New York 196: My Game, My Flavor Mafia (Mafia Win)

[Transcend]

I'ma bring up a point I brought up in a previous game. Mind you, I was scum in that game, and in this game my alignment is opposite of that.

Regardless: The more power roles that town have, the more powerful prs that scum have. I.E. possibly a strongman to counter all these protective roles. So I really don't think a Neapolitan mafia was the most powerful role on the mafia team we have. I think there is probably at least one more role powerful than NM.

[Transcend]

Setup spec is dumb and I'm not gonna do it for the duration of over one post, I'm just giving some food for thought in terms of "well ______ is obvious town for voting mafia pr".

[Transcend]

And honestly guys, Neapolitan is a pretty weak role in the first place. It's a watered down version of role cop which gets the EXACT role of someone as opposed to "vanilla" or "not vanilla".

[Airick10]

because what moderator in their right mind would conceive of the idea of a backup nurse without a nurse

if they were going for something like that they would just put a nurse without a doctor or a deputy without a cop. Those are sort of standby choices (along with miller) for moderators looking to add a named townie to a setup. They wouldn't think of it.

Well, we don't KNOW there isn't a deputy (or a Cop with no deputy for that matter). The former become "already done" in response to your suggestion, while the latter becomes "no can do".

Now as for the doctor -and precisely for our case here in this game- I guess the setup needed one. So, I'm MERELY SPECULATING- that either a Cop OR a Deputy is in play and thus the mod got cornered between including a Backup Nurse w/o there being a Nurse or adding a Backup Deputy.

Obviously I'm NOT an expert in setup balancing (I only modded one game that had a fixed standard open setup and still somehow managed to slip up to confirm TWO players roles, so I'll just shut up now!)

This is interesting discussion as this is only speculation it being a closed game, so I don't want to read too much into this and I think it's quite a challenge to try and figure that out blind. But a couple questions.

- Implosion, I agree that adding a backup nurse or deputy without a nurse or deputy is pretty crazy. So are you saying if there is a backup nurse, there can only be a nurse without a doctor? What would a nurse be able to do without a doctor? And with this logic, do you believe Mirhawk's/Varsoon's claims?

- A50, all of this sounds like speculation. Again, an interesting discussion, but I'm not sure how much we are going to get trying to solve GIF's puzzle.

Right now, I'm leaning on voting on PV... I just haven't seen anything of value coming from him here in D2.

[Transcend]

pv is a minimal information flip

but given it's him vs. the doctor vs. kraska the obvtown

i'd lynch him in that pool of 3

maybe if we got some boem/implosion momentum hmmmhmhmmmhmmm

[Airick10]

Yes, there's not much info he's giving us. But at the same time, we aren't giving him much of a reason to participate. Actually, we've learned quite a bit here in D2 overall.

[kraska77]

I don't mind lynching him either
But
Can't remember who said this but apparently he lurks as both alignments but his lurking when he's scum is more calculated
He's been involved in day 1's lynch wagon and Mirhawk's near lynch. Day 2 is going to end in another wagon ofc so i think if he's scum, his involvement with 3 wagons can give enough clues
Which is why I'd rather we look into him day 3
If u want pressure on boem I'll help

[Transcend]

VOTE: Boem

[kraska77]

VOTE: boem [/boem]

[kraska77]

Lmao

[kraska77]

VOTE: boem

[Boem_u_dusi]

And what are you dumbasses trying to achieve with this?

[Transcend]

hopefully a mafia lynch that i've wanted to achieve for quite some time now honestly.

[Boem_u_dusi]

I sense a disappointment in your near future

[Boem_u_dusi]

How come you never explained why you scumread me?

[Transcend]

i have

[Boem_u_dusi]

nope

[Transcend]

ignorance is bliss

[Boem_u_dusi]

you must be a very happy man

[Airick10]

I'd rather go here.

Vote: PeregrineV

- He was on the original 5 voting block on Vedith, the same 5 I suspect somewhere in there is scum that bussed Vedith.
- He hasn't contributed much of anything. Post 3896 illustrates this as implosion asks valid questions and he pretty much dismisses them. For example:

2) give reads on more than two players when you've been playing the game for 140+ pages

I have a few more, but they are not relevant to the current discussion. If and when they are, I'll give them.

I'm still awaiting these reads...

- This goes into reason 3, actively not actually hunting for scum and the vote on Mirhawk - post 3205, certainly looks like following another wagon.

[Zachstralkita]

Okay... so that happened...

I don't know if I feel good about a Boem lynch. Since you FUCKS won't lynch kraska I'm willing to go podo or PeregrineV.

Transcend im going to kill you in your fucking sleep

[kraska77]

Silence, fool
Can you like
pipe down and chair the symposium?
Podo has been crumbling pr for a while now btw

[kraska77]

Crumbing*

[Transcend]

VOTE: PV

fuck it

[kraska77]

Ugh fine
VOTE: pv