New York 194: Guns N' Roses Mafia! (Day 8)

[Performer]

FBG = DGB.
Vote with me, old friend!

Aristo is trying to derail your Yume wagon DGB

I have thought about this a lot and have basically concluded we can only lynch Yume/Bugs (Yume) without any replacements as otherwise tomorrow is even worse than today. Take into account just how bad mislynching an active player is when you have both Yume/Bugs still in the game tomorrow and yeah.

I see your point but I'm townreading ilikebugs. Yume I placed back into null due to d4, how easily the wagon formed. I've also reread notes on dead Townies - Snark & Drixx for instance, both had KAAG as higher scumread than KTS. Based on my above case and this case - both on pg 98 - I think KAAG is more likely than KTS to be scum, but I don't see KTS being too hot as town either (ISO).

And seeing pg 98 interactions from KTS, I can agree with the 2 posts from Ari & Fire - 2445 & 2446.
VOTE: KTS

[Performer]

^ebwop that pg 98 case and this one on pg 99

Didn't realize that post would turn into a new page.

[Axl_Rose]

VC 4.3

V

o

t

e

C

o

u

n

t

4

.

3

With 12 Alive, it's 7 to Lynch!

Mod Notes:

Please do PM me immediately if there's been a gap longer than 3 days for a VC. Also, please check if your vote is accurate. Doing an official mod prod on the other heads. If they fail to respond, I will officially take over modding, but still post under this account.

Thanks,

Titus

• (1)
  KuroiXHF
  — Something_Smart,
  
  (2)
  Aristophanes
  — KickAssAndGiggle, Killthestory
  
  (2)

  Killthestory
  — KuroiXHF, Performer
  
  (1)
  Performer
  — Firebringer
  (0)
  Ilikebugs
  —
  (0)
  Firebringer
  —
  (0)
  RachMarie
  —
  (0)
  Something_Smart
  —
  (0)
  Slandaar
  —
  (0)
  Reverie
  —
  (0)
  DrippingGoofball
  —
  (1)
  KickAssAndGiggle
  — Aristophanes
  
  
  (5)
  [Not Voting]
  —
  Ilikebugs, Reverie, Slandaar, RachMarie, DrippingGoofball

- (expired on 2016-06-02 23:00:32) - Just keeping the countdown code. Deadline is paused.

[Axl_Rose]

Reverie replaces Yume. Please welcome them.

Deadline still frozen for ilikebugs replacement.

[Reverie]

Hello, friends. I warren it's a bad idea to lynch me, so let's not do that, okay, DrippingGoofball?

I've been following along a bit since Day 4 or so, but, to be honest, nothing has jumped out at me except for Aristophanes's and Firebringer's reactions to the deaths on Night 3. I had a lead that went up in smoke, so that doesn't help. It also doesn't help that there's a lot of griping about lynching empty slots, which anybunny can do. I'll breeze through it again today, but don't hold your breath about me getting through 99 pages.

About Aristophanes and Firebringer. I carrot like Aristophanes's reaction in particular because it sounded like someone knows something about what happened, but the defense of Aristophanes after the fact is puzzling and is what's stopping me from voting Aristophanes right now. Firebringer's seems genuine, I guess? Is he the kind to "fake" reactions as any alignment?

[KuroiXHF]

Why have you been following along since Day Four? If you were looking to join the game, why did you only choose to join now?

[Reverie]

Why have you been following along since Day Four? If you were looking to join the game, why did you only choose to join now?

I don't see how this is relevant.

Anyway, I was following along because I wanted to replace into the game due to the month-old outstanding replacement request, but I also didn't want to replace into a game that was 80+ pages. I checked in once in a while (hence "a bit") and then decided a bad replacement was better than no replacement at all. I'm surprised that Axl_Rose didn't just modkill Yume's slot, but that turned out to be for the best.

Worst case scenario: I troll everybunny.

[Reverie]

Back in the good old days we enjoyed a vigorous lynch and were loathe to stall it with nonsense.

Cat got your vote?

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: vote: Reverie

[DrippingGoofball]

I warren it's a bad idea to lynch me

Vague PR hints are scummy

[Reverie]

Vague PR hints are scummy

I hoppen to disagree. It's a bad idea to lynch me because I'm now a warm body. Why did you wait until Yume's slot was filled before voting?

[Something_Smart]

2460 is a terrible post. It seems to admit that it was a vague PR hint yet not actually disagree with DGB's statement.

