Pick Your Power 6: The Revival (Game Over!)

[Katsuki]

ZZZX might be scum for making a game relevant post

You SURE he's not a CES alt? It's even the same sarcasm.

Unfortunately spiffeh lacks the beard.

[Katsuki]

this is bad because I think even at this point in the game firebringer was obv town. He did then immediately jump to spiffeh which is a town hiplop thing to do. Interested in seeing where he goes from here because usually this is about the time he finds a good vote if he's town and continues futzing around if he's scum.

What is the point of saying this

It looks like you want everyone to know you're thinking critically about the game

TSQ would not be a bad lynch.

[Spiffeh]

ZZZX was my other option. But I know already that it wouldn't fly.

Why not?

[light_ganski]

Which part of it exactly? IAI saying it would be a say day vig shot, or the second part?

The second part but considering it in context with the first part makes it worse. Looks like someone trying to deflect attention away from a partner whilst attempting to maintain plausible deniability if they flip scum (ie. along the lines of "well I said he would be a safe kill").

I see more of a fence sitting position, so he can transition his town read to a scum read if the town happens to go that direction.

I say that with a townread on House, though.

He seems suspicious to me, but the first point I made about him still stands.

[Spiffeh]

Do you have specifics on why you are townreading those three? Or thoughts on any of the conversations that have been going on?

I think openly claiming roles is something town is more likely to do

And Fire Assassin is just obvtown

[Spiffeh]

ZZZX might be scum for making a game relevant post

You SURE he's not a CES alt? It's even the same sarcasm.

It wasn't sarcasm

[Spiffeh]

Aristophanes is reaching really far to make House's strongman claim look scummy

There's other stuff going on

[UpTooLate]

Aristophanes is reaching really far to make House's strongman claim look scummy

There's other stuff going on

What do you think of Light then?

[GreyICE]

Do you have specifics on why you are townreading those three? Or thoughts on any of the conversations that have been going on?

I think openly claiming roles is something town is more likely to do

And Fire Assassin is just obvtown

Not obvious to me.

So your statement that ZZZX is scummy for posting actual game related content was

serious

?

Mind expounding on that a bit?

[hebichan]

Now who IS town is Hebi, because I know her and I know she'd listen to her scumteam, and there's no way a scum team rubber stamps "spend your points on neighbor topics so you can chat with your neighbors while you chat with your neighbors."

I was thinking about this, and would it really be a bad idea? I mean, they take it out of town's hands, and not only that, they could cause a lot of WIFOM with it. Say she's scum, and neighborizes 4 (I think that's how many slots she said she had?) other scum. Town don't have the opportunity to scumhunt elsewhere, and then if she gets killed, we're forced to try to figure out who she would try to neighborize alignment wise. Would she neighborize her scumbuddies? If so, how many? I can see it more than likely making some people in the neighborhood townread on that alone, which would be fantastic for scum.

Alternatively I decided to pick those roles before I even knew my alignment because I thought it would be wonderful to be a double double neighborizer. I might have even tried to go for three but switched to two later on.

Honestly speculating on what I would or wouldn't do with my neighbor slots before I use them seems silly. Also there are only 4 scum total in this set up, so I could not neighborize "4 other scum".

I don't think you're scum, but I think you're thinking too hard on my motivations.

...................................................................................................................
UNVOTE:

VOTE: I am Innocent

.... I, on the other hand think this is pretty good. That buddy to house was too good. It was also like a semi-claim here.

[UpTooLate]

Alternatively I decided to pick those roles before I even knew my alignment because I thought it would be wonderful to be a double double neighborizer. I might have even tried to go for three but switched to two later on.

Honestly speculating on what I would or wouldn't do with my neighbor slots before I use them seems silly. Also there are only 4 scum total in this set up, so I could not neighborize "4 other scum".

I don't think you're scum, but I think you're thinking too hard on my motivations.

I got mixed up, I was thinking there were 6 scum in this one, so my apologies. However, I'm not so much questioning your motivations as I am pointing out that I think GI clearing you based on you being a neighborizer isn't necessarily as solid as he seems to think it is.

Also, can you answer the question I asked you about voting Spiffeh, please?

