Mafia v. Wolves Redux: Finally Over!

[The Fonz]

Mod: Votecount please?

[Thok]

I'm pretty sure that BM was the hammer, actually.

[Kison]

He was.

[Lowell]

Is someone dead finally?

[The Fonz]

Apparently.

[Battle Mage]

can someone tell Jdodge to stop pissing about with his alts.

[theopor_COD]

Am I dead? Shameful.

[Battle Mage]

Were you scum?

[theopor_COD]

Afraid not.

[Mr. Flay]

I believe I will be taking over moderation of this game from Phoebus shortly

, as soon as I get the roles. Please continue to bear with me in that regard (yes I know I was a player, but I've been dead a long time).

[Battle Mage]

Afraid not.

dammit. Akbar must be scum then...

in other news: YAY FLAY!

[Akbar]

Thanks for the help Flay.

@BM
Apparently you missed Greg's illustration of the truth in post 1819. But that's ok. It'll be funny tomorrow, watching you explain trying to get me lynched.

I don't even think Theopor is town. I think he just said that in hopes we have a lynch blocker, or the vote count is wrong. Thok's roleclaim matches XreyoX's roleplay early in the game and N9V's testimony of the roleblock. It's likely XreyoX wouldn't joke about being drunk, hinting at his role if was a scummy role.

[Kison]

Any updates?

[Mr. Flay]

Okay, I've got roles from Phoebus, so here's that lynch scene you've been eagerly awaiting!

6: theopor_COD (Thok, Kison, Akbar, The Greg, The Fonz, Battle Mage)

1: Raffles (theopor_COD)

4: Not Voting (Raffles, PBuG, Lowell, Fuldu)

---

theopor_COD was lynched by the group, including Battle Mage coming back from his sabbatical to jump up and down on the lever of the gallows until it finally gave way. Good thing, too, since theo's hands were dirty as sin.

[Mr. Flay]

theopor_COD - Butler at the Estate - Banished - Day 5

Night choice deadline: Monday the 24th, 2300 GMT.

There may be a delay of dawn, if I have to prod too many people, so please even if you do not have a night choice, send me a "I'm still here!" PM...

[Mr. Flay]

As you head to your homes for night, you realize that Kison is stumbling and weaving. Concern sets in - is he drunk? Ill? Fascination mingles with horror, as the crowd stands paralyzed by indecision, watching the spectacle.

Kison

's stumbling increased as he wandered down the road toward his house, finally crashing into a post and falling on his back, gasping and rattling his breath. Clawing at his throat, he died without ever saying what was wrong...

Kison - Witch - Dropped Dead - Day 5

[Mr. Flay]

Celtic18 replaces Fuldu.
ThAdmiral replaces PBuG.
Tarhalindur replaces Raffles.

[Mr. Flay]

Lowell's predictions and pronouncements fell on deaf ears, but will be heard no more. It's awfully difficult to give sage advice when you lack a tongue... or a larynx... or fingers...

Lowell - Gypsy - Eaten - Night 5

It is now Day Six; with eight left alive, five votes will be needed to lynch.

[Thok]

I blocked Fuldu (now celtic) last night. [For a quick explanation of my choice of roleblock, on various rereads Fuldu struck me as the most likely mafia by process of elimination. I'll explain in more detail if people want me to.] The lack of a mafia kill strongly suggests he's Lucius Lovato, the last mafia.

BM and Raffles (now Tarhalindur) are probably both werewolves.

Unfortunately, ThAdmiral can't confirm this (I got an item last night, which means he probably didn't use his broomstick).

It looks like the daykills are a form of werewolf kill.

[Akbar]

Nice work Thok. I was suspicious of Fuldu(Celtic18) & BM to begin with. Especially after BM tried to save Theopor. But, the roleblock is pretty convincing. Without Kison, they knew I'd be covering Pbug(ThAdmiral). So they had to come after me. I'd be willing to vote either one of them. What makes you think Fuldu is the last mafia?