I don't love the KAAG votes, however I also don't love KTS calling KAAG obvtown. I'm thinking there's probably exactly one scum in <KuroiXHF, Killthestory> and while I still think it's Kuroi, I would probably be open to lynching either one of them at this point.

I'd like to hear Reverie's reads in particular on DGB and Kuroi.

[KuroiXHF]

Why have you been following along since Day Four? If you were looking to join the game, why did you only choose to join now?

I don't see how this is relevant.

Anyway, I was following along because I wanted to replace into the game due to the month-old outstanding replacement request, but I also didn't want to replace into a game that was 80+ pages. I checked in once in a while (hence "a bit") and then decided a bad replacement was better than no replacement at all. I'm surprised that Axl_Rose didn't just modkill Yume's slot, but that turned out to be for the best.

Worst case scenario: I troll everybunny.

It's relevant because I'm not sure I trust you. You just came in and I tend to have a habit to town read new people, but I don't town read you at all.

[Reverie]

I'm outright ignoring any references to "vague power role hints" from this point forward.

It's relevant because I'm not sure I trust you. You just came in and I tend to have a habit to town read new people, but I don't town read you at all.

This is all well and good, but that's not where your question seemed to be going.

"Why have you been following along since Day Four?" - This question is asking me about my state of mind before I knew Yume's alignment. Therefore, the answer to this question is not alignment-indicative.

"If you were looking to join the game, why did you only choose to join now?" - This question is also asking me about my state of mind before I knew Yume's alignment. Therefore, the answer to this question is not alignment-indicative.

Thinking about the reason you gave above, then it sounds like you asked because you figured that I was reluctant to join because I was reading Yume as alignment X. Am I correct? If that was the reason, then the questions still do not make sense, not least because I joined regardless and Yume had not posted in the interim and the most anyone ever said of Yume was "Let's kill the inactive slot for the sake of the game." Still not indicative of Yume's alignment, especially if this is multiball.

[Something_Smart]

Can we not discuss a person's thoughts before they received their role PM?

Instead, Reverie, can we get some actual reads from you? Your slot owes the game a lot of content.

[KuroiXHF]

"Why have you been following along since Day Four?" - This question is asking me about my state of mind before I knew Yume's alignment. Therefore, the answer to this question is not alignment-indicative.

You saying that you've been following since Day Four happened after you came in, meaning that you could have lied. Basically, I wanted to see how you would respond. Same with the following.

"If you were looking to join the game, why did you only choose to join now?" - This question is also asking me about my state of mind before I knew Yume's alignment. Therefore, the answer to this question is not alignment-indicative.

Thinking about the reason you gave above, then it sounds like you asked because you figured that I was reluctant to join because I was reading Yume as alignment X. Am I correct?

No.

If that was the reason, then the questions still do not make sense, not least because I joined regardless and Yume had not posted in the interim and the most anyone ever said of Yume was "Let's kill the inactive slot for the sake of the game." Still not indicative of Yume's alignment, especially if this is multiball.

This is not multiball. Only one scum. Only one SK. I'm pretty confident in that.

[Firebringer]

2) Performer — Firebringer

I am double voter now, woot!
I am actually voting KTS I am pretty sure too lol.

BAD MOD!

[Aristophanes]

Yay! Anybunny is better than nobunny in this slot!
Hopefully this game will wake up with a Reverie!

What, in my reaction to the flips, looks like I had insider info? Do my reactions to any other flips also show this? Because I think you're reading too much into that.
What was interesting about FB's reaction?

Do you have any developed reads on anyone else? Any comments about the occurrences of D4?
What are your thoughts, more precisely, on the K slots (KAAG, KTS, and Kuroi), and on DGB?

[Killthestory]

and scum are on my wagon.

perf might also be scum for the chainsaw since we're in LyLo I think

[Killthestory]

MyLo*

[Killthestory]

VOTE: Kuroi

lynch this today to confirm me as town ty

[KuroiXHF]

Thanks, KTS. I sincerely mean that. This game is actually moving again.

[Aristophanes]

How the fuck are you assuming Mylo!?

12 alive, 2 dead scum.
Even if a scumteam of 5 plus an SK, a mislynch would leave us at 4:5 tomorrow, assuming both NKs go through.

[Killthestory]

someone said it was mYlO

[Aristophanes]

Someone was wrong.