OK, so I'm posting this. I lost between Page 30 and Page 35, but nothing was too huge other than stuff I'll probably repeat when I go back. For right now, here's what I have. No, I won't respond to any individual points until I'm fully up to date:
Page 1 Notes:
- Early suspicion on iraonvp and Mafiaturtle on this Jam wagon.
- FoS GoldenRobster If you're saying boonskiies is scum, you're saying I'M SCUM! >:o (No. I'm not serious.)
Page 2 Notes:
- Town vibe on SomethingSmart.
- Actually, scum vibe now on Golden Robster. He made that scummy comment on
27 to just bandwagon Boonskiies. Just "bandwagonning" anyone is a terrible idea. I thought he was laughing it off in the next post so I kind of disregarded it. Then
42 rekindled my suspicion.
- I actually don't like
48. There's a difference between lurking and coasting. This early on in the game, scum coast, not lurk. If someone didn't post, it's more likely because they haven't found time in the day to pop in quite yet.
Page 3 Notes:
-
71 This may just be more annoying to me because I faced the same damn thing from the first game, but are you really saying someone not understanding game terms like alignment-indication or RVS or something like that is alignment indicative? Get out of here.
- Also Boonskiies agrees? The guy I'm replacing - I don't like his play style.
-
74 Here here.
Page 4 Notes:
-
81 Ahahaha. This is adorable.
-
85 Ness, I think, is overreacting a bit.
-
92 Why do I get a KainTepes feel from you?
-
94 If I was here during Day One, I'd probably vote him by now.
Page 6 Notes:
-
129 For some reason and this is only a gut feeling, but I don't like this post from Fraggernaut.
-
136 I generally have negative opinions on anyone who unnecessarily calls themselves town.
-
137 This post made me realize that GuyFawkes has really coasted quite a bit this day phase. Not good.
-
149 General town vibe from Mafiaturtle.
Page 7 Notes:
-
156 Fraggernaut has some good questions and shows thoroughness in Iroanvp's ISO. Townie points.
-
161 I didn't like his earlier vibes, but I'm liking this. He's bringing me to null-territory on him. Maybe even lean town.
-
164 I don't like this. Just because you have a vote doesn't mean that you should use it. It also seems a bit out of SirCakez's character to be this aggressive.
Page 8 Notes:
-
178 I actually don't have full confidence that Snowman read the game before responding. This may not be the most relative comment in the world, but that's what I feel now.
-
189 What a terrible introduction. With as much info as there is in the game, you could have certainly done more.
-
191 While I believe Ozgin's premise is fallacious, I don't object to this vote and I think it's coming from a town point of view. (The fallacious part is that just because you consider someone's play to be how you would play as scum, doesn't mean they're scum.)
- In general, Iraonavp (Glad I finally got his name right) - His defense isn't terrible. If I was in the game, it would at least make me go over the evidence.
Page 9 Notes:
-
202 Really? It seemed anything
but
sincere. lol
-
213 I'm really trying to shake this off but everything Slandaar is throwing me is coming up null. I can't read anything off him. I'm hoping this goes away soon.
-
222 I'm beginning to think of this as terrible words coming from a probable town.
Page 10 Notes:
-
229 Doesn't make me think he's any more town, but I agree.
-
240 Terrible reason to vote someone. You know what I did when I had school projects? Procrastinate.
-
245 Did you seriously vote Ness after there's a replacement search on him? This is... beyond terrible.
-
255 VOTE: Mod Lynch all liars!
...okay, fine.
UNVOTE:
274 This reminds me of nearly everyone's involvement in Yuk It Up Buttercup, when there were more, "I'm going to catch up," rather than actually catching up.
Page 12 Notes:
-
276 Oh, come
on.
-
279 I think I'm right. This is more answering questions rather than actually catching up and issuing his reads.
-
299 I think you're giving Ness way too much credit. Him replacing out doesn't mean he's not scum. In fact, him replacing out is not alignment indicative. If he's town, he has schoolwork. If he's scum, guess what? He has schoolwork. I suggest we stop talking about Ness' exit and worry more about whom replaces him. (Although, it's Day 2 now. I'm guessing the discussion has stopped.) Also, I disagree about SirCakez.
Page 13 Notes:
-
314 Please tell me he's already lynched... pretty please?
I can't comment more on this. Sure, there's the vote on Iraonavp but I have to read more on Killthestory, and he's not contributing anything to help town. He is epitomizing stagnation.
Page 14 Notes:
...Just realized. Where the hell is the guy I'm replacing?
331 Slandaar is still pretty cloudy, but I think I'm confident enough to put him as a lean town.
Page 15 Notes:
350 I don't like how Slandaar said this like it's an established fact. (I.e: Innocent Child) Frag obviously has a different opinion.
368 I can't be the only one thinking he's a troll, can I?
370 What were you hoping to accomplish with this post? Were you expecting anything outside of, "No, I wouldn't?"
Page 16 Notes:
386 Bad answer. You said something was bad. Something that isn't good isn't necessarily bad. If you've made the claim of something being bad, you have the burden of proof to answer the question, not deflect it.
399 Ahahahahahahaha.
Page 17 Notes:
Loved Iraonavp's
403 but hated
405. I'm pretty confident Iraonavp is town-aligned.
406 This was actually very odd to me. I don't know why Drixx felt the need to say this... Maybe he actually didn't read the game.
418 You're a dick friend? I mean, I don't swing that way, but enjoy being a dick friend.
Page 18 Notes:
433 I don't like this. Scum leaning on Creature.
438 Repeating what's already been said.
447 Yet you're not even trying.
449 I hope you're enjoying a nice Pina Colata during this beautiful cruise on the coast...
Page 19 Notes:
473 Thank you!
Page 20 Notes:
479 Why Kop?
Page 21 Notes:
505 Translation: I'm useless this game, and am contributing nothing.
511 Welcome!
513 This is not the action of someone that's scum.
518 Simple. The same as other numbers. Difference? More scum. More townies. Get to it.
521 I'm going through ~50. I have no sympathy for you.
Page 23 Notes:
574 You decide that. Don't let the group dictate who you vote for. Think for yourself.
Page 25 Notes:
Dripping Goofball needs to condense this shit. He's just spamming. Blame me if you must but I'm skipping it. I can't deal with this.
607 This appears to be sheeping to me.
613 A blanket "this is scum" seems cookie-cutter and poorly executed.
615 Are you tooting your own horn or changing your mind.
622 He just called scum in two other posts this page.
Page 26 Notes:
627 Pot calling kettle black?
638 I get why you voted Iraonavp, but if you're suggesting he's the scummiest one of everyone here, you're wrong.
646 No it's not.
Page 27 Notes:
652 Nice comeback.
654 You know, I never thought of it that way... but you're exactly right.
664 You said that you won't be prodded again. The fact that I am here proved that was a lie.
Page 28 Notes:
676 Agreed. People who want PR roles are more worried about having work done for them rather than being good at Mafia.
Page 29 Notes:
709 This is more smart-assed than this is being helpful.
717 This post made me go into his ISO. I found about 5% of his posts to be of
any
value. I stopped until when I hit his 717 post. Please tell me he's dead. ...eh, I'll find out by the time I get to the current page, but even the guy I'm replacing added more value. Holy shit.
723 I need to fact check this but if you're right, then good on you and I'll town read you, but right now, it just seems like a pissing contest between two towns.
