Open 643: Kill All Townies! (Game Over)

[Chip Butty]

Sads lack of a vote for a scum claim is skeevy

Smithereens looks like they are reaching a bit?

Also, almost 50 is vibiing town.

In other news, ranger still can't read me.

Doing a reread. This rings scumhunting for me. You get the Jae seal of approval.

Also rings as town for the last bit about Ranger not being able to read you.

Eh? So all someone has to do for the Jae seal of approval is string together three vague reads ("looks like they are reaching a bit?", "vibing Town")?

And how is thinking that Ranger can't read her AI? She might as well have just said "I am Town". Expressing that sentiment in a slightly different way doesn't make it Towner.

[Almost50]

Believe me, if I could choose the lynch of the day, it would be you.

DixC just isn't as bad as Jae or LQ.

I would agree, as my top 3 lynches are Jae, House & LQ, but I wanted someone to make a case so I could see if I had missed something.

[Almost50]

@Almost50 you're basically saying you don't wanna read the game.

Not so, but I'm not seeing an actual case on Dix other than his relative low activity.

[pistachi0n]

I don't want to vote Dix, I will if there are less than 24 hours left and he has the most votes. I'd strongly prefer Jae or LQ.

[KuroiXHF]

I don't want to vote Dix, I will if there are less than 24 hours left and he has the most votes. I'd strongly prefer Jae or LQ.

This reeks of scum.

[JaeReed]

Sads lack of a vote for a scum claim is skeevy

Smithereens looks like they are reaching a bit?

Also, almost 50 is vibiing town.

In other news, ranger still can't read me.

Doing a reread. This rings scumhunting for me. You get the Jae seal of approval.

Also rings as town for the last bit about Ranger not being able to read you.

Eh? So all someone has to do for the Jae seal of approval is string together three vague reads ("looks like they are reaching a bit?", "vibing Town")?

And how is thinking that Ranger can't read her AI? She might as well have just said "I am Town". Expressing that sentiment in a slightly different way doesn't make it Towner.

Not quite. You know I like my tone & gut reads. I like the way she went about expressing it here. It's like how you claimed you didn't mind being lynched in trees vs how kappy did it. There are town and non town ways to express that Ranger can't read her and that was a town way imo.

[Almost50]

My problem with the Dix lynch (he's null on my reads) mainly stems from the fact all 3 of my scum reads ARE on his wagon. I'm not comfortable voting with all 3 of them. If it was one I would have probably over looked it, bc this is MB AND I could be wrong.

VOTE: Jae

[Almost50]

P.S. For what it's worth, Jae & LQ are NOT of the same faction.

[karnos]

Vote LicketyQuickety for lynch, 2016. Make Town great again!

To sum this up, I am not a role model on how to play.. I have funky reasoning that no one gets, I don't play by the book and I miss a lot of really obvious stuff that causes a lot of heat on me.

This. Can't tell if you are being sarcastic or serious. Either way it's a common scum tell.

Scum constantly acts sarcastic in the thread so that when he makes an actual scum slip he can just call it "OBVIOUS SARCASM".

In the alternate universe where LQ is being serious, he is basically saying he acts like scum all the time, so if you read him as scum it's really just his town game that looks like scum. Yeah sure dude, nice cover.

Here's my

would

lynch pile:

KuroiXHF
Charloux
JaeReed
karnos
House
Creature
pistachi0n

Seven names and you would happy to lynch any of them. I guess it would be too obvious if you listed everyone outside of your scum team, so you had to draw the line somewhere, right? I just find this odd. Usually you try to find scum, and then lynch the most likely scum. I don't think I have ever seen a towny before say he was willing to lynch any of SEVEN different "scum".

Links or it didn't happen.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 1#p8023311

One lousy link is the best you could do, huh? Not buying it with one game. You implied multiple games you have see this, unless you are just really new to this game and think one game means something.

This is incredibly telling to me. You complain about it just being a single link, but you obviously didn't even click on it. I linked back to this very game, it's not another game's example. You aren't trying to solve the game, you are just trying to respond and look like you are busy without doing the work.

[pistachi0n]

I don't want to vote Dix, I will if there are less than 24 hours left and he has the most votes. I'd strongly prefer Jae or LQ.

This reeks of scum.

This reeks of scum.

[Smithereens]

I don't want to vote Dix, I will if there are less than 24 hours left and he has the most votes. I'd strongly prefer Jae or LQ.

This reeks of scum.

This reeks of scum.

This reeks of scum.

[Chip Butty]

I don't want to vote Dix, I will if there are less than 24 hours left and he has the most votes. I'd strongly prefer Jae or LQ.

This reeks of scum.

How so? I'm not seeing it, as I have said stuff similar to that when Town. Could you please explain explicitly what is scummy about it?

Ninja'd Smithereens

[KuroiXHF]

It sounds town when you want to vote someone, but express hesitation.

