In the event that Edward Elric is a Werewolf, would you think that Killthestory would be as well?
yeah, you could make that association based on edward's reads, but they both voted me at one point which is giving me pause about this line of thinking
VOTE: edward
Last edited by SnarkySnowman on Wed Mar 30, 2016 3:17 am, edited 1 time in total.
In post 320, emogirl123 wrote:to clarify: like backtracking and saying he had a reason instead of admitting he actually wanted a policy lynch, because that would look scummy.
you and Rhaegar both need to understand wanting to policy lynch a millar claim is completely standard
I could find you half a dozen of games where people claimed millar in their first post and got either PLed d1 or heavily wagoned
If I don't explain it, why should I drop the vote on choof? are you his partner??
This is some wacky logic here. Do you genuinely believe I am partners with Radiant Cowbells? I can't tell how much you are just trolling and how serious you are.
Correction, meant on Choof.
There are many questions in this world that have no answers.
He had the worst response to my miller claim where he straight said I should be policy lynched in post 88. As I mentioned just earlier, policy lynches are an easy out for scum. Of course, he just had to choose to replace out, so there won't be a response to this, which sucks. I'm interested in hearing what his replacement has to say.
Edward: scum
Her RVS was at the start in post 29 was just bad. Question three "What are your thoughts on the setup?" was rolefishing. I have yet to see Edward give a good reason as to why this question was asked and what information he got from it.
I pressured him, albiet a bit sarcastically, and he responded with this doozy in post 56. It was a scummy reaction in my mind, and really quite a bit of an overreaction at that point. What bothers me as well is he comes out later and puts me as a town read, but really doesn't have a great explanation of it in post 303.
I extremely disagree with your reads here. Choof has been a strong town ping since they answered my question in my opening post. As for me, why does it bother you that I don't have a strong explanation for you as town?
There are many questions in this world that have no answers.
In post 312, RadiantCowbells wrote:No, but it seems like there's a pattern of my scumreads not townreading me immediately in this game.
Want to point out this pattern and who are your scumreads are?
Your lack of participation has been noted for awhile. You seem to have strong opinions though.
There are many questions in this world that have no answers.
I thought choof was kind of towny with his push on the miller-claim, wouldn't expect scum to attract attention to themselves that way. Reading it again in iso, I don't really agree he backtracked but I do agree he looks scummy. He is very much against the miller-claim and wants it PL'ed Day 1 yet isn't voting or pushing for a lynch. In retrospect I also dislike the active lurk-vote he placed on RC. It was very early to accuse anyone of active lurking. Sucks he replaced out.
Emogirl, can you help me out and tell me where you think choof backtracked?
Edward: What specifically pinged you as town from choof?
Replacement for choof: What's your opinion on the miller-claim?
In post 336, Masquerade wrote:
Emogirl, can you help me out and tell me where you think choof backtracked?
here
In post 88, choof wrote:i just feel like claiming miller is gambit tier because if you're legit you've basically told everyone "dont kill me guys totally not an important and pro-town role to be found here guys"
imo the miller claim is always our best lynch today. we run the chance of outing other people by pushing them to L-1 and forcing a claim. what do we lose by lynching a miller?
dont even say conftown because thats bullshit
In post 162, choof wrote:see, I didn't like his entrance
it felt forced; too self-important and too calculated
I really, really,
really
do not the fact that you're basing a townread on the setup
In post 336, Masquerade wrote:Emogirl, can you help me out and tell me where you think choof backtracked?
i kind of explained it here.
In post 165, emogirl123 wrote:if you think it is too self-important and calculated, wouldn't you think about the setup to see if scum/sk claiming miller makes sense. also i wasn't aware that you thought his post was forced, it looks like a policy lynch to me until you brought it up just now.
up until that point it just looked like he was supporting a policy lynch disguising it as a scum read at best. then he says he is against policy lynches and i explain to him that he is in fact pushing a policy lynch. next instead of saying oh yeah you are right, he says he thought rhaegar's entrance was scummy all along and its not a policy lynch.
seems like he didnt want to admit he was pushing a policy lynch to avoid looking scummy.
i dont know how to get past your cryptic words and understand what you are trying to say. i have no idea how the hell you have a choof townread but his plays are classic serial killer plays pushing for a policy lynch d1.