Open 648: Ari's Donner Party Mafia! Game Over! :O

[Aristophanes]

VC 1.4

CyTheFlyGuy

(2): Gameplay506 52, Franky 54

Majiffy

(2): AlpacaAlpaca 11, Shinobi 205

Io

(1): Majiffy 42

AlpacaAlpaca

(1): Farside22 72

Gameplay508

(1): cytheflyguy 130

Shinobi

(1): Realeo 152

Dunnstral

(1): Jaereed 186

Franky

(1): Dunnstral 210

Not Voting

(2): Bins, Io,

With 12 Alive, it takes 7 to hammer.

The day will end on July 30th, 2016 at 10PM EST

(expired on 2016-07-30 22:00:00) (10PM EST July 30/16)

[Majiffy]

Oh wait hold on I know how this works

Shinobi please elaborate on your read for me thanks

I feel like you've been relatively lackluster thus far - your Io push feels half-hearted and I'm not happy with you taking a potshot at me based on the fact that I'm asking people to explain things.

Oh no a half-hearted push on someone who has posted 4 times

Say it isn't so

[Io]

Sorry I was busy all of yesterday, found out my bathroom sink was leaking and there is a pretty large mold problem now so I was gutting the entire sink area.

And I'll have you know I actually have 5 posts Maji.

I don't like Cy's reaction testing, mainly because that is sometime townies only rarely did when I played on another sight. Reaction tests are really just an easy way to look like you're giving content and often just a cop out for a bad move, but honestly I don't get that feeling from him but it's not something that would make me super town read him for doing.

@Dunn, I still don't see how that wall makes Franky look like he is overreacting. That doesn't really seam much of a good accusation by looking at that. He's even right in post 68 that the burden of proof does lie in the accuser not the defendant. Not to mention like with Cy it was just a reaction test and I don't really see those as having town motivation in them very often.

Far is also now my top town read since they've only been contributing more content since I last posted and they are generally doing townie things like giving opinions, scum reads, and other comments on whatever they feel like.

New reads are:
{far}
{Reallo; Maji; Game}
{Bin; Franky; Jae; Shinobi; Alpacha}
{Cy}
{Dunn}

Lastly I will VOTE: Dunn
You're accusation of Franky is really starting to look like a huge stretch now. Honestly after you posted those evidence quotes it just makes me more suspicious of you.

[cytheflyguy]

I don't like Cy's reaction testing, mainly because that is sometime townies only rarely did when I played on another sight. Reaction tests are really just an easy way to look like you're giving content and often just a cop out for a bad move, but honestly I don't get that feeling from him but it's not something that would make me super town read him for doing.

Again, I did it to move the conversation along. I never did it to be a "big" move or do anything super townish. I just wanted to move it from being circular logic while testing something out that I've seen other people do before. I'm not sure why when I do it, it doesn't look good?

[Majiffy]

UNVOTE: Io

[gameplay506]

Ffs dunn is town
Vote cy

[Shinobi]

Btw shinobi can you give us your reads ty
Pedit: I don't get it aswell

I'll try to write out my current list tonight.

[farside22]

The Dunn case seems like a stretch tome.

[Dunnstral]

Honestly after you posted those evidence quotes it just makes me more suspicious of you.

Which I was asked for like 4 times.

[Dunnstral]

How is it starting to look like a huge stretch now, as opposed to two and a half days ago when I made the case?

[Realeo]

Wut why is Dunn Sk again

His reaction is scummy but I reckon that if he's a mafia--he will be more relaxed.

Why he will be more relaxed as mafia? Psychology dictates that having a companion--like scum partner--helps to calm yourself because you know someone have your back.

Dunnstrall was being retaliated by JR, Bins and forsaken by me. No one has his back.

Dunnstrall town? Maybe. Dunnstral SK? Maybe. Dunnstral mafia? I don't reckon.

[Realeo]

I will move my vote to Dunn after Shinobi gives the readlist.

[Dunnstral]

Dunnstrall town? Maybe. Dunnstral SK? Maybe. Dunnstral mafia? I don't reckon.

Then don't vote me genius

[JaeReed]

{Io, Franky, cytheflyguy, Farside, Shinobi}
{gameplay, Majiffy}
{Bins}
{Realeo, Alpaca}
{Dunnstral}

6. (no change)

{Io, Franky, cytheflyguy, Farside, Shinobi, gameplay}
{Majiffy}
{Bins}
{Realeo, Alpaca}
{Dunnstral}

7.

Why is majiffy so high on the list?
I have a slight scum read on him.

Tone. He comes across as lazy town rather than coasting mafia.
He has been stuck in the same position for a long time for a reason. His placement isn't a particularly strong read, but he's still more likely to flip town than everyone below him, barring Realeo.

[farside22]

Wut why is Dunn Sk again

His reaction is scummy but I reckon that if he's a mafia--he will be more relaxed.

Why he will be more relaxed as mafia? Psychology dictates that having a companion--like scum partner--helps to calm yourself because you know someone have your back.

Dunnstrall was being retaliated by JR, Bins and forsaken by me. No one has his back.

Dunnstrall town? Maybe. Dunnstral SK? Maybe. Dunnstral mafia? I don't reckon.

I will move my vote to Dunn after Shinobi gives the readlist.

Fos

[Majiffy]

VOTE: Franky

[Bins]

promise i will finish my catch up tomorrow cause work today but free tmmr!!

[Shinobi]

Got stuck at work and haven't had time to write things out.
Will look for time to do so tomorrow.

[Dunnstral]

Realeo makes no sense to me

He basically said I'm probably not mafia to him but mysteriously there's a chance that I'm serial killer or town so I should be pushed anyway (Even though me not being mafia to him should probably make him push

elsewhere

)

I don't even know why he "suspects" ? me in the first place or why he gave a 24-hour vote notice

[Realeo]

I kinda confused at people who fos me due to that post. I told previously that I vote Shinobi to accelerate Shinobi's conclusion. I don't fos him. The moment he comes to a conclusion, I don't need to vote him any longer and I can go to the next suspect in the line.

[gameplay506]

ye that seems bad

[Realeo]

Hmm. ok.

Let me rephrase the sentence.

I fos Dunnstral to a level that I feel I need to vote him. However, my vote has other priority. I am foreshadowing the vote now so there won't be additional fuss afterward when Shinboi give his conclusion.

I mean, imagine Shinobi giving his conclusion than I move my vote. That would create more confusion.

Does this make more sense?

[Realeo]

Can someone rephrase the meaning? I am not exactly native speaker.

[gameplay506]

No I get it I just don't get why you would vote somebody your not fos'ing over somebody you do.
Whatever the reason its seems bad.

[gameplay506]

Anyway if somebody comes off with a better reason for dunnscum than "his arguments are bad" please share it. Cus right now your reasoning is just that guys.