Mini 1773 : Symphonic Metal Mafia (Game Over?!)

[a plain farmer]

@ Masq

Between Snarky and I, who do you think is more likely to be scum?

Masq, this is important, answer this please.

[Jeanne11]

And what about you Wisdom? You dodged my point in my last post. :/

[Wisdom]

Jeanne, whatever I say you interpret in a negative sense, so :/

I gave you my word, you can lynch me if I am wrong. There is nothing more to this than that.

[Jeanne11]

Yeah, you only say that cos you know you won't be wrong due to you two being scumbuddies. Nice try.

[Wisdom]

Okay then, you can lynch me even if farmer flips scum. I'll take the sacrifice.

[Jeanne11]

Suppose he flips scum. You can defend yourself on account of his flipping scum and end up being scum yourself at end.

[a plain farmer]

And he calls me manipulative

There's no way he can know I'm scum - because I'm not scum. And he's not just going to lie down tomorrow because that would be going against wincon.

[Wisdom]

So am I scum, farmer? I haven't heard you say it yet.

[Jeanne11]

I don't know what to think now. I think you two are scumbuddies and have agreed to suspect each other without fail so we would discard the possibility you two are scum together, with farmer being the sacrifice. You also agreed for farmer to appear whenever someone starts to vote him to maintain the illusion.

[Wisdom]

Okay then, you can lynch me even if farmer flips scum. I'll take the sacrifice.

[Wisdom]

Do you want me to swear for that too or is it okay like that?

[a plain farmer]

I've been town-leaning you, but your recent stuff with Jeanne pings me so I dunno.

PEdit: @Wisdom

I just appeared today because I got back from Easter family stuff.

[Wisdom]

Oh, so still scared to scumread me. Gotcha.

[Jeanne11]

After all, there's nothing scum wouldn't do to survive. I remember my first game as scum. My partner and I deliberately made him a sacrifice so I could win for us. You two could be doing the same thing.

[Wisdom]

So for whoever is keeping track - 1706 is yet another reason farmer is scum. He is subtly implying I am scum so he can match Jeanne's thoughts and make her listen to him (aka manipulation), yet he refuses to commit to scureading me when asked.

[a plain farmer]

Says the guy who is leading Jeanne to believe he'll consent to his own lynch when I flip town :/

And, for the record, I'm not scumreading you.

[Jeanne11]

After all, there's nothing scum wouldn't do to survive. I remember my first game as scum. My partner and I deliberately made him a sacrifice so I could win for us. You two could be doing the same thing.

[Jeanne11]

If I am right, you're both manipulating me.

[Wisdom]

Says the guy who is leading Jeanne to believe he'll consent to his own lynch when I flip town :/

And, for the record, I'm not scumreading you.

So how does that work? I am town and I am manipulating people?

[a plain farmer]

I can't speak for Wisdom, but I'm nobody's scumbuddy. I want to survive because I believe Snarky is scum and should be lynched instead, and I hold this apparently archaic position that you want to hit scum when you lynch.

[Jeanne11]

Granted, it's mostly gut, but something feels off with these posts you two make. It feels rehearsed.

[a plain farmer]

What you're doing could be town arguing for who you believe scum is (not manipulation, except to the degree that presenting an argument is manipulation). Which I am also doing.

[a plain farmer]

Well gosh we've sure held this script in reserve for quite a while then :/

[Jeanne11]

Wisdom knew this would happen from ASOIAF. He said so himself. That's exactly what they were counting on.

[Jeanne11]

Yes, you were. Just as me and Coldwine were. There is nothing scum wouldn't do. Wisdom said himself that town and scum don't act the way we expect them to.