Mini 1773 : Symphonic Metal Mafia (Game Over?!)

[Masquerade]

I don't like how a plain farmer responded to my questions to Dierfire. It feels a little defensive. But that;s all I have so far.

[Frozen Angel]

Vote Count 2.5

Wisdom (2) : Jake from State Farm , Jeanne11
Maestro (2) : Wisdom , SnarkySnowman
Masquerade (1) : Shiro

Not Voting (5) : Aristophanes , Masquerade , nnn_thekushmountains , a plain farmer , Maestro

With 10 players alive it takes 6 votes to lynch.

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2016-03-29 06:00:00)

Lacuna Coil : Our Truth

Spoiler: lyrics

Clock is ticking while I'm killing time
Spinning all around
Nothing else that you can do
To turn it back
Wicked partnership in this crime
Ripping off the best
Condescending smile trying to forget (Wasting my time)
We're falling right through
Lying to forget (Telling more lies)
We're raising our truth
Go on and tease me
Clock is ticking while I'm stealing time
Can't you turn it back?
Stop the cycle
Let it free and run away
Silent sneaking along my path
Rugged the road
But we feel it like we're flying
Trying to forget (Wasting my time)
We're falling right through
Lying to forget (Telling more lies)
We're raising our truth

[Wisdom]

Yeah I don't like a plain farmer either. He can replace Masquerade in my scumpile.

[Maestro]

She could also be white knighting.

She = Shiro?

[Masquerade]

Who else?

[a plain farmer]

Snarky's starting to look bad. His case against Maestro in 613 is pretty much a bunch of quotes that the reader is supposed to interpret negatively.

@ Snarky

Do you have any prior experience with Maestro?

Can we drop this and agree Wisdom is town? I definitely follow his line of thinking here and I think it's distracting from {Jake, Maestro} scum and {Aristo} SK

Why do you assume that the second death is due to a SK, and why do you posit that SK to be Aristo?

Also I'd like an actual claim if possible, and also a weigh-in from anyone who is not Wisdom, Jake, Maestro

Why do you want a claim at L-4? I know it's low-hanging fruit, but how am I to see this as anything other than role-fishing?

[a plain farmer]

Let's not be a town that doesn't entertain any lynch candidates except for the participants in whatever the loudest 1v1 is at the time. Maestro's hammer actuallly gives me town vibes (I wouldn't think scum would be so quick to finalize the mislynch of someone who could probably be easily mislynched on a later day). I'm still null on Wisdom. It does appear that his reads are progressing, but what I don't see is how he's actually sorting.

@ Wisdom

In 684 you say you're scumreading Maestro because his appearance here is like previous games in which he was scum. Was this also the basis for your scumread on Jake?

[a plain farmer]

I don't like how a plain farmer responded to my questions to Dierfire. It feels a little defensive. But that;s all I have so far.

How was it defensive? If anything, it was probing, or could even be interpreted as accusatory.

[Wisdom]

In 684 you say you're scumreading Maestro because his appearance here is like previous games in which he was scum. Was this also the basis for your scumread on Jake?

That's not why I'm scumreading Maestro

[Wisdom]

Also farmer is scum and these posts made me more confident

[Jake from State Farm]

Wisdoms basis for my scum read is I said dire instead of kill. his basis for maestro is he hammered kill and wisdom didn't die so that means maestro was the only person who would leave him alive.

[Masquerade]

I don't like how a plain farmer responded to my questions to Dierfire. It feels a little defensive. But that;s all I have so far.

How was it defensive? If anything, it was probing, or could even be interpreted as accusatory.

Yes. Defensive of your buddy. Isn't that chainsawing? I don't really remember all those terms.

[Wisdom]

Wisdoms basis for my scum read is I said dire instead of kill

Not quite

[Wisdom]

Eh. I think I was too quick to write Jake off as VI. He is only posting to discredit me now and has stopped scumhunting and it's starting to worry me again.

[Masquerade]

Well Dierfire hasn't said much for me to go on but his 132 sounds just as weird as 248, which was a forced scumread. I'm afraid I'm going on confbias here, but to me 132 feels like forced scummunication. It's like he's trying to point out how he and farmer engaged so they wouldn't be buddy-read. Why would Dierfire take special interest in farmer's question?
Then farmer's iso, when farmer makes his case on Kts (387) he takes a lot of words to say that he scumreads Kts for 'opportunistic jumping the jake-wagon' Also, like Dierfire, he adds another perspective. I don't even know why you would add another perspective? If you're town you have one perspective and that's to lynch scum.

VOTE: a plain farmer

[Aristophanes]

Nice shot Vig!

"a player who comments on the outcome of a night when that outcome was detrimental to one or more factions is very probably scum".

Reading up. I'm reading Wisdom as town right now for the record.

Am I wrong that it was a good shot? Is it bad I'm happy about it?

Like, seriously people.

[Aristophanes]

Can we drop this and agree Wisdom is town? I definitely follow his line of thinking here and I think it's distracting from {Jake, Maestro} scum and {Aristo} SK

Ooooh. I get it.
Haha I wish! That'd be far more interesting!

[Wisdom]

Maestro, farmer, Jake. It's two of them. Everyone else is town.

[Masquerade]

I don't agree on Maestro. I'm kind of scumleaning Shiro a little. Maestro is null should dig into his iso next.

[Masquerade]

Oh almost forgot, jake, Wisdom did not omgus Dierfire and also Dierfire flipped scum.

[Wisdom]

Side note 2: Is it me or Dierfire post seem really slow ? Like, reading them I felt like they were dead. Can't truly explain the feeling though. Maybe it is because he is using way too many words to say way too l little.

Shiro is town for this if nothing else. This isn't a buddy accusation.

[Masquerade]

Yup. Thanks, that's another iso I can skip.

[Masquerade]

Dammit, I'm afraid I have to admit that you're possibly right on Maestro as well.

[Masquerade]

Snarky town, Jeanne null. I think that makes it complete.

[Jake from State Farm]

Eh. I think I was too quick to write Jake off as VI. He is only posting to discredit me now and has stopped scumhunting and it's starting to worry me again.

Of course I'm going to discredit my top scum read. And don't call me a VI cause I most certainly am not. And the "not quite" imo is a lie since you refused to explain yourself, when pressured by Jeanne you just do a complete 180 and start calling me town. Town doesn't do that.

You are scum.