Open 645: C9++ - Game Over

[Bins]

THEREFORE NO

IT DOESNT MAKE DUNN EVER A GOOD FAKE CLAIM

so answer me again WHY DIDNT I JUST PROTECT ZACH

[Postie]

Ranger, Postie, one time only. I swear on Annie that I am town this game. lynch Bins with me.

I would but apparently LQ is confirmed scum to me.

[a plain farmer]

Bins knew that the vig was 1-shot since the moment she found out that there was a vig. She knew there was a D (less likely, a B) when their N1 kill attempt on Zach failed, so there was only one letter left that was unaccounted for before Umlaut's flip. And, as she indicated, she didn't think her N1 RB hit the vig, since she did not know that a RB'd vig would be refunded shots. She can explain to us postgame why she chose to fake-claim targeting Dunn, but it remains that she had every reason to believe that we wouldn't have evidence enough to cast dbout on that choice of target.

@Those who want to lynch from the VT pool today:
There's a 96% chance we're in a single D setup, 4% chance we're in a DDD setup. If you're townreading both Bins and dave, that'd better be a damn strong townread to overcome that kind of a prior. Make sure you're accounting for everything we now know.

You'll recall at the beginning of D2 how bewildered we were at Dunn having been the target. Bins would now have us believe that the scum, texcat, and doc!Bins passed up on Zach and the reputed scumhunters (Titus/RC/Ranger) and all independently converged on Dunn. I don't buy it. But this is something you must believe if you believe Bins is town.

Then there's the ludicrous softing that she's done the past couple days. You'd normally expect doctors to be the roles least inclined to soft. It's as if when she found there was a doc she decided to make sure she could also claim doc in the event of a no kill.

So vote Bins.

[Zachstralkita]

BINS I TRIED TO STOPI T

[Bins]

What? Dunn was an obvious kill? Because he was super town read.

[Bins]

Also, I still can't follow what you're saying.

Please don't make me go survivalistic. I actually think RC is scum.

[RadiantCowbells]

No you go away.

[Bins]

Don't forget i'm spicing things up day 2

oh and I totally forgot this was another main reason I thought dunn would be the NK target

[LicketyQuickety]

Don't forget i'm spicing things up day 2

oh and I totally forgot this was another main reason I thought dunn would be the NK target

This post is horrible.

VOTE: bins

[Bins]

VOTE: LQ

sigh i knew you'd jump on me if you were scum

[Bins]

but why is it horrible?

[LicketyQuickety]

but why is it horrible?

Because you are saying because Dunn said that they were going to spice things up Day 2 means anything at all. It just means that Dunn is prolly just saying that thinking they are actually going to spice things up and play different when they really prolly don't have the capacity to. Like it it common sense. Do you really think Dunn has the ability to make a big change like that, cuz I sure don't. The only other explanation I can think of is that Dunn said that to try and draw a NK, but I don't really put much faith in that considering the type of person Dunn is.

[Zachstralkita]

Don't forget i'm spicing things up day 2

oh and I totally forgot this was another main reason I thought dunn would be the NK target

This post is horrible.

VOTE: bins

what

VOTE: LQ

sigh i knew you'd jump on me if you were scum

WHATTTTTTTTTTTTT

[Bins]

but why is it horrible?

Because you are saying because Dunn said that they were going to spice things up Day 2 means anything at all. It just means that Dunn is prolly just saying that thinking they are actually going to spice things up and play different when they really prolly don't have the capacity to. Like it it common sense. Do you really think Dunn has the ability to make a big change like that, cuz I sure don't. The only other explanation I can think of is that Dunn said that to try and draw a NK, but I don't really put much faith in that considering the type of person Dunn is.

what i thought it looked like a clear PR soft??

[Bins]

either way how does my interpretation of that post make me scum?? looks like pulling opportunistic reasons out of your butt

[LicketyQuickety]

either way how does my interpretation of that post make me scum?? looks like pulling opportunistic reasons out of your butt

Not at all. I gave my reason which has to do with reading the person behind the action, something you utterly fail to do if you are Town. Also, I don't buy that Dunn way someone who should have been the obvious NK. I think Scum should be looking to kill a lurker ie someone who doesn't give a lot of info from their Kill or someone who is a strong candidate to be a PR or someone who had really good reads and I believe Dunn was none of these things.

[Bins]

ok i'm sorry my protect target sucked but hey guess what DUNN GOT NIGHTKILLED

if dunn softed PR and was also a good way for scum to dodge a protect i think ya doi he was a dece NK

[Bins]

I think Scum should be looking to kill a lurker ie someone who doesn't give a lot of info from their Kill

this is also just no

[Bins]

can i also remind you that dunn was hardtownreading me i wouldnt have killed him for WIFOM jesus especially because there were other kill options

[Zachstralkita]

What the fuck? We can't even unite and lynch outside of Bins/LQ?

BOTH OF THOSE FLIP GREEN, FOR FUCK'S SAKE

you guys wanna do postie?

[a plain farmer]

I'll make a deal with you Zach. We'll lynch Bins today, Lickety tomorrow, and then if the mod still wants to do vote counts after that we'll lynch Postie together. Sound good?

[LicketyQuickety]

UNVOTE:

[Bins]

you realise it's mylo tomorrow why would he agree to that

[RadiantCowbells]

Bins today, Postie tomorrow, game over*

[Zachstralkita]

I'll make a deal with you Zach. We'll lynch Bins today, Lickety tomorrow, and then if the mod still wants to do vote counts after that we'll lynch Postie together. Sound good?

We should amend the first part of this deal to where I jump off of a fucking mountain before this happens.