Mini 1717 Alfred Hitchcock UPick [GAME OVER]

[Nachomamma8]

I was thinking of character claiming because as I said my role said there was a character in the game that could commute and I wondered if the player was scum because I couldn't do it if that player did it.

You're going to have to give us details because now that we know that the "other commuter" is Norman, it lines up that you're Mother and that's not a good thing.

I townread Massive and even so I'm surprised with the strength of support he's getting now.

As normally I'm a prime candidate for a mislynch around D2-3, I'm just as surprised as you are. For whatever reason, scum have been afraid of pushing me ... or possibly happy to leave me be? But that's not something to really dig into today.

Why, it's you pick?
Characters mean nothing.

Nacho: I'm confused by your claim. Your modified backup but didn't do anything to get the info on hoot?
Is that right?

Yep.

[hiplop]

davsto/thor = lynch candidates IMO

davesto been coasting so fucking hard

thor is just so scummy.

either is fine with me, I don't want nacho dead.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

I'm a neighborizor with the ability to shoot the person I neighborize on the following night, or anytime thereafter. N1 I neighborized massive because MS and I both thought he was scum and if he was, that he'd be a difficult lynch to achieve. After talking with him in the hood I've determined without a doubt that he is town.

N2 I neighborized Thor for the same reason I did massive - think he's scum and would be a difficult lynch to achieve. I told him in the PT exactly what my role/ability was and that I plan to shoot him tonight.

I agree that davsto is a good candidate to be Thor's partner. I became suspicious about dav after N1 when he did not die, over wingback. A kill that made absolutely no sense with a claimed JK.

That is why I didn't want to waste a lynch on Thor today.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Dav is only scum if Nacho is town, by the way, which is another reason I felt lynching Nacho would be good information, no matter what he flipped. The associatives between Nacho/pistachio were strong in my opinion, but after the discussion today I'm thinking he's maybe town.

[Ankamius]

Is the neighborhood open at all times or only at night?

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Is the neighborhood open at all times or only at night?

all the time.

[Ankamius]

I have to go back to work soon, but I'll get to making a list of people I'd be okay with lynching now thast this new info on the table.

I imagine the list will be pretty short, and even then, Davsto will probably be the only reasonable one.

[Davsto]

I became suspicious about dav after N1 when he did not die, over wingback

I mean Hecatia didn't die N1 and she was a goddamn investigative role but sure, drink that wine.

[Davsto]

davesto been coasting so fucking hard

[hiplop]

VOTE: davsto

[Davsto]

Go home, hiplop, you're drunk.

[massive]

Why, it's you pick?
Characters mean nothing.

Because Anti's obviously done his homework and done a very good job matching the roles that ultimately we received with the characters we play. Whether you want to argue that specific characters can't be scum simply because it's U-Pick, that's fine, but I'm more curious who you picked that lines up as a half-commuter better than Norma / Mother, who we know impacted Norman's commuting. And I'm willing to help you reveal that.

VOTE: farside

[massive]

Also, Judy Barton as a post-death backup is sheer genius.

[Nachomamma8]

Ah. That explains a lot.

Vote: Davesto

[Davsto]

Okay, Nacho, questions about your claim:

Before a lynch? Is that before the lynch actually happens or is it at twilight?
What happens if you backup a non-town player?
How would you inspect to a Flavour Cop after Backuping?

If you're actually telling the truth (I don't buy it for the record):
Would it work on an Ascetic (because if you're lynching me I sure as hell want the Jailkeeper to stay in the game because it's a goddamn good role and I ain't losing it just because you guys can't find actual scum)?

Also, can people stop just voting me with no reason and give a reason that isn't WIFOM or coasting? Because basically all of the reasons so far have been WIFOM and coasting.

[Davsto]

Actually

Fuckit

Jailkeeper's a powerful PR, giving it Ascetic so that the Backup can't keep it in the game makes perfect fucking sense for balance

I- goddammit

UNVOTE:

[Davsto]

Like I was thinking "man that seems awfully swingy when we've got a Jailkeeper and all" and then thought "wait shit ascetic" and blargh

[Davsto]

Man, I'm not sure what to think now, previously I was hella suspicious of Nacho and thought he was scum but his role actually gives a good reason for me to be ascetic (because I doubt the existence of a protective because I'm already JK) so now I'm super conflicted.

[massive]

Also, can people stop just voting me with no reason and give a reason that isn't WIFOM or coasting? Because basically all of the reasons so far have been WIFOM and coasting.

Coasting sounds like an awful fine reason to vote you. (Your role claim is basically the only thing keeping you alive right now -- or do you not remember we almost lynched you D1?) Directing our actual investigative role doesn't hurt either, and you being scum and knowing Hecatia was following your lead gives you a pretty good reason to not have to kill her N1.

[Nachomamma8]

Before a lynch? Is that before the lynch actually happens or is it at twilight?
What happens if you backup a non-town player?
How would you inspect to a Flavour Cop after Backuping?

Before a lynch happens.
I get their role except I'm still town.
Judy Barton.

[Nachomamma8]

And yes, it works on an Ascetic.

[Nachomamma8]

I don't understand why voting you for coasting is unacceptable; if I remember correctly, your vote on me was for coasting + some pistach reasons, correct?

[Davsto]

knowing Hecatia was following your lead gives you a pretty good reason to not have to kill her N1.

And yet was a good enough reason for me to kill her N2?

[Davsto]

I don't understand why voting you for coasting is unacceptable; if I remember correctly, your vote on me was for coasting + some pistach reasons, correct?

I mean I think it was gut and the convenient timing of the nightkill, I don't think I expanded on it.

[Davsto]

And yes, it works on an Ascetic.

Okay well that eliminates my reasoning for thinking you're town. Onwards and upwards!

VOTE: Nachomamma8