Mini 1792: Baccano! Mafia [Game Over]

[The Daily Days]

Official Vote Count

Cerberus v666

(3): Thor665, camntsuki, Aristophanes

Nosferatu

(1): Staeg

heuristically_alone

(1): Dwlee99

AlpacaAlpaca

(1): Florestan

camntsuki

(1): Cerberus v666

Not Voting

(3): Nosferatu, heuristically_alone, AlpacaAlpaca

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.


Day 2 ends in (expired on 2016-05-29 10:01:09)

[Aristophanes]

^ can we have a countdown timer or whatever plz?

okies.

[AlpacaAlpaca]

anti town and scummy are different

I get that they can be 2 different things but the scum's overall goal is to get rid of the town so if they acted in a anti-town way it wouldn't be too surprising if they were scum themselves, or maybe they were just acting anti-town but only time will tell that.

[camntsuki]

OK. I agree this game needs more than us and Cerb.
That said- 2 points on him:
a> is the language necessary? My virgin ears.
b> I don't think claiming ascetic up front is a scummy play. I think LINKING "I'm Ascetic" with "obv don't consider lynching me until just before LYLO" is the scummy part. We should lynch him when and where WE choose.. not where HE chooses.

That is down ftr, but I think we can table the discussion for now..

lets reset:

Nosferatu

- I WANT to sheep Staeg on this.. but looking over his ISO I don really feel much scumminess here. I don't like Hated claims, but if it's true its town right? Maybe Slizard? I think town though. So I am not feeling it for now.

Thor665

- I am townreading this slot. He is the townthor I remember from back in the day.

Cerberus v666

Discussion tabled.

Aristophanes

- Reasonably strong townread here.. although maybe its the buddying. Which I appreciate. Willing to sheep.

Florestan

- That slip up front was a compelling thing.. but things have turned up since. Probably town?

Staeg

I WANT this to be a townslot. I like the hunting. But I am POE-ing myself into a corner here with all these townreads. I could totally be getting fooled here.

POE leaves these 3 as the not-town, If I assume Cerebrustown:

AlpacaAlpaca

"aw, Shucks" in 555 is a classic tell. Otherwise mostly lurky. Again, I could totally go this way.

Dwlee99

- His ISO is SUPER THIN, and I could totally see scum here.

heuristically_alone

- Also a thin ISO.. but I get a tiny townvibe from it.

OK. Who is scum/3p? They are in here [AlpacaAlpaca, Dwlee99, Cerberus, heuristically], probably in that order, in my current opinion.

Do we have a townbloc yet? Lets run up Alpaca or Dwlee.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Dwlee99

[AlpacaAlpaca]

OK. Who is scum/3p? They are in here [AlpacaAlpaca, Dwlee99, Cerberus, heuristically], probably in that order, in my current opinion.

Do we have a townbloc yet? Lets run up Alpaca or Dwlee.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Dwlee99

So my 555 post was more of me being stupid honeslty and i regretted it when Thor got mad at me for it but that probably doesnt weigh into your thoughts on the matter.

Also not to push a vote onto myself but if you think that I am more scummy than Dwlee than why would you vote for him and not me?

[camntsuki]

I want more Dwlee, is why.
But I would vote for you, don't worry. 555 wasn't you "being stupid". It was you trying to act like a concerned townie, but failing.

[Florestan]

Only person I'm not sure about in your townbloc is Nosferatu.

[Aristophanes]

We have a town bloc?
I think I missed something here..

[Aristophanes]

Also, thanks for the countdown!

[Thor665]

policy lynching is stupid when it seems there is a vig in the game.

That presumes a lot on the Vig.

[AlpacaAlpaca]

Let's say hypothetically of course since that's the only way you'll listen that what I said in 555 was me being stupid, no matter what I say you won't beleive me because I can't prove something intangible so there isn't much I can do but stand by my inexperience and stupidity as you'll see through most of my posts. All of which can of course in turn be viewed as a scum being bad

[Dwlee99]

why out of those 3 are you picking on me

[camntsuki]

I expect more of you, that's why.
What's up, anyway? Why are you being so scummy?

Aristo- do we? I wish we did.
Alpaca- its one of Tar's Standard Tells. I'm old school like that.
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?tit ... dard_Tells

[Aristophanes]

Aristo- do we? I wish we did.

I mean, it'd be nice. I took that from this:

Only person I'm not sure about in your townbloc is Nosferatu.

[camntsuki]

Well, he is the one I am a little uncertain about, too.
But I think WAY less scumm than Alpaca or Dwlee, right?

[Aristophanes]

Well, he is the one I am a little uncertain about, too.
But I think WAY less scumm than Alpaca or Dwlee, right?

Agreed.
Dwlee having a low postcounr makes me think scum, so I'm in.
VOTE: Dwlee

Def can see Alpaca or Cerb Vig shots tn. Likely the former unless an SK.

[Dwlee99]

I dont even have any completed games with you camn. How can you say you expect more.

[Dwlee99]

Yo nos, somehow I missed your 27 pagebottom. when did you make a case while you were scum like that?

[Nosferatu]

Yo nos, somehow I missed your 27 pagebottom. when did you make a case while you were scum like that?

red neighborhood.

[Dwlee99]

I dont even.remember that. your case most likely wasnt the same quality as the one from game shop

[Staeg]

Do we have a townbloc yet? Lets run up Alpaca or Dwlee.

unvote
vote: dwlee

[Dwlee99]

Do we have a townbloc yet? Lets run up Alpaca or Dwlee.

unvote
vote: dwlee

bleh

ok so I think I might vote nos because they didnt really make a case in red neighborhood and it seems like their response was just a way to get out of the situation kind of.
In red neighborhood he didn't make a case at all similar to the way he made a case in game shop. Although upon checking nosferatu did say, and I quote: "You shouldn't townread me off of my case on you, I can make a case on anyone. I could argue aero and frogger are scum together and they pretended to clear each other through meta that no one would bother to verify because of their portrayed confidence. Does that make me town because I bothered to actually care about the game? No, it means I saw something and I went after it, something scum can do just as easily as town." that game. This could point to it being less of a way to get out of the situation and more of something they honestly believe.

[Dwlee99]

that game is gameshop mafia, the game he made the case on davesaz.

[camntsuki]

I dont even have any completed games with you camn. How can you say you expect more.

Alpaca is a brand new rookie, joined this month.
you have scummy noms and per reports are generally active.
So don't be dense- this is not a meta argument, it's here and here alone. I expect more.

Again- why are you being so scummy?

[Nosferatu]

mfw I'm still burdened by proficiency because of a game >6 months ago.