Open 648: Ari's Donner Party Mafia! Game Over! :O

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: Franky

So you agree on this lynch then?

[Bins]

i definitely agree on pushing it

[gameplay506]

READS!

Oh my, this is a game with an SK! I almost forgot to put that in my reads!

Town:

AlpacaAlpaca-Super strong town read. Posts like 151 and 287 show really good, pro town questioning.
Dunnstral-Independent thinker. Makes logical pushes but does not tunnel.
Farside-See above but less tunneling.pushing xDD
Io-Borderline null, but makes solid paragraphs that I respect.
Majiffy-Another borderline town. I don't understand the scum read some people have on him?
Realeo-I have vibes. Idk good or bad. For now I'm going with good.
Shinobi-I like his posting and I'd like to know scum reads on him too?


Scum:

gameplay-6 268 Really really...bad

Frankie-Seems very isolated from town, but looks to confident to be SK

SK:

JaeReed-13 posts and 7 of them are unexplained reads. Looks like trying to be town without providing content.

Null:

Bins-Really want to see more from. Tbh borderline scum.

Guys are you serious? This is positioning at its worst like cmon.
He is scum look at his reads he pulls reads out of his ass. He doesn't know who to point as scum that is why he is pointing Frankie who is being pushed by almost half the players, me because I am obv pushing Cy and jae on some fake arguments that he doesn't explain his reads ( given that almost nobody has explained his reads). Like really?
He wants his vote on me to make him look like he is doing something that is why he is pointing me as scum despite having 0 arguments.
And why is Jae Sk and not lets say mafia Cy?
Also I wouldn't be surprised if he is scum with Bins. Because Bins has been pretty shit as well.

[gameplay506]

Scum:

gameplay-6 268 Really really...bad

That was the plan, anyway. Now I still have null on you and it's all for naught :T

^
His thoughts after he voted me for "reaction testing"
Another thing - post 6 one of the two posts that he uses against me under the premise that it's bad was way before this post. Yet it didn't impact his read on me did it.

His whole attitude is off. He is being too calm for a newb.

Iso him. He has basically contributed nothing, blending into the crowd.
1-7th post - RVS and RQS
8-13 post - absolutely nothing, I dare you read it
post 14 - votes me ( the shitty reaction test)
post 15 - 22 - tries and fails to explain his vote/ again nothing contributing to the game its just him trying to defend and explain his irrational plays
23 and 24 are nothing and 25 is the readlist that triggered me
He isn't trying to progress the game.
Like cmon.

[Dunnstral]

dammit too many townreads


let's go ranger since everyone is doing it

{Farside, CY}
{Realeo}

{gameplay}
{Alpaca, JaeReed}
{Dunnstral, Shinobi}

{Franky, Io, Majiffy}
4324325.

Why am I near the bottom?

[Realeo]

Why are you so confident you're in the top? I mean, even before the JaeReed incident, I still put you on null.

[farside22]

Farside, before I go around moving my vote from people I don't trust to other people I don't trust, talk to me about bins.
What do you think of her?

second post I was town reading her. The rest post kind of made my eyebrow raise a bit.
Right now null.

Do you believe his vote on me was anything more than OMGUS?

Do you think me "OMGUS" voting makes me more likely to be mafia?

It doesn't and you're just trying to throw shade, this isn't a town perspective

VOTE: Jaereed

I like this vote!

VOTE: Jaereed

Bins if you don't talk about me/Jaereed on me/franky ur getting tunneled

go away


you and jaebae are null to nulltown like the rest of that group for now



yes i have too many townreads
dw they always sort themself out

[farside22]

READS!

Oh my, this is a game with an SK! I almost forgot to put that in my reads!

Town:

AlpacaAlpaca-Super strong town read. Posts like 151 and 287 show really good, pro town questioning.
Dunnstral-Independent thinker. Makes logical pushes but does not tunnel.
Farside-See above but less tunneling.pushing xDD
Io-Borderline null, but makes solid paragraphs that I respect.
Majiffy-Another borderline town. I don't understand the scum read some people have on him?
Realeo-I have vibes. Idk good or bad. For now I'm going with good.
Shinobi-I like his posting and I'd like to know scum reads on him too?


Scum:

gameplay-6 268 Really really...bad

Frankie-Seems very isolated from town, but looks to confident to be SK

SK:

JaeReed-13 posts and 7 of them are unexplained reads. Looks like trying to be town without providing content.

Null:

Bins-Really want to see more from. Tbh borderline scum.

Guys are you serious? This is positioning at its worst like cmon.
He is scum look at his reads he pulls reads out of his ass. He doesn't know who to point as scum that is why he is pointing Frankie who is being pushed by almost half the players, me because I am obv pushing Cy and jae on some fake arguments that he doesn't explain his reads ( given that almost nobody has explained his reads). Like really?
He wants his vote on me to make him look like he is doing something that is why he is pointing me as scum despite having 0 arguments.
And why is Jae Sk and not lets say mafia Cy?
Also I wouldn't be surprised if he is scum with Bins. Because Bins has been pretty shit as well.

Hey grumpy man.
If you would mind getting off your tunnel for a moment and explain your bins scum read that would be swell.

[gameplay506]

No cy is scum

[gameplay506]

Give me a reason why cy is town so that I can stop my tunnel
Cus right now I see 0 reasons for cytown

[cytheflyguy]

Scum:

gameplay-6 268 Really really...bad

That was the plan, anyway. Now I still have null on you and it's all for naught :T

^
His thoughts after he voted me for "reaction testing"
Another thing - post 6 one of the two posts that he uses against me under the premise that it's bad was way before this post. Yet it didn't impact his read on me did it.

