Open 648: Ari's Donner Party Mafia! Game Over! :O

[Dunnstral]

"his arguments are bad"

Nobody even said that

Jaereed won't give a reason and realeo pretty much went on about how I'm probably not mafia, but I could totally be the sk but didn't have a real reason

[gameplay506]

io I think is voting you based on your push on Franky. She didn't actually give much of a reasoning for that vote.

[gameplay506]

Cy I want your reads ty

[Realeo]

Jaereed won't give a reason and realeo pretty much went on about how I'm probably not mafia, but I could totally be the sk but

didn't have a real reason

The reasoning is your panicking.

The reason I said "maybe" is I want to gauge people to give me reasoning why you are town.

I mean, gameplay went "WTF people, Dunn is town!" but he didn't exactly tell reasoning. How can I fish response if I show certainty? When I show unceratainty, people starts rebuttal me. Just like 104. I throw analogy, it got destoryed. I am expecting something in line like that.

[gameplay506]

I don't see Dunn panicking anywhere lol

[Realeo]

You don't????

[gameplay506]

Ye
Show.me

[farside22]

I kinda confused at people who fos me due to that post. I told previously that I vote Shinobi to accelerate Shinobi's conclusion. I don't fos him. The moment he comes to a conclusion, I don't need to vote him any longer and I can go to the next suspect in the line.

Anyway if somebody comes off with a better reason for dunnscum than "his arguments are bad" please share it. Cus right now your reasoning is just that guys.

This was why I fos.
Also it apparently doesn't matter what shin says, the vote will be moving, which means his vote is worthless as is.

[Realeo]

I ain't saying Dunn's argument is bad. I acknowledge him rectifying his read on Bins. He initially fos Bins then later fos JaeReed and I acknowledges it. What makes me wonder is why he is being impulsive when Bins enters the arena. I acknowledge his read but question his reflex.

About Shinobi, I get cranky if people don't make any accusation. I don't care if it's good or bad reasoning. I just want to pin you on the map and see you moving. That's why I am the first(or second?) one to put initial fos. I want to see the ball rolls. After the ball rolls, I can move on. I saw shinobi attacking Majiffy and Dunnstral, but does this mean he fos him or just simple interrogation? I don't know until he told me so.

[Realeo]

Two people are misreading my argument so I am going to use analogy. It helps with my argument with Franky

Video

I didn't dare to play it due to internet quota but if I'm right this is the video.

This is a video of a guy being surprised by another person. The pranked guy instantly punch the other guy.

Read:

You maybe in danger so punching is a good option

Reflex:

Don't you even bother seeing what is happening?

This is my problem with Dunn. His read is nice. His reflex when JR start producing the readlist and Bin joining the action disturbs me.

[gameplay506]

Okayyy
Real is town once again

[Bins]

Yeah, you said that already.
I fail to see how that's outside his expected range or why it's overblown. Can you fill those two gaps in logic up for me?

I will try to fill in this because I am also bothered by the same thing.

Have you ever heard the phrase, "The innocent relax, The guilty shouts." I mean, it's classic scene where your mom accuses your dad cheating, then your dad shouts back at your mom saying, "You bitch! How dare you accuse me of cheating! We have been marrying for 25 years! Do you never believe in me?"

And it turns out the father is cheating.

When I poke cy, cy just relax. When Dunn poke Franky, Franky becomes dad.

lmfao this post

but idk if my bf accused me of cheating i'd be pretty peeved and i ain't no cheater



i didn't like franky's reaction either. mostly because he seemed

overly

defensive. but some defensiveness is good and natural. being lynched as town sucks. being relaxed is actually a scumtell for me. scum are more relaxed because they don't want to seem defensive.



anyways nbd just some theory

[Bins]

I looked through the links and I think alpaca from what I saw of his town and scum games will be the one I wait to see on this game.

Realeo: Why Shinobi?

Shinobi is in questioning mode. I want a conclusion. I think a vote will accelerate the process. Two will help, too.

OU

is the SvT about to happen


do i feeeeeel it

--


shinobi is being lurky / needing to catch-upy but i think his vocalness (hefty vocalness) about it is good if that makes sense

--

OU MAJIFFY VOTE LIKEY

--

k
like i know im supposed to be good at this game but i think its about time i ask what NAI stands for because i can't fill it in with Not Anything Interesting each time i read it.

--

ehhhh majiffy unvoting Io... ehhhh is that a townmove.... are they scum together... ? how do i feeeel...

[Bins]

dammit too many townreads


let's go ranger since everyone is doing it

{Farside, CY}
{Realeo}

{gameplay}
{Alpaca, JaeReed}
{Dunnstral, Shinobi}

{Franky, Io, Majiffy}
4324325.

[Bins]

UGH Majiffy's unvote changes everything.

[Bins]

VOTE: Franky

I'll leave my Io/Majiffy thoughts to brew. Was certain I was going to come in and vote one of them.

[gameplay506]

Ur townreadin CY?
Wtf bins

[Bins]

He's like my strongest townread >_>

he could be scum being SUPER awkward but I'm just going to say he's town being SUPER awkward

[gameplay506]

Are u scum

[Bins]

Let me put it this way: he's either town or scum.

Obvtown or obvscum.

pedit - no how dare you

[Shinobi]

I ain't saying Dunn's argument is bad. I acknowledge him rectifying his read on Bins. He initially fos Bins then later fos JaeReed and I acknowledges it. What makes me wonder is why he is being impulsive when Bins enters the arena. I acknowledge his read but question his reflex.

About Shinobi, I get cranky if people don't make any accusation. I don't care if it's good or bad reasoning. I just want to pin you on the map and see you moving. That's why I am the first(or second?) one to put initial fos. I want to see the ball rolls. After the ball rolls, I can move on. I saw shinobi attacking Majiffy and Dunnstral, but does this mean he fos him or just simple interrogation? I don't know until he told me so.

I think I've been particularly vocal wrt my distrust of majiffy.
Is there any reason you think the opposite?

[cytheflyguy]

Let me put it this way: he's either town or scum.

Obvtown or obvscum.

pedit - no how dare you

Why does everyone say I'm awkward? :T (Maybe bc I am... :c)

Ur townreadin CY?

Sure thing, just give me a bit of time ^^

[Io]

@Bins just a quick question. Which scum do you think Frnaky is?

[Aristophanes]

Mine

[Aristophanes]

Mine