Mini 1749: Classic Rock Mafia: Game Over!

[Albert B. Rampage]

Is it iraonavp?

[davesaz]

so like no one is interested in the fact I have day chat now with a potential scum power role ok then.

You're saying someone neighborized you and Matt, and you now have daychat with that player? Or was there a hood already that you got added to?
How would you know that Matt became a member? Is that based solely on what the other neighbor told you?

[RadiantCowbells]

Classic Rock Mafia:

Votecount #2.42:

Firebringer (2): Dierfire, Albert B. Rampage
Aeronaut (1): Firebringer
AlwaysInnocent (1): Aj The Epic
Dierfire (0):
Albert B. Rampage (0):
iraonavp (0):
Frozen Angel (0):
Aj The Epic (0):
Garmr (0):
Davesaz (0):



Not voting: Davesaz, Garmr, AlwaysInnocent, Frozen Angel, iraonavp, Aeronaut

With 10 alive it's 6 to lynch.

Night falls in (expired on 2016-01-22 21:00:00).

Song:

Cheap Trick: Surrender

Notes:

Obscure one for you guys!

[Firebringer]

so like no one is interested in the fact I have day chat now with a potential scum power role ok then.

Thats cool Garmr.
How you doing mate!!?!?!?

[Aeronaut]

Hey guys, I have like ten or so pages to catch up on.

[Aeronaut]

Hey Firebringer, what are you reasonings for parking your vote on me?

[Aeronaut]

Because all you've really said about it is "oh I got bad vibes from that guy", which is something people say they don't actually plan on pushing someone.

[Garmr]

so like no one is interested in the fact I have day chat now with a potential scum power role ok then.

You're saying someone neighborized you and Matt, and you now have daychat with that player? Or was there a hood already that you got added to?
How would you know that Matt became a member? Is that based solely on what the other neighbor told you?

We got added all of us abr was supposed to have joined us as well but something blocked him from entering according to the person who made it.


Also I'm not saying anything about the person for a reason.

[iraonavp]

Is it iraonavp?

No comment.

Although that does itself constitute commentary.

[iraonavp]

so like no one is interested in the fact I have day chat now with a potential scum power role ok then.

You're saying someone neighborized you and Matt, and you now have daychat with that player? Or was there a hood already that you got added to?
How would you know that Matt became a member? Is that based solely on what the other neighbor told you?

We got added all of us abr was supposed to have joined us as well but something blocked him from entering according to the person who made it.


Also I'm not saying anything about the person for a reason.

That doesn't sound like a Normal Role. I think that the person who told you that is probably lying.

[iraonavp]

No. Chop his head off.

No mercy.

Let's be extreme.

This is really not like you at all AI.

Meta wise, this seems scummy.

Firebringer, you haven't answered my question. I ask because the above post seems to be expressing suspicion towards AlwaysInnocent.

[Aeronaut]

so like no one is interested in the fact I have day chat now with a potential scum power role ok then.

You're saying someone neighborized you and Matt, and you now have daychat with that player? Or was there a hood already that you got added to?
How would you know that Matt became a member? Is that based solely on what the other neighbor told you?

We got added all of us abr was supposed to have joined us as well but something blocked him from entering according to the person who made it.


Also I'm not saying anything about the person for a reason.

That doesn't sound like a Normal Role. I think that the person who told you that is probably lying.

You can have one not-explicitly normal role in any mini normal game.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Ah so it's Aeronaut.

[iraonavp]

I did not know this, thanks for the clarification Aeronaut. Surely this does not mean that any role could be allowed, for example, a serial killer that can stab 10 people in a single night? I presume there are at least some kind of guidelines.

I was considering Direfire's push on Firebringer during the night phase and I noticed that Firebringer only made 2 meaningful stances in his entire ISO: something about Aeronaut being scum-aligned (don't remember why but it was weak) and something about AI being scum-aligned from meta. The rest of his posts are just irrelevant commentary, repeatedly asking useless questions like "hey player whats your read on player??", and most notably complete ignorance of the main wagons. The Aeronaut vote close to deadline seemed perfunctory and for show. So I felt slightly better about Direfire after considering that vote.

I would like to hear more from Firebringer before I come to a conclusion, though.

[Frozen Angel]

Wtf was that shot matt ... why you didn't kill FB ...

I'm still suspicious of AJ and Frozen. But Dave needs a serious look into.

Frozen is the most towniest town in townsville.

lol ?! scum likes to buddy me?!

[iraonavp]

Yeah. The death-tunneling on Mathilda was a big mistake. I wish I had stayed with Dierfire.

I think AI's (misplaced) confidence in Mathilda being scum-aligned looked genuine, especially when he admitted to his mistake and vowed to move on constructively. AI is probably town-aligned, in my opinion.

[Frozen Angel]

No. Bad fire.

Can you explain why Aero is town here?
I don't see it.

why you think he is scum?

[davesaz]

I looked at Firebringer just now, and I think I'll skip the questioning and jump straight on the wagon.
VOTE: Firebringer

[Frozen Angel]

lol I forgot to vote in day 2

thx dav!

VOTE: FireBringer

[Frozen Angel]

L2 I guess ...

[AlwaysInnocent]

@ABR

I think Dave is scum guys.

Why? I was thinking that the Miller claim becomes more believable when a Cop has flipped.

@AJ

AlwaysInnocent is Town, he's just overconfident and misguided (a dangerous combination).

@AlwaysInnocent

You look overconfident and misguided to me (a dangerous combination). I would like you to reconsider your read on me.

VOTE: Firebringer

If Aero is Mafia then why not vote for him?

No. I should not have moved my vote to Mathilda on D1.

VOTE: Dierfire

[Aeronaut]

I did not know this, thanks for the clarification Aeronaut. Surely this does not mean that any role could be allowed, for example, a serial killer that can stab 10 people in a single night? I presume there are at least some kind of guidelines.

Well every normal game needs to go through a review with the Normal Review Group, and generally they'd be the ones to nix something like that. But yea, having that one slot for a not previously explicitly normal role really adds an opportunity to play around with new kinds of mechanics and stuff.

I would like to hear more from Firebringer before I come to a conclusion, though.

I would too.

[AlwaysInnocent]

I agree that we should not end this day too quickly. Let's not bring Firebringer in the hammer range for now. Pressuring him is fine, but we should make the most out of this day.

[Aeronaut]

who did FB replace again?

[Aeronaut]

Dwlee