New York 194: Guns N' Roses Mafia! (Day 8)

[Axl_Rose]

Aristophanes, Vanilla Townie

was killed Night 4. It is now Day 5.

Aero will be along shortly to make the thread look pretty.

Day 5 starts now.

[Performer]

Hmm. One death again.
We have so many VTs. I'm starting to dread this setup.

[Performer]

Sigh.

I feel like I'm coming to my wit's end in this game. Very frustrated .

Sigh.

pk I miss you, we clearly needed your powers very much for this game.

[Killthestory]

I shot Fragger and Aris, basically conf town. Now let's figure out who scum is since I'm out of shots

[Performer]

I shot Fragger and Aris, basically conf town. Now let's figure out who scum is since I'm out of shots

...you are our 2-shot Vig ?

What do you make of our recent night that only 1 death?
I'm curious, KTS, who do

you

think is scum?

[Performer]

ebwop: that only had 1 death

[Killthestory]

Thought Aris was some sort of SK, so I shot them. That's where 1 death came from.

I'm thinking SK is trying to play himself off as town, maybe??? I don't see another town role with killing potential, or it's possible it was mafia with a 1 shot.

Clearly there was a BP or doctor, potentially jailkeeper, who shouldn't out themselves now, but if it comes down to it, should confirm themselves as town later on.

[Something_Smart]

I'm going to have to look at some ISOs because odds are one of my townreads is wrong.

[Killthestory]

so heres the thing.

fires defence of Kuroi is town, but the rest of his play is scummy. like, i cant shake the feeling he defended town because he knew himself he was scum. his entire play doesn't fit his town meta, and it's really bothering me

[Firebringer]

I would like you to lynch me, you being town in this scenario just baffles me.

[Killthestory]

I would like you to lynch me, you being town in this scenario just baffles me.

shut up

VOTE: Fire

gonna leave that there since I still don't like fire

[Firebringer]

Good. I still don't like to think you are really town.

[Slandaar]

I don't know. I'm going to have to reread.

[Something_Smart]

VOTE: Fire
Doubtcasting the conftown is a huge scumtell.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Fire
Doubtcasting the conftown is a huge scumtell.

What a scum claim.

[Firebringer]

That is a post I would have posted if I were scum.
LOL, like almost word for word.

I would have said something like "Trying to see if its still possible to lynch KTS, huh?"

[Firebringer]

That was just funny to read.

[Something_Smart]

I'm comfortable with my vote.

[Slandaar]

The longer the game goes on and Slandaar is still alive, the stranger I think his reads on Ari & Guy/RachMarie are. He also mentioned scumreading Kop/Ari, Frag, Ozgin, Guy, and Drixx a while back, and

I don't recall observing anyone else hitting 2 scum out of their reads lists.

How would you know if anyone else hit 2 scum in their reads lists Performer?

[Slandaar]

Yeah that is awful sorry I missed it before.

VOTE: Performer

[Slandaar]

He also has the power of foresight:

Ozgin's playerslot is conftown.

Good luck on your exams!

I would be very wary of saying something is confirmed anything unless the mod is involved (Innocent Child for instance).

I can see where Killthestory's coming from on pg 91 , regarding Kuroi. I'd like us to wagon Ari first though . Scumread on him is higher than on Kuroi - also placing a bit of trust into Slandaar's reply to me. If we're wrong about Ari, we can look into Slandaar .

This reminds me of Frag's constant push on ira since d1, and Frag turned out scum.
Slandaar I really hope you are right about that slot.

All makes sense.

There is more but I don't think more is required. It's clear. Lynch Performer be happy.

[Performer]

@Slandaar because at the time, I couldn't think of anyone other than you who hit 2 scum in your scumreads. It seemed way too exact so I was noting it as "coincidence? Or more than that?"
In terms of the foresight accusation - I brought that up because it's incorrect FM theory from Dripping, to make a rash assumption like that.

On a related note, thanks for bringing that up - I went to the page for the 1917 post, page 77. I saw interactions regarding Aris, Frag, KAAG, Drip, Ozgin.
I'm thinking KAAG or Drip today.
VOTE: Dripping
Tunneled a rookie slot (Yume/Reverie) that said she's town (typically turns out to be the case when rookies claim that in FM), does a completely mysterious reverse of her scumread on Reverie at end of d3 . Plus she stated Ozgin was conftown.
---
Still waiting to see the rest of the players post something of substance for this phase. I've been wrestling with an idea for awhile but I feel like the timing isn't quite right yet.

[Performer]

^ebwop: as in the rest of the players who haven't posted yet after n4.

[Performer]

Good. I still don't like to think you are really town.

But Fire, he just claimed....

[Performer]

VOTE: Fire
Doubtcasting the conftown is a huge scumtell.

Wait, let me get this straight. KTS claimed, Fire stated he doubted KTS was town because KTS's behavior was baffling to him in this game, SS voted Fire because Fire merely expressed his thought, SS also KTS is conftown - something that Drip stated about Ozgin on pg 77 but Ozgin turned out to be scum.

What in the.