Also, what is NM doing? Worst play I’ve ever seen.
I can't remember the last N_M post that wasn't bland, unimaginative and lame. Some shitposters are at least somewhat funny. You are the epitomy of the type of poster that nobody would miss if you were to suddenly disappear. You never add anything of value.
I'm guessing you haven't read the game and probably never will? Why even sign up to play?
Also, what is NM doing? Worst play I’ve ever seen.
I can't remember the last N_M post that wasn't bland, unimaginative and lame. Some shitposters are at least somewhat funny. You are the epitomy of the type of poster that nobody would miss if you were to suddenly disappear. You never add anything of value.
I'm guessing you haven't read the game and probably never will? Why even sign up to play?
Anyway, I guess I'll have to prove I'm town through play then. This game wouldn't be fun without a challenge though.
~wgeurts
Hey, I apparently missed a ton. You people work fast.
Anyway, I try to keep in mind how peoples' playstyles can reflect their roles and an ISO of BAG's early posts screams IC. Obviously wasn't going to force-out them (cough cough) but this post helped to give it away. The vig joke claim was also helpful for speculation. Thus why I would rather me be lynched before BAG (there was no specific game of Aero's that I was referencing, just needed an excuse to say we were NOT lynching them.)
I realize that doesn't clear me at all but I'm still bummed they had to claim, which made my defense pointless lol.
Skimming/catching up shortly, but this thread reads like a damn mess. I'll probably still be wanting to lynch Kain (and could buy them working with Not_Mafia on a team, perhaps)
In post 130, Bill and Gompers wrote:The one that was swooning over how experienced me and Aero are.
Us being new to this kind of behaviour we are naturally sceptical of our first fanboy/gal.
As you should be. You should have been townread for that, but NotMafia kept poking at you incessantly. Part of my suspicion towards them there.
In post 160, Bill and Gompers wrote:By the way, we're not really going to be lynch today, so please stop wasting your vote pers. Just because we think you're scum doesn't mean you can mislynch us.
--Aero
Bad play to continue to scum read a claimed PR in an open setup. Thanks for confirming my read.
In post 220, NinoMasaki wrote:All I feel so far is that though Maestro looks a bit too... excited for a policy lynch? We have 8 players, so policy lynching is not an option unless you think there is some likeliho that Kain is also scum. Do you think Kain is scum, Maestro?
Still want to hear more from lovelygiant, who is also on the Kain wagon.
If Kain isn't mafia, he more than deserves to eat a lynch. We'll have a less ridiculous day chat. Things will actually progress forward.
If he IS mafia, congrats, we've snagged one. What's not to love?
*this is mostly in jest, but at least he's be the smallest town loss*
The only downside is trying to find meaningful interactions to analyze in his ISO after he flips. Votal analysis would also prove little. That's why I'm no longer voting him, and have switched to our next best crazy, N_M.
In post 220, NinoMasaki wrote:All I feel so far is that though Maestro looks a bit too... excited for a policy lynch? We have 8 players, so policy lynching is not an option unless you think there is some likeliho that Kain is also scum. Do you think Kain is scum, Maestro?
Still want to hear more from lovelygiant, who is also on the Kain wagon.
If Kain isn't mafia, he more than deserves to eat a lynch. We'll have a less ridiculous day chat. Things will actually progress forward.
If he IS mafia, congrats, we've snagged one. What's not to love?
*this is mostly in jest, but at least he's be the smallest town loss*
The only downside is trying to find meaningful interactions to analyze in his ISO after he flips. Votal analysis would also prove little. That's why I'm no longer voting him, and have switched to our next best crazy, N_M.
Ah, that strange moment where my exact words come out of somebody else's mouth except worded worse. Have I finally made it, Ma?
In post 220, NinoMasaki wrote:All I feel so far is that though Maestro looks a bit too... excited for a policy lynch? We have 8 players, so policy lynching is not an option unless you think there is some likeliho that Kain is also scum. Do you think Kain is scum, Maestro?
Still want to hear more from lovelygiant, who is also on the Kain wagon.
If Kain isn't mafia, he more than deserves to eat a lynch. We'll have a less ridiculous day chat. Things will actually progress forward.
If he IS mafia, congrats, we've snagged one. What's not to love?
*this is mostly in jest, but at least he's be the smallest town loss*
The only downside is trying to find meaningful interactions to analyze in his ISO after he flips. Votal analysis would also prove little. That's why I'm no longer voting him, and have switched to our next best crazy, N_M.
Ah, that strange moment where my exact words come out of somebody else's mouth except worded worse. Have I finally made it, Ma?
I promise, I felt this way since Kain's first post, thus my early lynch on him, Check my ISO.
I'm not surprised we play similarly. I watched Critically Experimental beginning to end, screaming at Gale internally. Some players make me cross-eyed.
In post 289, lovelygiant wrote:If Kain isn't mafia, he more than deserves to eat a lynch. We'll have a less ridiculous day chat. Things will actually progress forward.
If he IS mafia, congrats, we've snagged one. What's not to love?
As several people have explained, what's not to love is that we just don't have the numbers to indulge in a policy lynch.
In post 289, lovelygiant wrote:If Kain isn't mafia, he more than deserves to eat a lynch. We'll have a less ridiculous day chat. Things will actually progress forward.
If he IS mafia, congrats, we've snagged one. What's not to love?
As several people have explained, what's not to love is that we just don't have the numbers to indulge in a policy lynch.
While I have you, could you do me a favor? I'm bad at math and love when people post breakdowns of best/worst case population counts, if that makes sense...
like Night 1 - 5 town / 2 mafia if mislynch
Day 2 - 3 town / 2 mafia if vig kills town
etc... how long do we really have if we fuck up?
And I understood that, thus my switch to N_M for finding him scummier, for now.
In post 160, Bill and Gompers wrote:By the way, we're not really going to be lynch today, so please stop wasting your vote pers. Just because we think you're scum doesn't mean you can mislynch us.
--Aero
Bad play to continue to scum read a claimed PR in an open setup. Thanks for confirming my read.
In post 297, lovelygiant wrote:Furthermore, if policy lynching is discouraged due to risk, how do we guarantee the vig kill is any safer to make? Genuinely wondering.
We don't guarantee it. There are very few
guarantees
in mafia. But, I've asked people to name primary and secondary scum reads. So, the vig shot will basically be an extra lynch. Actually I think we should come to agreement on a pool of 3 - one to lynch today, one to vig tonight, one to lynch tomorrow if it comes to that. My pool is currently Not_Mafia, Maestro, and you.
