Mini 1749: Classic Rock Mafia: Game Over!

[Frozen Angel]

only If aero pushes it?

put aside dave miller stuff for one sec

is he scum for sake of being himself?

[AlwaysInnocent]

only If aero pushes it?

put aside dave miller stuff for one sec

is he scum for sake of being himself?

No?

I think he's scum because:

1) Role setup speculation points in the direction of there not being a Miller.
2) Dave's interactions with Albert B.
3) He hasn't done anything Town (true, me neither, but still).

[Frozen Angel]

So why were you hesitating to vote him before?

I was talking with Aero in neighbourhood about it. You were the one who started this day phase with throwing shade on him

[AlwaysInnocent]

So why were you hesitating to vote him before?

I was talking with Aero in neighbourhood about it. You were the one who started this day phase with throwing shade on him

When?

[AlwaysInnocent]

Let me ask you. I have been wrong all the time in this game. What kind of attitude do you think is best in my case? An overly confident attitude? Or a more cautious attitude?

[Frozen Angel]

I seriously thought it was lylo. This is better.

Aeronaut, do you remember what you said about this setup before?

Albert B. was lynched because there couldn't be a Miller and Ascetic role. However Albert B. was confirmed Ascetic. But we never questioned Dave afterwards. We assumed that Taly would not have fakeclaimed because it could be counterclaimed on D1. But I think Taly was confident that he wouldn't be counterclaimed because he knew Albert B.'s role. He knew that there couldn't be both a Miller and Ascetic.

This means FA was right all along for being skeptical about the Miller claim.

VOTE: Dave

Let's do this actually.

here you started casting shade on him and attached it my earlier reads but when Aero voted him you didnn't even continued to continue your point of view for a while

[Frozen Angel]

Let me ask you. I have been wrong all the time in this game. What kind of attitude do you think is best in my case? An overly confident attitude? Or a more cautious attitude?

I'm not talking about cautious I'm talking about your scummy muddying the water and watching it get dirty

[AlwaysInnocent]

I explicitly said that I wanted your input. Clearly my problem in this game has been my confirmation bias. It helps to have other people look at it first without pushing it too hard.

[Frozen Angel]

I don't understand wanting to go for a miller at this point. Unless you see something to say that was just a gambit, I'm not a fan of lynching it.

But if it's not Dave, and it's not you, then who is the remaining scum? I can tell you it isn't me either.

posts like this makes me thing you know dave and Aj are town

[AlwaysInnocent]

Let me ask you. I have been wrong all the time in this game. What kind of attitude do you think is best in my case? An overly confident attitude? Or a more cautious attitude?

I'm not talking about cautious I'm talking about your scummy muddying the water and watching it get dirty

So I shouldn't have any ideas?

[Frozen Angel]

Let me ask you. I have been wrong all the time in this game. What kind of attitude do you think is best in my case? An overly confident attitude? Or a more cautious attitude?

I'm not talking about cautious I'm talking about your scummy muddying the water and watching it get dirty

So I shouldn't have any ideas?

never said that don't misrepresent me , your today posts are highly scummy and I already mentioned it multiple times in Neighbourhood with Aero , I just was unsure to state them today or take them as a frustration issue for a town!you

[AlwaysInnocent]

Let me ask you. I have been wrong all the time in this game. What kind of attitude do you think is best in my case? An overly confident attitude? Or a more cautious attitude?

I'm not talking about cautious I'm talking about your scummy muddying the water and watching it get dirty

So I shouldn't have any ideas?

never said that don't misrepresent me ,

In that case you shouldn't misrepresent me either.

your today posts are highly scummy and I already mentioned it multiple times in Neighbourhood with Aero , I just was unsure to state them today or take them as a frustration issue for a town!you

What do you mean take them as a frustration issue? Do you have an issue with my play if I am town? I don't try to be annoying or unhelpful. I am just sucking so hard this game.

[Frozen Angel]

What do you mean take them as a frustration issue? Do you have an issue with my play if I am town? I don't try to be annoying or unhelpful. I am just sucking so hard this game.

I mean your apealing to ATE and say things like "I really suck in this game" and " this was my worst game so far"

and as an emotional being I don't know how should I look at to your posts, your hesitation can be simply becuase of your frustration - but there is a good chance for all of it to be fake

[AlwaysInnocent]

It is probably easy to fake my hesitant play this day if I were scum.

But other things are a lot harder (and riskier) to fake.

[Aeronaut]

Like?

[AlwaysInnocent]

My frustration with FA after her hammer on FB.

[davesaz]

FA, Aero: you're giving AI a free pass on town reading everyone but Dierfire yesterday.
That gamelong tunnel along with avoiding any responsibility is the epitome of safe scum play.

[AlwaysInnocent]

After re-reading, I am more convinced that it is Dave. It is not LYLO, and it would resolve the Miller claim anyhow, so I am willing to take the risk.

VOTE: Dave

I'll take responsibility for this hammer.

[RadiantCowbells]

twilight! :>

[Frozen Angel]

I'll take responsibility for this hammer.

what do you mean by this?

[Frozen Angel]

You know he is flipping town don't you?

[Frozen Angel]

like omg

are you scum claiming there?

[AlwaysInnocent]

I'll take responsibility for this hammer.

what do you mean by this?

That I take responsibility in case I'm wrong.

[Frozen Angel]

But that seemed like you know your wrong

[AlwaysInnocent]

You know he is flipping town don't you?

I think he will flip scum, but I can't say for sure. I've been thinking about it over and over again, and the roles just don't add up. In combination with the weird interactions with Albert B.

But let's wait first. The game could very well be over right now.