In post 92, Slaughterhouse Five wrote: In post 5, IceGuy wrote:Since we can't really do RVS, let's discuss strategy.
To me, it seems like our best bet would be to go into night after every lynch at first, because it's unlikely four or three Mafia will all choose the same player, and we gain more information that way. When we're down to two Mafia, nightkills are more of a risk, so we just lynch until the game ends.
It also seems far more entertaining to lynch everyone except for the TOP TWO TOWNIES or even just lynch a bunch of people until we think everyone is town and then see how well we did. I also don't see the benefit of your plan even - every time we lynch and don't go to night it's like mafia missed a nightkill; I mean I guess associatives are nice but not even giving them the chance to make a kill seems better for our wincon and for our souls.
The thing is that there isn't a way for an early nightkill to happen without town being able to go back and find who crumbed the kill. Trading town for scum is good early so all flipping early does is give town more information since it isn't worth it for scum to go for early nightkills.
In post 17, Espeonage wrote:I feel like assessing our flips is an important part of play as we need to see how many scum we have dead, for both relational tells and to give us our next number of lynches number.
Why?
I don't need to see how many scum have died, I just need to stop scumreading people.
And if I've stopped scumreading people, then I start lynching the least town or offer myself up for death and I'm pretty fine with that actually.
Also fun!!!!!!
This I 100% disagree with. From what I have seen the first lynch of game is 50/50 a mislynch, but the way the game goes afterwards changes dramatically on whether the lynch was successful or not.
This vote sucked!!!
Maybe we can kill you first :]
What, there was no other possible vote there. Because a few guilty votes could lead to a lynch, town has to vote inno and mafia also does. Everyone is going to vote inno there so the accusation was dumb since it provided no information. Why was my vote bad?
In post 51, Randomnamechange wrote:I agree we should only lynch once today. The chances of scum making an NK are so low that we don't really sacrifice anything in return for having a flip before the next lynch.
Except a chance at scum making a kill and a chance to make history.
You are still wrong here.
In post 74, itlepip wrote:VOTE: Rushing
I feel like they are focusing way to much on the pokemon gimmick when they started to get questioned.
This also totally doesn't make sense :/
[/quote]
Meant to be an RVS vote but since someone scum slipped I no longer care.