Blitz 16: Blitz Greatest Idea Mafia(GAME OVER)

[Jackal711]

So this has started...

VOTE: RC
Policy.

My first draw was:

Mafia Bus Driver
Mafia Private Investigator
Rolecop

Of which I picked Mafia Rolecop.

Retract this or I consider it grounds to policy you in return.

Go ahead, considering you shouldn't be in this game at all

[Smithereens]

@smithers I called persivul scum and voted him. I see you don't let reality bother you either.

I don't recall seeing a scum read from you. After reading your ISO I still don't see a scum read from you.

[RadiantCowbells]

Game started before that happened *shrug*

[lane0168]

I'm down.

VOTE: Jackal

VOTE: jackal

What is this? Explain yourselves

[RadiantCowbells]

I don't see how you wouldn't understand it by reading the context of the thread.

[RadiantCowbells]

At least for my part the vote isn't entirely policy.

I get bad vibes from his post.

[Wednesday_]

@smithers I called persivul scum and voted him. I see you don't let reality bother you either.

I don't recall seeing a scum read from you. After reading your ISO I still don't see a scum read from you.

The intent is fairly clear from my post how did you interpret trying to blend in and my vote following? Or are you sincerely that blind?

[Jackal711]

Game started before that happened *shrug*

Maybe so. But there's instances of the same behavior already in this game.

My vote will remain where it is until I have a reason to move it.

[RadiantCowbells]

Game started before that happened *shrug*

Maybe so. But there's instances of the same behavior already in this game.

My vote will remain where it is until I have a reason to move it.

I'm perfectly happy with everything I've said this game.

If you care to point out a post I've made that you have a problem with and explain what your problem is, I'd be happy to assist you.

[RadiantCowbells]

Oh, I didn't realize I said "fucking great great great great granddaddy", so you have somewhat of a point there.

[lane0168]

I don't see how you wouldn't understand it by reading the context of the thread.

Ok. You moved your vote off of someone that you liked my scum read for, to someone you want to policy lynch for wanting to policy lynch you. Brilliant

Doesn't explain Wednesday

[lane0168]

At least for my part the vote isn't entirely policy.

I get bad vibes from his post.

How could I know you get bad vibes by reading the context of the thread? Cause I didn't

[RadiantCowbells]

She's sheeping me.

*feeds sheep grass*

[BlackStar]

At least for my part the vote isn't entirely policy.

I get bad vibes from his post.

How could I know you get bad vibes by reading the context of the thread? Cause I didn't

What's his face jumped on the wagon and his excuse was just that it was a policy lynch. Then RC voted to lynch him because that was a poor excuse. It's not hard to understand

[Ranger]

Reading:
{Smithereens, Wednesday}
{Frozen Angel, Flubbernugget}
{davesaz}
{BlackStar, lane0168}
{RadiantCowbells}
{Persivul, Starbuck}
{Almost50}

And yours were...

Didn't have the time to look during my lunch break. But I was looking not for the cards themselves, because frankly I don't get card interaction dynamics, but rather, which combinations you got. Mine were Town Two-shot Coroner, Town Watcher (what I picked), Town One-shot Kingmaker, Mafia One-shot Kingmaker, and Mafia two-shot Coroner.

Was extremely disappointed that got discarded, and incredibly miffed most of the stronger roles I could pick on the reshuffle were scum. (As a result, to be town, I got stuck with something weak.)

What do you expect to see from reveal of the 1st set of cards?

If people tell what they selected at the very least (but preferably every combo they could get), then assuming everyone's telling the truth, we'll know why the setup could not be generated. If someone lies, then we'll know that there's a liar and that will be useful information to have.

[Ranger]

...Somehow, Jackal has a

nasty

habit of escaping my readslist.
Place him below BlackStar and lane, but above RadiantCowbells.

[Frozen Angel]

{Smithereens, Wednesday}

why?

[Ranger]

why?

Smithereens popped out immediately and said some extremely town things.
Wednesday's discard looks good for Wednesday, but that's not the real reason Wednesday's there; Wednesday stole my shtick and produced some content that was incredibly town in mindset.

Also, I'm looking at things right now claim-wise, and I've got this:
Ranger--Town Watcher
Frozen Angel--Town Rolecop
Smithereens--Town Cop

RadiantCowbells--Survivor Doctor
Persivul--Survivor Captain
davesaz--Mafia Commuter
Almost50--Werewolf Jailkeeper
Jackal711--Mafia Rolecop

BlackStar--Chose Clairvoyant; no second pick.
(So, town?)
lane0168--Chose jailkeeper; no second pick.
(So, town?)

Wednesday--??
Flubbernugget--??
Starbuck--??

I still want answers from everyone here.

[Ranger]

Also,
VOTE: Almost50.

[Frozen Angel]

I think they meant town Clairvoyant and town jailkeeper

[davesaz]

Reading:
{Smithereens, Wednesday}
{Frozen Angel, Flubbernugget}
{davesaz}
{BlackStar, lane0168}
{RadiantCowbells}
{Persivul, Starbuck}
{Almost50}

I'd be interested to hear what you saw from Smithereens and Starbuck.

[Ranger]

Smithereens immediately posted strongly town things.
Starbuck immediately tripped my radar as being suspicious. It felt like what a scum her would have been like in Mafiaception had she been there from the beginning. Furthermore, there's her discard: Hider is an incredibly strong town role, but an incredibly dangerous, borderline-worthless scum role, especially in a setup like this where there can be multiple kills flying around per night and redirections are possible and there can be up to five players hiding behind that would get a scum hider killed.

[Ranger]

To put things in perspective:

1. Frozen Angel - Survivor
3. Smithereens - Werewolf Roleblocker
4. Wednesday_ - Mafia Jailkeeper
8. Ranger - Werewolf
10. lane0168 - Cult Leader

These are all pro-town discards. Frozen Angel and lane less so than the others, since it's discarding third party rather than scum, but still show they are not as interested in playing that type of role.

5. Starbuck - Hider
6. Radiant Cowbells - Bodyguard
11. BlackStar - Cop

These are examples of pro-scum discards: Bodyguard is a useless scum role, but a great town role. Hider is a very powerful town role, but a useless scum role.

I don't really need to talk about Cop, however, I buy BlackStar's posting, that it was essentially accidental and not intended.

The other discards are fairly null, as there are reasons not to want them as either town OR scum.

[Ranger]

Also, I think I want to update my list.
{Smithereens, Wednesday, Frozen Angel}
{Flubbernugget, davesaz}
{BlackStar, lane0168}
{Jackal711}
{RadiantCowbells}
{Persivul, Starbuck}
{Almost50}

I'm almost willing to move BlackStar and lane up a tier, but I need a little more from them to be sure.

[Ranger]

I'd be interested to hear what you saw from Smithereens and Starbuck.

Speaking of things that are interesting...
Why those two specifically?

You don't hold interest in Almost50, Persivul, and RadiantCowbells reads? Is that because you understand their placing?

'Cause if so...would totally love support on the Almost50 wagon.