I got the biggest scum vibe from it.

[pistachi0n]

I don't want to vote Dix, I will if there are less than 24 hours left and he has the most votes. I'd strongly prefer Jae or LQ.

This reeks of scum.

How so? I'm not seeing it, as I have said stuff similar to that when Town. Could you please explain explicitly what is scummy about it?

Ninja'd Smithereens

House is being overly confrontational without anything to back it up. It strikes me as lazy scum looking for small things to jump on. Which is not as much of a tell as it would be otherwise because multiball, but I still don't like it.

[LicketyQuickety]

Vote LicketyQuickety for lynch, 2016. Make Town great again!

To sum this up, I am not a role model on how to play.. I have funky reasoning that no one gets, I don't play by the book and I miss a lot of really obvious stuff that causes a lot of heat on me.

This. Can't tell if you are being sarcastic or serious. Either way it's a common scum tell.

Scum constantly acts sarcastic in the thread so that when he makes an actual scum slip he can just call it "OBVIOUS SARCASM".

In the alternate universe where LQ is being serious, he is basically saying he acts like scum all the time, so if you read him as scum it's really just his town game that looks like scum. Yeah sure dude, nice cover.

Please, I'm not stupid. I am prepared to link MORE games to prove my point, but you didn't ask about that because you are Scum trying to shade me. Consider the context here.. I was being serious. Jae went on and on about how they idolize Ranger, so I was simply pointing out that I am not someone to be idolized.

Here's my

would

lynch pile:

KuroiXHF
Charloux
JaeReed
karnos
House
Creature
pistachi0n

Seven names and you would happy to lynch any of them. I guess it would be too obvious if you listed everyone outside of your scum team, so you had to draw the line somewhere, right? I just find this odd. Usually you try to find scum, and then lynch the most likely scum. I don't think I have ever seen a towny before say he was willing to lynch any of SEVEN different "scum".

Again, you lack context because you are trying to provide a case on me as Scum. Its day 1, which means we have prolly the worst chance at our reads being correct at this time. I am not only stating here what people I thinki are Scum, but what people will also have a good chance at being problematic going forward in this game. Furthermore these are old reads and mine have changed since.. specifically since rereading the thread.

Links or it didn't happen.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 1#p8023311

One lousy link is the best you could do, huh? Not buying it with one game. You implied multiple games you have see this, unless you are just really new to this game and think one game means something.

This is incredibly telling to me. You complain about it just being a single link, but you obviously didn't even click on it. I linked back to this very game, it's not another game's example. You aren't trying to solve the game, you are just trying to respond and look like you are busy without doing the work.

Believe it or not this makes you look more guilty than me.. What is one game going to tell me? A lot of crazy shit happens in a game once. You implied this happened multiple times and that it was a pattern that you have noticed. The fact that you can't back this up properly is what is really telling IMO. I called you out on this saying you are lying if you couldn't provide more than one link and you STILL have yet to do that.



Let me ask you something: how well do you think you are doing this game?

[KuroiXHF]

I am not House. And I don't need to justify scum vibes.

[DixC]

There's no disagreeing with it any more, VOTE: JaeReed for Mafia (and/or Werewolf, or, whatever scum-species indeterminate term is preferred; or not). I agree LQ & Jae are playing like different factions, so one gives a great deal of tell on the other.

[LicketyQuickety]

Karnos, I visited you link and it seems you can't even provide one game where Scum have acted like they were not Scum after a lynch. If you can't even provide one lousy link, then I am going to do this:

VOTE: Karnos

[LicketyQuickety]

There's no disagreeing with it any more, VOTE: JaeReed for Mafia (and/or Werewolf, or, whatever scum-species indeterminate term is preferred; or not). I agree LQ & Jae are playing like different factions, so one gives a great deal of tell on the other.

Its funny that you say this cuz I was actually starting to come around to the idea that Jae could be Town here.

[Chip Butty]

I am not House.

You sure as fuck look like him, though. Seriously, you could be the guy's body double.

[Chip Butty]

At least, face double...

[Chip Butty]

This is incredibly telling to me. You complain about it just being a single link, but you obviously didn't even click on it. I linked back to this very game, it's not another game's example. You aren't trying to solve the game, you are just trying to respond and look like you are busy without doing the work.

Karnos, I visited you link and it seems you can't even provide one game where Scum have acted like they were not Scum after a lynch. If you can't even provide one lousy link, then I am going to do this:

VOTE: Karnos

Once again the "dumb or scum" question raises it's ugly head...

[KuroiXHF]

I am not House.

You sure as fuck look like him, though. Seriously, you could be the guy's body double.

A piece of shit may look like chocolate mousse, but I'm not going to put it on a birthday cake.

[pistachi0n]

VOTE: Jae

[JaeReed]

So out of curiosity what's this magical case you guys have? I wanna see it so I know which of you is dumb and which is scum.