1. In
13, Ryu asks what happens when 3 different alignments remain. -
Very strange question to ask, especially when the possibility does not exist, but nonetheless, nothing meaningful can be made of it. -
Null Indicative
2. In
25 and
72, Ryu emphasizes the fact that the UTL vote was a joke -
The only way I can say this is scummy is if I knew what prior experience Ryu had concerning forum mafia. Ryu made an RVS vote, yet then proceeds to emphasize it was RVS for strange reaons. If he had prior experience, I could definitely say that is scum indicative due to the fact he is trying to disassociate himself from the hammer. If this is his first time though, then it makes more sense, though then the question arises about emphasizing it twice. That however is answerable, as Ryu later explains he is a poor communicator. If I give Ryu the benefit of the doubt, then that means I can also take the trying to fit in part as null. -
Null-Town Indicative
(Considering the evidence, I don't think he has forum mafia experience, and if that is the case, then everything else about the posts concerning this make perfect sense.)
3.
74 - Ryu also puts an FoS on YA saying it's simply gut -
Except this part. Again, I have to weigh in the poor communicator aspect. Someone needs to remind me what the VC was at the time. If the VC was less than 3, this is
Null-Scum Indicative
; else, it is
Null-Town Indicative
. This one needs to be kept in mind though it tells little by itself.
4.
92, Ryu states he has played EpicMafia as mafioso before -
Whoops, scratch that earlier conclusion (2) and replace that with -
Scum Indicative
as I am sure there is RVS on EpicMafia.
5. Ryu End Result ===> Neutral (-45%)
6. Egg gives read list in
224 -
Nothing alignment indicative here. There are a lot of "effort" reads, but I tend to make such an association a lot too. The only thing weird is the Aero read which is based on Aero being the IC, but I don't think it's a tell in and out of itself. -
Null-Indicative
7. In
275, Egg randomly brings up fake cop and asks why is it frowned upon. -
Another "noise" question that is completely irrelevent to the conversation on hand.... This is a bit of a stretch, but is how I perceive it -
Null-Scum Indicative
8.
371 - Egg does 1) VT claim 2) State he's useless 3) Unvotes YA, his only scumread........ -
This post is by far the worse post this slot has made. The VT claim & useless comment is akin to giving up - bad start. But, the worst part is the unvote of YA, his main and only scumread, with no reason other than "I'm, uh, not feeling it anymore" - Seems VERY opportunistic in nature (isn't this about when the YA wagon began to die?) and the utter lack of confidence he expresses in his unvote makes me think he isn't really committed to it; in fact, this post gives townie points to YA since Egg opportunistically got off the YA wagon with a half reason that isn't even confident! -
Very Scum-Indicative
7.
383 - Egg is asking others about the UTL slot, etc. -
Not sure what to label this as; really, I can go either way. Scum -- Doesn't want to take an active stance & wants to avoid any blame for a possible mislynch. Town -- Confused townie who isn't good at mafia. Oh well, I guess I have to go with -
Null-Indicative
8. More newbie questions in
384 and
429 -
Really hard to tell; genuine, or is it a false newbie facade to try to cover up his lack of content? I haven't really like the amount of effort so far, so I'm leaning toward the latter:
Null-Scum Indicative
9. Readlist at end of D1 by Egg in
697. I will come back to this, but the interesting part i I'm a townread.
10. By
787, Egg provides an updated readlist with me as Weak Town and.... votes me??? -
Now, look at #9 again. There is no mention of me by Egg at all between the posts, but I'm suddenly deserving a vote? No, that doesn't cut it for me; when making that drastic of change of read, you need an actual reason, even if it is gut or PoE (neither of which you specify; you simply say Shannon is ranked lower (but interestingly enough have YA on the bottom tier), omgus me, and say I have an aggressive playstyle (not at all, it's analytical)) - Omgus in this case is very weak, weaker imo than gut. And what you said does not seem to match up with what you do. We can also add in the town lose attitude (we should lynch Ircher D2 then me D3 which is a town loss if you are town), we can safely conclude -
Very Scum Indicative
11. Asks me some decent questions in
935, but now I'm in the bottom rung..... -
This time, Egg is being more consistent with doing what he says, so I must -
Town Indicative
12.
Combine that with the lurking and defeatist attitude and what I perceive as not trying -
Null-Scum Indicative
