Newbie 1724 ~ Endgame

[Zyf]

there's a difference between humor that isn't alignment-related (puns, references to outside literature/art in responses, etc)
and alignment humor
I can't help it
You making jokes about how you or someone else *might* be scum just puts me on edge

For example, if you made a post that rhymed and someone called you out for having a misleading username I'd just laugh and move on
but if you made a post that rhymed and someone was all like "Wow, you've got a lot of time to goof around, I bet you're scum" and then called it a joke 2 posts later I wouldn't be half as OK as in example 1.

That's just me.

Where is everyone by the way i mean it's like saturday

[Impoetic]

But see, if they said that, I'd believe it was a joke because it makes far more sense for it to be a joke than it does for it NOT to be such.

[Impoetic]

This whole argument has made me feel incredibly bad for my poor sense of humor, FWIW. It was pretty much pointless and all it did was stir this up. Genuinely sorry I didn't think of something better and realize those were still gonna be inappropriate -- especially the last one.

[KittyMo]

Vote Count 1.13

[4] PkmSilver ~ LicketyQuickety, JaeReed Zyf, frog
[2] LicketyQuickety ~ Thor665, Impoetic
[1] GreenNope ~ Dewy
[1] Thor665 ~ GreenNope

[1] Not Voting ~ PkmSilver

With

9

alive, it's

5

to lynch!

Deadline is at (expired on 2016-07-20 18:00:00)

Searching for GreenNope replacement.

[Zyf]

This whole argument has made me feel incredibly bad for my poor sense of humor, FWIW. It was pretty much pointless and all it did was stir this up. Genuinely sorry I didn't think of something better and realize those were still gonna be inappropriate -- especially the last one.

dw it's fine
for today anyway

your humor just puts >>me<< on edge.

[Zyf]

well you see impoetic
in my short time on MS I've already seen jokes be used as WIFOM
I can't elaborate more b/c ongoing games

[Impoetic]

Alright fair enough, but I promise you I'd never ever use that as WIFOM for obvious reasons. At least you'll see when I flip, and I'll know better than to say things like that on this website.

Also I just realized I was wrong when I thought you hammered. That's probably good from a mechanical standpoint because -- as I said -- I'm of the belief that PKM is genuine, but tbqh I was kinda relieved the day was over and I'd see someone's flip. ;-; I'm bad @ scumhunting

[Zyf]

i wouldn't hammer pkm with no claim
but I'm pretty sure they need a prod by now

[Zyf]

Yep

@Mod-Has PkmSilver been prodded?

Indeed ~Mod

[Thor665]

in my short time on MS I've already seen jokes be used as WIFOM

Everything is WIFOM.

[Zyf]

i guess
aside from PR claims

[Thor665]

Those are also WIFOM, even in Open games.

[Dewy]

you mean he's clearly not PR?
VOTE: Impoetic
Scumslip?

Wait, it's

you

again.

The whole of my last post was me attempting to snarkily reiterate myself about how PKM is obviously claiming blue and if he claimed PR it would be a scumslip so I probably shouldn't have said it in the first place but whatever, he wasn't about to come back and magically see the two posts where I pointed out that he said "Lynch me if you want" and he probably wasn't going to claim PR anyway because he is likely blue.

What do you mean by blue? Blue as in VT?

Scumslips usually involve logic, not wording. Even if I hadn't meant to say exactly what you asked about, it wouldn't be a scumslip!

Not necessary. Scumslips can involve anything that's a scum claim.

[Zyf]

Like fakeclaiming doc in a newbie game and then saying you self-protected
Like i did today
"It's just a joke bro"
Yeah no

[Dewy]

*WHEN* PKM flips

villager

.

And I don't

know

he's villager, obviously, but that's my guess about his alignment at this point and it certainly seems to be his claim. ~_^

These two statements kind of contradict each other.

[Dewy]

Silver needs to get in here and respond what we asked him.

[Dewy]

No lolhammers please.

[Dewy]

Also many people have been calling me experienced but this is my first game IMO. I townread those two because the way they interact are really townie and I think that mafia wouldn't have interaction lines like that.

What about those interactions make them town?

[Dewy]

Alright let me re-read to tell you, my whereabouts on this read.

