I have suspicions but feel like it is most prudent to keep silent for the moment until more of the day has played out. I definitely think scum were on the Vedith wagon even if BlankFace is not Mafia so that is sort of a silly question.In post 938, Hoopla wrote:Sera, if Blankface is scum, who are his partners? Were they on the Vedith wagon? Who are likely candidates?
In post 945, Egg wrote:Grendel, how surprised would you be to see cmit flip town?
Pretty surprised. If I'm confident enough to vote him then I don't expect him to flip town. May I ask your thought process behind this question?In post 954, Egg wrote:Still waiting for this to be answered:In post 945, Egg wrote:Grendel, how surprised would you be to see cmit flip town?
His reaction to my proposing RQS looked really scummy to me. He acted paranoid, then instead of using his own reasoning to say why RQS is bad he just quoted another persons argument. I continually pressed him to elaborate further. He never did provide any counter arguments of substance, and recently admitted that he saw nothing bad coming about due to my questions. To me it seemed like scum trying to take advantage of popular opinion to get quick and easy town cred. Later his unablity to explain why, (or even where), he thought my questions instigated crap posting further solidify my read on him.In post 932, Seraphim wrote: Grendel, identify for me one thing or post in particular that you don't think town would do that cmitc1 has done or posted.
What kind of angles are we talking about here?In post 951, Seraphim wrote:
We need to lynch scum today or at the very least make sure we are investigating every angle and folks are not doing that right now. It's been a while since I've played but even I know that.
I am not really sure...In post 932, Seraphim wrote:
cmitc1, if you could vig shot one player in the game without a claim, who would it be and why?
In post 954, Egg wrote:Still waiting for this to be answered:In post 945, Egg wrote:Grendel, how surprised would you be to see cmit flip town?
In post 953, BlankFace wrote:I have made a case about Cmit, it was in 809. All of that, added with his weird reactions to the wagon yesterday have not changed my mind. He knows enough about this game that he doesn't get a newb pass. His actions were erratic at the end of the dayand he's just sheeping other reads while trying to seem hesitant, making it feel like he's really considering the game.
What's your read on Cmit? Do you feel like my reasoning for that vote is bad?
As far as coasting goes, it depends. Sometimes I'm incredibly active, sometimes I'm not. If you're looking for meta, I can give you links. Nothing here has put that spark into me yet. D1 sucked, I've already complained about it. D2 is off to a slow start with KtS refusing to read. I need to look at the Masq wagon a little more in depth, so far the biggest red flag to me on that was Cmit's eagerness to engage and then how quickly he disengaged from it.
In post 958, cmitc1 wrote:I am not really sure...In post 932, Seraphim wrote:
cmitc1, if you could vig shot one player in the game without a claim, who would it be and why?
I guess i would go with Masqurade, due to his sudden increase in bad post?
mmm, i'm not really town-reading you and although Wake was ok D1 and Sera has been good today, I think it's possible that slot is scum.In post 962, Grendel wrote:Am I correct in thinking that you're town reading everybody except Mask, Egg, and Cmit1? Is this your chosen scum team?
What do you think of Wake/Seraphim?
I agree that he is engaging in the behaviors you have described, I'm just not convinced as to whether they are coming from scum or not. He is the type of player that is very hard to read because their playstyle is generally anti-town and lacks any convincing "honesty" as to their motivations. I don't think your reasoning is bad except it feels that you have yet to connect for me why that makes him scum. Players like him are easy to write up but they could just be bad town players. Makes them good targets for players looking for an easy mislynch.In post 953, BlankFace wrote:I have made a case about Cmit, it was in 809. All of that, added with his weird reactions to the wagon yesterday have not changed my mind. He knows enough about this game that he doesn't get a newb pass. His actions were erratic at the end of the day and he's just sheeping other reads while trying to seem hesitant, making it feel like he's really considering the game.
What's your read on Cmit? Do you feel like my reasoning for that vote is bad?
As far as coasting goes, it depends. Sometimes I'm incredibly active, sometimes I'm not. If you're looking for meta, I can give you links. Nothing here has put that spark into me yet. D1 sucked, I've already complained about it. D2 is off to a slow start with KtS refusing to read. I need to look at the Masq wagon a little more in depth, so far the biggest red flag to me on that was Cmit's eagerness to engage and then how quickly he disengaged from it.
I find this to be an odd question but I will humor it. I don't even think misguided is necessarily the right word here. I think you are town because you are making a lot of posts, making a lot of opinions, throwing your weight behind them, and trying to get people lynched in a way that reflects an actual thought process and not a process that reflects a Mafia alignment. I was uncertain at first; your RQS felt kind of forced, but the way you handled it (even if I don't feel as if it has paid dividends) afterwards leads to believe you are town.In post 962, Grendel wrote:I'm gonna try something...
@Seraphim: You think I'm misguided town. Why misguided town, and not deceitful mafia?
Are you town reading Cmitc1, and Kill?
Which bad posts in particular and why are they bad? I am not letting you off the hook.In post 958, cmitc1 wrote:I am not really sure...In post 932, Seraphim wrote:
cmitc1, if you could vig shot one player in the game without a claim, who would it be and why?
I guess i would go with Masqurade, due to his sudden increase in bad post?
In post 956, Grendel wrote:What kind of angles are we talking about here?In post 951, Seraphim wrote:
We need to lynch scum today or at the very least make sure we are investigating every angle and folks are not doing that right now. It's been a while since I've played but even I know that.
Please keep up
Cool. And sorry, I just noticed that you said your were busy in you last post. Hope I didn't seem inconsiderate.BBmolla wrote:My house townread has decreased with kts.
You're pretty townish
I'm catching up
I'm having trouble placing Seraphim. I was leaning town for a while due to Wake trying to defuse Rob, and House. But Egg seemed pretty sure Wake would have done that as either alignment, so I'm not sure where I stand on Sera's slot currently.In post 963, Hoopla wrote:mmm, i'm not really town-reading you and although Wake was ok D1 and Sera has been good today, I think it's possible that slot is scum.In post 962, Grendel wrote:Am I correct in thinking that you're town reading everybody except Mask, Egg, and Cmit1? Is this your chosen scum team?
What do you think of Wake/Seraphim?
I think this was the post that led me to think that. May I ask what changed for you in-between then and now?In post 612, Hoopla wrote:gut feeling.In post 608, House wrote:@hoopla:
Why is Grendel in your maybe pile?
He's voting me because I prefer being scum over town, as if we can ask the mod for a preferred alignment before the game starts.
He's totally married to this silly assumption, and completely misreps my play to fit that theory.
i think his attempts to gain reads from his random questions is flawed but a genuinely attempt at scumhunting - it's abstract sure, but i tend to think scum don't do things like that as often. they tend to hunt in more conventional ways.
nah dude were good lmao I need that sort of "LOOK HERE MOLLA" cause I do tend to skim large posts.In post 973, Grendel wrote:Cool. And sorry, I just noticed that you said your were busy in you last post. Hope I didn't seem inconsiderate.
