The Third Fortnight (Game Over [Bonus Round])

[Nosferatu]

asking for top three people you wouldn't kill seems like such a scum thing to do. Town would ask for a kill list.

[Antihero]

that's a pretty ridiculous thing to say

[Quilford]

How far have you progressed with your reading Nosferatu?

[Nosferatu]

that's a pretty ridiculous thing to say

don't blame me
blame his scum role pm

How far have you progressed with your reading Nosferatu?

read glork in iso. Read up until 13 but like other than bulge getting run up to L-2 nothing interesting happened so I took a shower

[Quilford]

Do you reckon you'll finish reading the game within the next 24 hours or so?

[Nosferatu]

I might power through it tonight, but if I can't I'll try to finish it up before my AP test tomorrow.

[Quilford]

Okay.

*wonders what Gorkington is going to make of all this*

[Antihero]

ok well i'm gonna go stick a pine cone up my ass and go to sleep now

see ya tomorrow afternoon

still waiting on some good stuff from snarky.

[zMuffinMan]

so I like read to #83 and then I had one of those moments where you like suck in air sharply so I was like agh and I looked in the activity overview and I saw he had like a crapton of posts, so I was like "obviously it must get better" but then it didn't :/

so ive been hoping for an opportunity to use this since i thought of it this morning and im glad one such opportunity came up so soon...

would you say his posts seem... gorkward to you?

thank you, thank you, ill be here all fortnight

[Davsto]

I've just been skimming the last few pages but the issue came up briefly of Snarky's activity

And well

It's pretty null as far as I know. I've modded two games with Snarky

In Werewolves of Miller's Hollow, he was one of two players which required prodding throughout the course of the game, 9th highest number of posts out of 13 players.
SCP Foundation Mafia, required two prods in the first day, was then treestumped and then his activity levels were so low that I ended up prodding him and replacing him despite originally planning not to do that to the treestump. As in, two softprods (PMs telling him without actually counting as prod), the second of which came with a warning that if he didn't post for 3 days he would be prodded and replaced.

Yes, he was town in both of those games.

[Gorkington]

asking for top three people you wouldn't kill seems like such a scum thing to do. Town would ask for a kill list.

why.

[Gorkington]

*wonders what Gorkington is going to make of all this*

we'll see.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Fuck me. So I just checked when the last time I felt I was "caught up" was and it was goddamn 30 pages ago. I shouldn't have agreed to play a large but hey fuck me right?

Rather than do the shitty thing and replace out I've decided to waste what little free time I have sorting through you bitches getting all testy with each other. I'll be doing this 10 pages at a time and I'll be starting right now. Every 5 pages I'm rewarding myself with a beer and every 10 I'm rewarding myself with anime, so it'll take a minute.

here is where I'm starting, for reference.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Fine, Anti, I was going to go for the bandwagon on scum, but let it not be said I'm unwilling to compromise.

Unvote, vote: bulge

Any lynch at all huh? Don't like this one bit.

Marquis I've read 185 like 5 Times and I have no idea what it's saying.

Anti, cheely, do either of you see anything alignment wise in that huge fight thing you had because I really don't wanna read it and I already really like both of you as town.

@Marquis how much do you trust the opinions stated in 211?

Answering the question sort of posed in 216 while his mislynch record is apparently technically alright he does get votes pretty frequently regardless of alignment.

First thing I think snowman did in this thread was implore that dude I've seen the face of to not leave. Seems weird?

My own ego is upset that I'm "unread" in snowman's 251, but the existence of a "null" category in the same list replaces my indignance with confusion.

The weird Hiplop Kuroi 1-2 punch Cogie vote without explanation has my head spinning. It's vaguely clear to me that Kuroi seems alright with a stupid=scummy mindset, but Hiplop didn't state a reason either, other than an implied hipocrisy=scummy mindset, neither of which I agree with.

Boy I was druunk when I posted on page 13, I don't remember that at all.

14 is a quil explosion. I like it, though I'm a little hurt he didn't mention me pridepridepride

I don't have a problem with it because I trust this player list to not be full of idiots. It's that some sort of mistake?

That's your first mistake.

I wanted to assume this was a joke but you're acting on it so let me just put here that I fervently disagree with this line of thinking. Its not really related to

this

game, but I'm bored. The reason I continue to get a kick out of this game and (most of the time) manage to keep my cool is because I treat it like a game, meant for fun, and treat my fellow players with respect in hopes that they'll do the same. Don't assume people are idiots and maybe you'll have a better time and also improve as a player.

The reaction to Kuroi, from both cheets and quil, make me smile. Still pretty sure grogington is town, quil remains to be seen.

Bonesies 399 makes me super uncomfortable. It's like a weird "I know how this game's gonna end but I'm not telling you HAHAHA which is freaky as shit. The only motive i see for this is he's confident he's not going to get lynched? Which seems bananas to me so someone else feel free to interject.

Ehhh he keeps it going on 403 (getting too lazy to link) which is still freaky. If Kuroi or someone Kuroi adjacent flees tonight I'll follow him into he'll but right now I really just want to poke at him about everyone right now.

Snap Chester cheetah taking moo cow to task. I'm practically beatboxing over here.

Every game needs a prideful idiot, and since I wasn't here to do it miltank took the reigns

Teebee still being super cryptic in 424-425, still not liking it.