[hiplop]

ZZZX might be scum for making a game relevant post

true.

isn't it a little early to start bussing, scummeh?

[SuddenlyARabbit]

Woah. First time playing on here, as I've only played werewolf on another forum before. This feels like crazy levels of discussion and guessing for day one.

[hebichan]

Woah. First time playing on here, as I've only played werewolf on another forum before. This feels like crazy levels of discussion and guessing for day one.

Get used to it. I've seen 70 pages for day one.

[Cephrir]

Welcome to mafiascum we talk a lot

[hebichan]

as for spiifeh, almost all of his posts have been to defend people or discredit scumreads.

[Aristophanes]

am i the only one who didn't think scum got to discuss their bids

They did. It says so in the scum sample pm.

P.edit - This post didn't load properly and u somehow got multininjad. At least the game is active!

[Aristophanes]

Man like this is so over the top I feel like you're trying to fake a town slip here.

that sequence of posts was in no way something i couldn't fake and should not be taken as such

because self meta is gr8.

[Cephrir]

Man like this is so over the top I feel like you're trying to fake a town slip here.

that sequence of posts was in no way something i couldn't fake and should not be taken as such

because self meta is gr8.

i was saying you shouldn't think i was town for that reason. that's sort of the opposite of self meta.

[UpTooLate]

as for spiifeh, almost all of his posts have been to defend people or discredit scumreads.

Not when you voted him, though.

You voted him at 96, and at that point, he had made the following posts:

k

VOTE: hebichan

hi LLD

Interestingly enough, your vote came right after hiplop started the Spiffeh wagon with LLD, and then he called you scum.

Your very next post after your Spiffeh vote was to join the new wagon that was gaining momentum, IAI.

In fact, all of the posts that you are saying were just to defend people or discredit scumreads were made AFTER your Spiffeh vote and BEFORE you switched your vote to IAI.

This doesn't add up.

VOTE: hebichan

[UpTooLate]

Alternatively I decided to pick those roles before I even knew my alignment because I thought it would be wonderful to be a double double neighborizer. I might have even tried to go for three but switched to two later on.

Honestly speculating on what I would or wouldn't do with my neighbor slots before I use them seems silly. Also there are only 4 scum total in this set up, so I could not neighborize "4 other scum".

I don't think you're scum, but I think you're thinking too hard on my motivations.

This was far more defensive than it needed to be, as I wasn't actually accusing you of anything at all. I was just pointing out a hole in GI's thinking.

[implosion]

Vote Count 1.3

I Am Innocent (3): Cephrir, Spiffeh, hebichan
Spiffeh (2): hiplop, Lady Lambdadelta
Lady Lambdadelta (2): Fire Assassin, I Am Innocent
Fire Assassin (2): Katsuki, GreyICE
hebichan (2): House, UpTooLate
UpTooLate (1): Thestatusquo
House (1): Aristophanes

Not Voting (5): light_ganski, SuddenlyARabbit, UnexpectedAnvil, zMuffinMan, ZZZX


With 18 alive, it takes 10 votes to lynch.
Deadline is on June 19 at 3:00 AM EST, in (expired on 2016-06-19 03:00:00).

@mod:

Can we please get a line break between the people being

bored

voted and those not voting in future vote counts?

Can do.

@Mod I am going on a retreat to hone my skills in my fighting skills. I shall not return for a few days. Do not replace me. I shall hopefully return by Thursday. Thank you.

Noted.

[House]

I Am Innocent, why did you feel the need to insinuate that you even MIGHT have done the same thing I did?

I'm seeing no town motivation at all for doing so. Mine at least informed town there was a lack of a strongman in this game, your post looks weird.

[House]

Also, Spiffeh went from voting for hebichan to being on the same wagon with hebichan.

Spiffeh, did your read of hebichan change (and if so, why?), or do you think scum would already be bussing?

[House]

That is possibly the worst vote you could have made.

Why?
I dislike his logics and I agree that he may be scum who didn't get the Strongman, and is posing as town because of it.
ZZZX was my other option. But I know already that it wouldn't fly.

ITT: Aristophanes is butthurt that I deprived him off his role.

VOTE: Aristophanes