Started looking scum:

...Wooper (WHO CAN USE ICE PUNCH, WHILE HAVING NO ARMS!)

ice bodyslam

there is seldom more than one vote (but we do have two votes on pkmsilver )

Honestly, I understand why someone would vote for them (RVS), but two is a tad bit suspicious, though it may be a coincidence.In my first game, the IC (who was town) joined bandwagon during RVS so it WOULDN'T be pointless. As you just said, 1 vote doesn't create pressure, so joining a bandwagon makes it better. There's no incentive for mafia to try to get someone lynched during RVS when they know it is RVS unless they're severely mistaken about the length of a normal day phase, imo. (I did try to argue that before so it looked like I was scumhunting, though, as mafia.)

I think your hesitation and brushing off your reads as coincidence is far more likely to be a scumtell, if any has been dropped at all on page 1.

I wrote that before seeing page 2, but there's nothing really to say about what's here. @Lick: Maybe if it continues, but so far, there was only one post and it was, if anything, helping discussion get started earlier.

VOTE: GreenNope

And she looked town here:

Frick. Sorry, I got this game ocnfused with the other one already. Yeah, I managed to forget that you were one of the primary people SRing GreenNope. Not counting RVS, was there a third player you voted that I've forgotten about too? u_u;

I said "tunnel" because the past few(?) pages have been primarily you two debating back and forth. That might not qualify as such, but it's what caused me to feel assured in using the word, at the time, along with getting the details of everything utterly mixed up. I'm sorry.

Somehow, despite reading all your posts, I haven't gotten the gist of your arguments.

Man, this is embarrassing. I guess I'll definitely be trying to reread some tonight. It just seems like a bunch of small thing you guys are getting on each others' cases about, from what I've seen. What do you think of Dewy? it seems like everyone but him has been considered despite his posts all being fairly low-key. I guess the GreenNope/Lick team makes sense, but more because Lickety would turn on Green as maf with GN town here than anything else.

Sorry once more. :c

Quote tag fix -Mod

Still missing the question. Like what about those make them town/scum.

[Zyf]

Yes dewy we all agree
I just think pkm siteflaked so atp we're playing a D1 6 person game
Meaning we have a super high chance to ML

[Dewy]

@Silver

At first the way she was talking looked scummy to me, but after a while her way of talking was more townie-looking. I think that's the mostly way I was scumreading her.

What about her talking

make them scummy or townie?

I'm trying dude, and I am still fairly new and you guys are having hard time against me, I know this is a wifom but if you must lynch me d1 you can. Anyways like Frog said? I believe I wouldn't last on LYLO.

You're dodging the questions and playing the novice card. Please answer the questions.

[Dewy]

Yes dewy we all agree
I just think pkm siteflaked so atp we're playing a D1 6 person game
Meaning we have a super high chance to ML

It would be nice if silver came back to answer what we asked him.

I'm not seeing the correlation between these.
What does silver's siteflake have to do with a ml?

[Impoetic]

you mean he's clearly not PR?
VOTE: Impoetic
Scumslip?

Wait, it's

you

again.

The whole of my last post was me attempting to snarkily reiterate myself about how PKM is obviously claiming blue and if he claimed PR it would be a scumslip so I probably shouldn't have said it in the first place but whatever, he wasn't about to come back and magically see the two posts where I pointed out that he said "Lynch me if you want" and he probably wasn't going to claim PR anyway because he is likely blue.

What do you mean by blue? Blue as in VT?

Scumslips usually involve logic, not wording. Even if I hadn't meant to say exactly what you asked about, it wouldn't be a scumslip!

Not necessary. Scumslips can involve anything that's a scum claim.

Oh, sorry. Yes, I meant VT.

[Impoetic]

And what I meant about scumslips is that simple miswordings and other things that aren't significantly more likely to be said by scum than by town are not scumslips, because they don't indicate alignment. What I meant by "involving logic," I'm not entirely sure...

[Impoetic]

*WHEN* PKM flips

villager

.

And I don't

know

he's villager, obviously, but that's my guess about his alignment at this point and it certainly seems to be his claim. ~_^

These two statements kind of contradict each other.

The first statement is my way of saying that's what he'll *probably* flip and the second line is me expressing self-doubt.