetic interference, and concave+convex lens problems.

[Hinduragi]

Hey, if you're reading this post and you're in this game, you need to be posting. Like right now. We can turn this game around but everyone needs to be posting and putting in input even while I'm putting my post together. I understand this is during normal work hours and school hours but please post when you check in.

[MarioManiac4]

Hello! I'm here to talk. I have a scumread on your slot because makara not using any action seems scummy, and I don't get why makara wouldn't have asked about her role

before

being questioned on it.
I've also had a townread on supercool all game and it's impossible for me, him and you to all be town.

[Nosferatu]

I will be back and I will be able to give you my thoughts on the game and they will be detailed. Extremely detailed.

Waiting for this ^