Mini 1738: Original Mafia (Day)

[Firebringer]

nacho ill buy as town

you im not sold 100%on

You look 10 x scummier than Aj, you realize that right?
All you do is say "Lynch" and "I am town" the last few pages are awful.
If yo uwere contributing it must have been earlier in the game.

The shit I have seen since replacingi n, is crap.

[Aj The Epic]

Sun could be the best play now. I think we can rid ourselves of that slot without costing anything to us.

However, I think taking out Itle, hip, fire, sun wins the game. Unless Nacho has any strong belief for these players?

This is like 4 god damn players, how you plan on doing this?

Here I thought Aj was the most reasonable looking player in the game, now I am worried.

Way the game works is we can lynch on out to 2 people without ever going to night.

[IceGuy]

VOTE: Yes

I don't see anything that would've changed my opinion.

Note that I'm currently trying to decide whether Aj is town trying to lead town, or scum trying to lead town right into disaster. I feel like he was very helpful in the beginning but his hiplop case was pretty obviously bad and I don't like how he's trying to line up lynches.

[Firebringer]

I say we go through with Aj plan since he is my strongest town read.

Might as well, since I am definitely getting lynched anyway.

also
@Ice Guy Hiplpo has done nothing to look town and I don't know how you can say his case on hiplop is inherently bad.

[IceGuy]

@Ice Guy Hiplpo has done nothing to look town and I don't know how you can say his case on hiplop is inherently bad.

He called him scum for mentioning Jingle twice. Aj mentioned Jingle twice, too.

[hiplop]

@Ice Guy Hiplpo has done nothing to look town and I don't know how you can say his case on hiplop is inherently bad.

He called him scum for mentioning Jingle twice. Aj mentioned Jingle twice, too.

his case/push on me is shit

im not even close to the same category of "lurker" as he places everyone else?

[Firebringer]

I am hating the semantics bullshit of the arguments right now guys.

[hiplop]

semantics on the word lurker? or?

[Firebringer]

semantics on the word lurker? or?

Lurker.

[sun_danyun]

Considering I got one person who said they would innocent me so I could catch up, Yeah. No.

You guys are lynching me because I won't catch up.
I won't catch up because you are lynching me.

See the problem?

We both are at fault here, the difference is I won't do what you tell me to do just because you gun to my head.

I can be more cooperative if I had less threats of me being lynched.

You kinda gave up when only two people were voting you, in 598. How was it not still worth going through the thread at that point, or at least skimming it? Giving up so early does not convince people that they should not lynch you. Giving up

at all

doesn't convince people, because it's such an anti-town thing to do. If you're really town, at least give more opinions on other players and relationships, because it may be useful later ("Well, fire said so-and-so looked scummy and so-and-so looked town, and he ended up being town, so" etc etc). Currently you're only responding to how people are acting

right now

, and without any context because you won't read the thread. Now that I think about it though, if you are scum it might make sense to give up; like a precaution to make sure you don't accidentally lead town to find your buddies if you feel that you are about to be lynched.

But dangit guys, if we lynch fire right now and the next day reveals that town and scum were lynched, we won't be able to... am I the only one still saying this?

Note that I'm currently trying to decide whether Aj is town trying to lead town, or scum trying to lead town right into disaster.

This is more or less why I want to be sure that we will know what the alignment of each and every person lynched is until there is only one scum left.

And not just for reading AJ, but for reading everybody.

[Aj The Epic]

Because we aren't going to night.

Also fire isn't scum. The last two is hiplop, itle.

[itlepip]

Because we aren't going to night.

Also fire isn't scum. The last two is hiplop, itle.

case please.

[Aj The Epic]

Ain't no case needed. Sun is town. Ergo, you're scum.

[Firebringer]

Now that I think about it though, if you are scum it might make sense to give up; like a precaution to make sure you don't accidentally lead town to find your buddies if you feel that you are about to be lynched.

It also makes sense from a town point of view anyways.
The number of times I give a "catch up post"
Then final 'reads' post.

And number of times they are either ignored or called bad, is pretty much 1-1.

So, I don't see the point in investing the time into it. You want to call me scum for that fine, but stop framing it like "I don't understand why Town would do this"

[hiplop]

death in family might be a little more absent than usual for a few days. will try to still post if i can

[IceGuy]

Firebringer, stop trolling and start posting constructively.

[Firebringer]

Firebringer, stop trolling and start posting constructively.

Let me refer you to this game:
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=83&t=63678

[IceGuy]

Can you present a game where you were scum and didn't play like that?

[Firebringer]

Here is me replacing into a slot:
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=55&t=63181

[IceGuy]

From a quick read, the play style fits.

[Firebringer]

From a quick read, the play style fits.

Well then I must be lynched then <3

[GuyInFreezer]

VC

[Aj The Epic]

Nacho really needs to chime in so we can discuss which of Sun/Fire or Hiplop/Itle he's less sure about.

[Slaughterhouse Five]

Fire's posting has been acceptable enough to back off for now; Itlepip was a scumread much earlier in the game but has been a pretty strong townread for a while now, I liked hiplop push on Firebringer but I'm not sure it convinces me of a strong townread there.

Give me a little time to go through ISOs when I come home tonight.

[Aj The Epic]

My thinking is if we're accepting Ice for town, then it's a pretty clear divide (Hip/Itle being willing to jump on this fire wagon super hard, Sun being much more reserved [and obviously fire not liking it]).

It actually kinda fits Itle's overreaction to Randommidget earlier.