Mini 1782 Game Over

[Maverick1102]

The game pretty much has started. We're all able to talk so everyone should be talking. Refusing to do so because we're in 'pregame' is more arrogant than anything else. We won't come up with any magical new info when it turns to D1 now will we?

[Jake from State Farm]

Eh I'm too busy to worry about pre game. It isn't arrogance

[Maverick1102]

That's fair enough, but I'd like to think that by talking for almost 10 pages whilst it's more contentless and RVS'ey than most games it's also given us a leg-up on scumhunting D1.

[RadiantCowbells]

would the real slim shady please stand up?

[Nosferatu]

I mean it basically just means we get a longer D1 tbh

[Jake from State Farm]

Who the hell wants a long day 1? Day 1s are too long as it is. 7 days max. 5 is ideal

[RadiantCowbells]

Wait what the fucK?

Nos why are you ban dodging?

[Nosferatu]

?

[RadiantCowbells]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 6#p7727028

Oh sorry my bad. Didn't realize the 3 weeks had expired.

[Jake from State Farm]

Nos is pm?

[RadiantCowbells]

2 weeks, sorry.

LLD, not Pirate Mollie.

[Nosferatu]

but I'm not LLD lol

[RadiantCowbells]

u stahpit LLD.

[Frozen Angel]

can we drop the topic nos is someone elses alt already?

[RadiantCowbells]

It's a joke

[Frozen Angel]

jake what is stopping you to intract with people?

pedit : pm already covered that joke in shop large game . and i hate that game. dont remind me that game plz

[a plain farmer]

I hoped to not have to go back to this, but
VOTE: mhsmith

On Roshar: The scumreads on him seem to be based on him having exhibited X, Y, and Z behaviors that are disproportionately seen in scum. This is certainly not negligible, but his instantiations of these behaviors so far seem like they could come from town. On the whole, I view him as a null.


Also, here's a thing. Come see how good or bad of a person you are:

{Maverick, FA}
{RC, Froot Loop, Lowell}
{Roshar} {Jake, KainTepes, Nos, shaddowez}
{Clumsy}
{mhsmith}

[mhsmith0]

@apf: do I get a reason or is guessing part of the fun?

Ps I sincerely apologize for forcing you into voting for me. It pains me deeply to have backed you into such a corner
(The eye roll is there just in case my ps wasn't obvious sarcasm... Please tell me that it wasn't needed. Please).

[a plain farmer]

For those who like guessing, I didn't want to deny them the thrill.

But I'm voting you because 50, 138, and 139 seem to me like moments where there was an opportunity to take a stance, but instead we got you setting up a potential future stance.

[mhsmith0]

Fwiw, I tend to be on the slow side in voting. I dislike throwing my vote around aggressively. I don't have a problem with those who do, but that's not my style. I obviously haven't been impressed with you so far, but I'm not at the point where i think it's vote worthy. I'd rather observe, ask questions, and develop a more informed opinion, of both you and others. Especially since I've never played with you before and don't know your meta.

I'd also note that 139 in particular was an answer to roshars 137. I don't see how that was setting anything up.

[Froot Loop]

Did you read it is as genuine or fake excitement when RC thought frozen slipped?

I read it as genuine.

I didn't take his assertion that strongly. I agree with you (not sure about the policy lynching,) I just don't think that's what he's doing in this game.

What do you think he's doing in this game, then? For the record, he still stands by his 'case'. I do find it hard to believe scum would throw themselves this way, but I also cannot come up with a town thought process.

APF hasn't been tunnelling and he has been talking about other things in the game and his later vote references other things smith has done as well.

Maverick came off pretty well from his interaction with RC - it feels like he's genuinely looking for information and not jumping on RC's behaviour which could be done as scum. I'm not saying that scum would definitely do it, but not doing it is a measured move.

RC seems sensitive but I'm not sure what this indicates, while it's definitely not useful to town. I can't really see anything useful to the town in his responses to Maverick.

[RadiantCowbells]

I don't like Froot Loop's commenting on 'usefulness to town' as if it's a synonym for 'towniness.'

[Froot Loop]

I'm not using it as a synonym for towniness. I mean being useful to town.

[RadiantCowbells]

Then what was the point of your last post?

[Froot Loop]

To share what I thought.

Town should try and be useful to the town, that doesn't mean they always are though. I'm not saying "not useful to town = scum." It can easily be "not useful to town = nothing," especially in the situation of a reaction to questioning from another player. But, "not useful to town" does not equal "useful to town," which for me would be town-indicative.