Pick Your Power 6: The Revival (Game Over!)

[Spiffeh]

pie why do you think randomidget is town?

[Katsuki]

You have just voteparked Muffin all day for no reason and have been buddying the fuck out of LLD and GI all game

And now kuribo

Clearly if I had no reason I wouldn't be voteparking Muffin all day.

LLD is my mason buddy always and forever~

Kuribo taught me how to navigate the internet.

[Spiffeh]

How much do you know of my town game, when you call me scum every time I'm town?

In the games that I'm talking about you actually did something substantial by Day 2

And your immediate reaction to me calling you out is to discredit me by saying I'm always wrong about you

Which is incorrect because I read you as town correctly in Fate's game and kuribo in Wonderland, 2 out of the 3 games I remember playing with you

So no

[Creature]

Townreads:

Cephrir

GreyICE

House

I Am Innocent

Katsuki

kuribo
MURDERCAT
pieguyn

randomidget

Spiffeh
zMuffinMan

These are my questionable reads, the others look pretty much town.

[Spiffeh]

Creature vote for randomidget

[Creature]

VOTE: randomidget

Okay

[Creature]

Is Aris going to tomorrow?

[Spiffeh]

Clearly if I had no reason I wouldn't be voteparking Muffin all day.

LLD is my mason buddy always and forever~

Kuribo taught me how to navigate the internet.

This is no excuse for exclusively interacting with them about things that aren't even game relevant

[Katsuki]

How much do you know of my town game, when you call me scum every time I'm town?

In the games that I'm talking about you actually did something substantial by Day 2

And your immediate reaction to me calling you out is to discredit me by saying I'm always wrong about you

Which is incorrect because I read you as town correctly in Fate's game and kuribo in Wonderland, 2 out of the 3 games I remember playing with you

So no

Gumball mafia overrode everything it seems. Along with [REDACTED].

Oh well~

[pieguyn]

pie why do you think randomidget is town?

I don't think rando is town, I just think ICE is a much better chance at hitting scum. I meant to get to this earlier, but about him mostly asking vague/neutral questions, I agree with your point here but on a gut level I don't think the way he's going about it is malicious; rando doesn't strike me as someone who usually strongly pushes his reads and none of the questions specifically read as disingenuous to me. in this case I think it looks more like "what he's doing isn't accomplishing anything but he's trying as hard as he can" rather than him deliberately trying to stay on the sidelines.

if I'm wrong in assuming this let me know. were there questions you specifically disliked, or is it a general issue?

[Katsuki]

Clearly if I had no reason I wouldn't be voteparking Muffin all day.

LLD is my mason buddy always and forever~

Kuribo taught me how to navigate the internet.

This is no excuse for exclusively interacting with them about things that aren't even game relevant

It kinda is.

I think I spoiled you with too much excellence and awesomeness.

[Spiffeh]

I look forward to shoving a wagon down your throat tomorrow cupcake <3

[Katsuki]

Good luck ever making that happen~ <3

[Spiffeh]

pie I have town meta of randomidget that showcases he is more than capable of having strong opinions and pushing his reads

So yes I do believe he is deliberately trying to stay under the radar and letting the Muffin/GI thing take over, especially since he's one of the prime candidates for the lynch

[Spiffeh]

pie I have town meta of randomidget that showcases he is more than capable of having strong opinions and pushing his reads

Granted he hasn't made the BEST pushes but there is never an absence of strong opinions like there is here

[pieguyn]

pie I have town meta of randomidget that showcases he is more than capable of having strong opinions and pushing his reads

So yes I do believe he is deliberately trying to stay under the radar and letting the Muffin/GI thing take over, especially since he's one of the prime candidates for the lynch

which games are you using as a reference for this?

[Katsuki]

I think you'll remember this quote from GI, spiff.

one of your (Katsuki's) premier talents is to remain alive for unholy lengths of time

[Spiffeh]

@pie
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... ct[]=23566
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=64487

ISO him in these games

[Creature]

I've played with him at Open 638.

[kuribo]

You have just voteparked Muffin all day for no reason and have been buddying the fuck out of LLD and GI all game

And now kuribo

katsuki always buddies me regardless of alignment; we've known each other since before the mafiascum days

[Spiffeh]

What's your read on him?

[Katsuki]

You have just voteparked Muffin all day for no reason and have been buddying the fuck out of LLD and GI all game

And now kuribo

katsuki always buddies me regardless of alignment; we've known each other since before the mafiascum days

Friends interact with each other as if they were friends, who would've thought!

[kuribo]

What's your read on him?

he's a non-entity in this game


which honestly worries me more than the "buddying" but it's a well-documented fact I can't read katsuki and he knows that, so it's not like I can apply pressure

i have stronger scum reads, but i'm not willing to call him town, so i guess a null non-entity would be the way i see it. frankly, i keep forgetting he's here.

[zMuffinMan]

Grey's response is convincing though

... what? what response was convincing?

<snip>

notice again that greyice isn't directly answering the questions i've asked:

i asked him, in recent pages, to name 3-4 scum reads (i even linked the posts in which i ask this). tell me how anything in #1912 answers this. can anyone at all tell me who greyice is currently scum-reading apart from me? anyone? and before you say the UTL slot, he's been going on and on about how he can't figure out whether i'm her buddy or whether i'm white knighting her, etc, so even that isn't clear

his response to this in #1912 is to link to two posts i made and suggest i'm not looking for answers

i've already gone over every single point he said about UTL in #1912 and literally all he's doing here is repeating the same things he's already said without addressing the issues i've raised about this...

and finally, when i ask where i lied or what i ignored, rather than bring up quotes and evidence of things i lied about or ignored, he just makes statements as though they're fact...

i have literally said i will admit i'm wrong and drop the entire point if he provides just ONE QUOTE of where i lied before he accused me of being a liar - ONE QUOTE... and he can't do it

i'm so fucking shit of people saying, "oh greyice is making good points..." you clearly haven't read shit if you think this

[zMuffinMan]

can anyone who thinks greyice has made even a single good point about anything, let alone me, quote it or at least reference it