His whole attitude is off. He is being too calm for a newb.

Iso him. He has basically contributed nothing, blending into the crowd.
1-7th post - RVS and RQS
8-13 post - absolutely nothing, I dare you read it
post 14 - votes me ( the shitty reaction test)
post 15 - 22 - tries and fails to explain his vote/ again nothing contributing to the game its just him trying to defend and explain his irrational plays
23 and 24 are nothing and 25 is the readlist that triggered me
He isn't trying to progress the game.
Like cmon.

LMAO Please excuse me for not freaking out at other people's accusations? xD

And I still don't see why you think my reaction thing was solely about reaction? I've stated multiple times that it's main function was to move the game forward bc your argument was going in circles xD

And again, initial reads, No one has said anything that has come off super scummy sans the people I've put in my scum reads. Like the people who have posted well didn't seem to have posts that have scum motive, so why would I randomly put them in scum reads to please you? xDDD I'll only move my reads when I feel they needed to be moved.

[gameplay506]

Cmon fight me
Why am I scum

[gameplay506]

Give ur arguments I gave mine

[Realeo]

farside, I'm confused.

Do you live with internet server that takes 24 hours to update?

[JaeReed]

Cy I need your responses to what I asked regarding your reads.

One of my townreads is wrong since I started townreading Realeo so I actually do need to do some digging.

[gameplay506]

Ye cy is scum
Vote him

[JaeReed]

Dunnstral is also scum. He is my preferred lynch.

[gameplay506]

Ok convince me.on Dunn scum and I will vote him
Cus I see town there

[Realeo]

OOT. Does anyone see Io as scum? Because I am thinking that I may be able to use gameplay's argument on cy at Io.

[cytheflyguy]

Cy I need your responses to what I asked regarding your reads.

One of my townreads is wrong since I started townreading Realeo so I actually do need to do some digging.

Literally am about to post it, wanted to check back before I do so.

Give ur arguments I gave mine

I see no harm in this.

[cytheflyguy]

OOT. Does anyone see Io as scum? Because I am thinking that I may be able to use gameplay's argument on cy at Io.

I literally have no feel on Io. I need to see more.

[gameplay506]

No feel on lo yet she is town
Die pls

[gameplay506]

OOT. Does anyone see Io as scum? Because I am thinking that I may be able to use gameplay's argument on cy at Io.

Ye I aint really a big fan of lo either

[cytheflyguy]

AlpacaAlpaca-Super strong town read. Posts like 151 and 287 show really good, pro town questioning.

Do you think those questions were likely to lead anywhere? Do you believe they were necessary to establish a read? Do you believe your intention in what you had originally stated was unclear enough to merit asking those questions?

Dunnstral-Independent thinker. Makes logical pushes but does not tunnel.

Do you believe Dunnstral's faking of a scumread on Franky was logical? Do you believe he has been reassessing his read on Franky? Do you believe his vote on me was anything more than OMGUS?

gameplay-6 268 Really really...bad

What do you believe was bad about those two posts in particular?

Frankie-Seems very isolated from town, but looks to confident to be SK

Why is being isolated from town a scumtell to you? Why is confidence a non-SK tell to you?

"Do you think those questions were likely to lead anywhere? (1) Do you believe they were necessary to establish a read? (2) Do you believe your intention in what you had originally stated was unclear enough to merit asking those questions? (3)"

(1) His questions majority of the time were towards me, I answered them, and I felt it helped town progress by moving it along. Yes, I do think that he should posts reads at some point.

(2) I looked at his meta, and honestly, the face that in his first game, he had full reads list does slightly bother me, and the fact he posts paragrahphs in his second also makes me feel uncertain about how high up he is with town...But now that I have read them, I do think more was needed to make those reads, and I just took Farsides word about it ^^;;

(3) Well again, he mainly asked me questions, and he seemed about confused as everyone else who askes me questions, so I'd say yes, it was merited.

"Do you believe Dunnstral's faking of a scumread on Franky was logical? (1) Do you believe he has been reassessing his read on Franky? (2) Do you believe his vote on me was anything more than OMGUS? (3)"

(1) Where did he say he faked it?

(2)Seeing as his vote is on you, I would say the question doesn't matter as he just seems to have scumreads but is open to other votes.

(3) Not really.

"What do you believe was bad about those two posts in particular?"

How do you not see it? He literally says:

I got town so fk u I aint votin

What type of person actually sees this as pro town? Is he like this in other games too? xD

"Why is being isolated from town a scumtell to you? (1) Why is confidence a non-SK tell to you? (2)"

(1) It is at the beginning of the game. I think the SK would either try to buddy up or try to not look too suspicious.

(2) It's more of an "I'm pretty sure is an evil role but he probably has back up so I don't think he'd be the SK" type thing. For now, it doesn't feel right for him to be SK.
----------------------------------------------

Honestly, I really, really loved the first and last questions but I didn't feel the need of the other two, especially the second. They feel forced questions, imo.

Btw, for anyone wanting to use this as an argument that I'm just joining the biggest wagon (bc I get that a lot xD), I'm compleltly not doing it for the same reason the other two. xD
VOTE: JaeReed

[gameplay506]

It was the beginning of the game u scrub
Jae vote him with me