In post 3107, Spiffeh wrote:Setup spec won me a game here soooooo yes it is a valid argument.
It doesn't make sense for all three of jailkeeper bomb and bp exist.
Actually it sort of does. Have you looked at the powers on the scum team flips? They had a vanilla cop (I believe that tells them whether someone has a role or not?), and a Ninja ... that we've seen.
There's also two people killing every night, who have never targeted the same targets. That's like bordering on absurd and making me a little paranoid, and I
really
think we should be assuming SK over vig for safety.
I'm not willing to bet the game on setup spec, especially when our utility potentially forces these two killers to end up
not
producing two bodies should we have a (presumed) SK in play, meaning that today can't end the game no matter what. Unless my count is off, I believe tomorrow is when you paranoia lynch us. Otherwise let us do our thing. There's enough information now, especially now that we can re-evaluate with the mason pairing known, that we might be able to actually hand you scum on a silver platter.
This is the part of the game where Cerb and I nail it.
The way I see it, we should be looking for a scum who has been among those running the town and we need to be looking for signs of an SK. I don't like the constant assumption of Vig that permeates the posts of a lot of now known townies. It's an assumption and I've seen that kind of assumption torpedo really good town games before.
And sorry I left my sig off a couple posts. We were posting back and forth quickly for a moment there. I personally need to sleep. Consider what I'm saying because we've been honest all game and just defaulting on us isn't going to work. This needs to be figured out, and that starts with throwing out assumptions and reviewing things with updated prior assumptions;
especially
since we had masons and their interactions now have a proper context.
I was actually suspecting Kthxbye yesterday, which makes me feel dumb, because I intentionally look for town crumbing to help me figure out the game, and I didn't catch a thing from either of them. Usually I'm really good at it and it helps a lot in figuring out who is town which makes POE so much easier.
Anyway, I'm rambling because I'm tired. Cerb is in a different timezone so he may show up. I've left him a note so we can get together before our DnD game tomorrow and re-evaluate (assuming I can pry his attention away from Fallout 4 ... *sigh*).
~Drixx