[Thok]

Nice work Thok. I was suspicious of Fuldu(Celtic18) & BM to begin with. Especially after BM tried to save Theopor. But, the roleblock is pretty convincing. Without Kison, they knew I'd be covering Pbug(ThAdmiral). So they had to come after me. I'd be willing to vote either one of them. What makes you think Fuldu is the last mafia?

Since Fuldu was the person I blocked, he's mafia unless somebody decided to kill ThAdmiral last night.

A long discussion of what I thought about last night (including some stuff I got from rereading various people).

All of me/Akbar/ThAdmiral/Fonz/The Greg are basically guaranteed protown. (With me/Akbar having a slightly weaker case than TheAdmiral/Fonz/The Greg at this point).

Since I believe Lucius Lovato is a role in this game, we have at least one mafia left. We've already seen 3 certain mafia (Flay, bird, theopor), and whatever was up with IH. I doubt we have 5+whatever IH was mafia.

At this point we had only seen 1 wolf. We likely have at least 2 more of those left.

Given that 1. wolves seem to have some ability to daykill, 2. there's likely more wolves than mafia left, I tried to figure out who was mafia, as that blocking the hypothetical last mafia would be more likely to actually stop a kill.

There were solid reasons for Raffles/BM to not be mafia.

Raffles made comments about there likely being 4 or 6 scum in the game (back when he was on the Over The Under wagon: it was part of his explanation for putting OTU at lynch -6). That suggests he is part of a 3 person scum group (4=3 scum+1 SK, 6=3 scum +3 scum and he shouldn't know the size of any scum groups at that point) and that group has to be the werewolves, since the mafia appears to have more than 3 people in it. He also had an a not mafia investigation on him. Also, theopor's desire to force a Raffles role claim yesterday suggest Raffles is not mafia. Also, mafia would have used Raffles to commit the kill last night if he was mafia; people were already suspicious of him, so there wasn't much risk in letting Kison see him kill people.

BM-theopor yesterday suggested BM is not mafia. There was no reason for the two of them to try to build a connection between each other if they are on the same team. BM also was never really fond of a Raffles wagon, which suggests he is a wolf.

That left Fuldu/Lowell to choose from. I suspected that the black cat was a possible cause of the day kills (which is a not mafia argument); also Lowell had a better name claim than Fuldu. I also got a strong "not werewolf" feel from Fuldu's posts (particularly his attacks on Raffles).

[Battle Mage]

I blocked Fuldu (now celtic) last night. [For a quick explanation of my choice of roleblock, on various rereads Fuldu struck me as the most likely mafia by process of elimination. I'll explain in more detail if people want me to.] The lack of a mafia kill strongly suggests he's Lucius Lovato, the last mafia.

BM and Raffles (now Tarhalindur) are probably both werewolves.

Unfortunately, ThAdmiral can't confirm this (I got an item last night, which means he probably didn't use his broomstick).

It looks like the daykills are a form of werewolf kill.

thats odd, because i too got an item. Apparently, i cant use it until tonight, and i dont even know what it is, but i got a pm during the night from the mod.
Anyway, Theo came up town. As far as i can see, Akbar must be scum, right?
Thok's comments don't make a whole lot of sense to me. I mean, Theo came up town. So from that alone you can ascertain that we are not scumbuddies. Yet why did you then infer that Theo trusting me, suggested that i was NOT FROM THE SAME SCUMGROUP as him?

BM

[Thok]

Huh? Theo came up as scum. He lied about his role name (he claimed to be a blind beggar, not a butler at the estate) and the lynch scene all but said he was scum.

[Lowell]

Yay now I can ignore this game!!

I mean, uh... go whoever.

[Akbar]

Thok's comments don't make a whole lot of sense to me. I mean, Theo came up town. So from that alone you can ascertain that we are not scumbuddies.

(Bolding for anyone interested in changing Theopor's lynch results.)

theopor_COD was lynched by the group, including Battle Mage coming back from his sabbatical to jump up and down on the lever of the gallows until it finally gave way.

Good thing

, too, since theo's hands were

dirty as sin

.