Gork, remove Kuroi from my "wouldn't shoot" list, and add

myself

...Johnny? Idk, I'm struggling to find anyone town enough to justify putting on the list above anyone else.

Motherfucker I hadn't posted anything serious in arguably 10 pages, how am I one of your 3?

Speaking of 10 pages I've earned some anime brb

[Nosferatu]

asking for top three people you wouldn't kill seems like such a scum thing to do. Town would ask for a kill list.

why.

Cause of like objectives. Town has to find and kill scum. Scum just has to survive. A not kill list is quintessentially against town's objective.

[Gorkington]

have you read the setup nos?

[Gorkington]

cheely

you cheeky guy.
nah.
anti's probably town.
i was just pissy because he was called me a dumdum.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Hey you're lucky, I used your real name like 97 Times in that post and replaced it with a cool name each time because who KNOWS what would happen to someone if their real name was on ms?

Nos's beef looks different from my early beef with this idea ftr but I also don't think I follow

[Nosferatu]

have you read the setup nos?

in a setup where there is only D1, I'm fairly sure scum objective is still to survive a lynch and not get scumread. Now they just have to do it once.

[JohnnyFarrar]

You are managing to be wrong, idiotic, and stubborn all at once.

What an achievement.

Vague, ad hominem and ad hominem. Congratulations.

Alright before you were objectionable but now you're just being gross.

People dogpiling on someone for being dumb isnthenwrong kind of interesting.

I kinda wanna be on Cogie's side in 447 because the bone zone is freaking me out but I can't get behind his language nitpicks. It's probably because I've made shitty votes followed by "no for real though" really early in my town games and also because it assumes a base level of shittiness in scum's play that I can't subscribe to.

I agree with 464 a lot and as I write this I'm getting paranoid about how my friendship with Gorky may be ruining my ability to read him. This is why I don't do large games. I latch onto certain people.

Oh snap there's a Kuroi wagon analysis.

@Kuroi I'm curious to know what about the ISO of myself, Dav and Kats sets us apart from those of Gork and bins?

Kats you're too cute in my head for this language

In a stunning turn of lurkervote, quil votes reck. It's clear that it's not a proper lurkervote, but gosh he'd been gone longer than me at that point, what's the point? I had more shit to say about the Reck vote and subsequent talking but Anti had that covered in 485 so snip~

506 is the best case in the game so far. I don't particularly care if googleton is pulling one over on me at this point, if he's scum he deserves the win.

@Kats why Cogie?

I kind of want to say even think like Kats is in 541 Seems townie to me but this setup is weird? And maybe only scum would think of this sort of auto lose situation for them? Fuck it nvm this thought is useless. Made you read it though

548 from Muffy is really bumming me out, why even play if you're not gonna try to win? I get it's a fun place and we're all hilarious but this game has a waiting list of people who presumably want to get in here and

play

.

Ugh gross now we're

discussing

it forget I said anything. *commence posts and posts of arguing about how to properly play mafia*

Bulge seems honest in 626 and his last game was a while ago, backing up said claim.

Wondering why Kuroi's reaction to any wagon is incredulity, but it might be a personality thing?

Then Kuroi takes over the thread again with opinions I disagree with. Notable here is Bulge defending bins

I actually like Dav here. Could be because I do the same thing a whole lot (questioning the motives of people agreeing with me vote-wise)

heyyy just finished 28 animeeeeee

[zoraster]

Day 1

Antihero ( 1 )

hiplop

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Bins ( 1 )

KuroiXHF

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Gorkington ( 1 )

Nosferatu

[/color]

(L - 8 )

hiplop ( 4 )

Gorkington

Quilford

Cogito Ergo Sum

Davsto

[/color]

(L - 5 )

KuroiXHF ( 1 )

T-Bone

[/color]

(L - 8 )

Quilford ( 1 )

SnarkySnowman

[/color]

(L - 8 )

SnarkySnowman ( 1 )

Antihero

[/color]

(L - 8 )

T-Bone ( 2 )

The Bulge

zMuffinMan

[/color]

(L - 7 )

The Bulge ( 2 )

JohnnyFarrar

Katsuki

[/color]

(L - 7 )

Not Voting ( 2 )

Bins Marquis

Total Votes ( 16 )

Needed to Lynch [ 9 ]

Deadline: May 8th at Noon EDT

The Bulge has been prodded. I will search for a replacement for T-Bone if he hasn't posted later today

[The Bulge]

Prodded. I've got a free afternoon once I'm off work and today seems like a good day to get shit done here

[camntsuki]

@Zora: Can we get a deadline extension with all these replacements?

[Quilford]

This is some good catching up by Johnny

[Gorkington]

A not kill list is quintessentially against town's objective.

tell me why you think this.

have you read the setup nos?

in a setup where there is only D1, I'm fairly sure scum objective is still to survive a lynch and not get scumread. Now they just have to do it once.

and why does your point translate to this when it has nothing to do with being "against town's objective"?

i could get thinking that maybe i was faking being protown with that opening. it is earnestly probably something i could see myself doing as scum, albeit maybe using it as more of a crutch than i did.
but that isnt what you originally said. talk at me about why you changed your angle from "this guy is playing against town's wincon" to "hes trying to fake being protown".

might be being semantic here, but i'd still like you to elaborate.