OPEN 649 — PICK YOUR POWER X/Y. EXPERIMENT OVER.

[Bins]

VOTECOUNT 1.8.

Searching for a replacement for Ümläüt.

>> [0] Dunnstral
>> [0] Firebringer
>>

[1] Vedith

— Firebringer
>>

[4] Shadow_Step

— Dunnstral, Killthestory, Creature, gigabyteTroubadour
>>

[1] pisskop

— Ümläüt
>>

[1] Killthestory

— Chrimi
>> [0] gigabyteTroubadour
>>

[2] Skelda

— Shadow_Step, MariaR
>>

[1] MariaR

— Charloux
>>

[2] Charloux

— Zachstralkita, Vedith
>>

[1] Ümläüt

— pisskop
>> [0] Chrimi
>>

[1] Creature

— Skelda
>> [0] Zachstralkita

>> [0] Not Voting

With

14

alive, it takes

8

to lynch.

Day 1

will end in

(expired on 2016-08-07 18:00:00)

.

[Charloux]

I can see shadow and skelda as scum, but i don't really see Ümläüt as one. Why do you scumread him creature?

He's null to me, but my gut says he's scum.

Maybe, but he gets town points from me because he was one of the few who made normal posts in the first 20 pages. Guess i will wait for his replacement.

VOTE: Shadow I don't mind voting for either him or skelda; but i trust the ones on the shadow's wagon more right now.

[Bins]

Wake88 replaces Umlaut! Please be friendly!

[Wake1]

I'll review the game momentarily.

[Skelda]

>> Dunnstral

>> Firebringer

>> Vedith

>> Shadow_Step

>> pisskop

>> Killthestory

>> gigabyteTroubadour

>> Skelda

>> MariaR

>> Charloux

(reason stated by giga)
>> Ümläüt

>> Chrimi

>> Creature

>> Zachstralkita

I thought you had me as Town before. What happened to that?

I was really enjoying not being suspected this game, lol. That hardly ever happens.

I still think it is Creature. I'm not convinced about it being Shadow, but he has suspiciously shitty reads.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

I think Firebringer earlier raised a good point about Shadow – his continued suspicion on Maria looks tryhard but in a fake way. To me, it's like he feels he has to look consistent and is now only on Skelda to make an excuse to vote someone else. I did say it was plausible for Shadow to be town and just have really bad opinions, but the move onto Skelda seems very strange to me.

I am interested in knowing what made Creature change his read on Skelda, I didn't pick up on it until it was pointed out.

[Wake1]

So I take it we don't know the Setup?

[Dunnstral]

I was really enjoying not being suspected this game, lol. That hardly ever happens.

But you weren't not suspected

[Dunnstral]

So I take it we don't know the Setup?

It's semi-open; we know what roles there are and that people higher in the draft are more likely to be pr, but don't know who is what

there's 8 sets of "roles" and 2 options in each

[Wake1]

Ah, so semi-Open.

[Dunnstral]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?tit ... _Power_X/Y

Probably want to take a look at this, at least the possible roles

[Wake1]

Why thank you good Sir but I'm unsure how useful that'll be without flips.

[Wake1]

...well, I guess crumbing Bomb is not a viable option.

[Dunnstral]

> Thank gosh! All of you are still alive. I'm glad we didn't need to make any replacements before the fun had even begun!
> Now... here are the exciting results to this very interesting social experiment!

== Draft Order ==

Chrimi — 1
Creature — 9
Killthestory — 11
MariaR — 13
Dunnstral — 2
gigabyteTroubadour — 2
Skelda — 4
Charloux — 4
Ümläüt — 5
pisskop — 5
Zachstralkita — 6
cytheflyguy — 6
Vedith — 12
Shadow_Step — 12


Please hang tight while Draft PMs are sent out. Please don't send selections before you receive a PM or I will send you a picture of a sad turtle.

If you pick a slot that is taken already, you will receive this PM:

> Golly gosh! You have picked a selection that someone has already picked. And guess what! They were a higher in the draft order.
> Boo hoo! You lose!
> It's okay...
> ... being out there... defenceless... you'll be fine.
> ... probably.

And you will receive your final Vanilla Townie/Mafia Goon role PM with everyone else during the Final Phase.

> EDIT:
> All PMs have been sent! Please send choices by (expired on 2016-07-23 00:45:00).
> Confirmations: 14/14.

EDIT: Congrats to all the winners! All selection PMs have been sent.

This should be useful, there was confirmation that mafia were able to talk pregame so it would be less likely for two mafia to pick the same number in draft (since it makes them less likely to get their abilities) unless they were gambiting

[Wake1]

Unvote

[Skelda]

I was really enjoying not being suspected this game, lol. That hardly ever happens.

But you weren't not suspected

Oh yeah, I forgot about you. Well, I wasn't suspected relative to how much I usually am on this site.

[Skelda]

I think Firebringer earlier raised a good point about Shadow – his continued suspicion on Maria looks tryhard but in a fake way. To me, it's like he feels he has to look consistent and is now only on Skelda to make an excuse to vote someone else. I did say it was plausible for Shadow to be town and just have really bad opinions, but the move onto Skelda seems very strange to me.

I am interested in knowing what made Creature change his read on Skelda, I didn't pick up on it until it was pointed out.

Yeah, that makes sense. I definitely am kind of shifting my opinion about the Maria thing being scummy in itself because Charloux made a good point about going against the rest of the Town's opinions not being scummy. But I think Shadow's opinions have continued to be so bad that I'm doubting they are coming from a Town perspective.

[Skelda]

> Thank gosh! All of you are still alive. I'm glad we didn't need to make any replacements before the fun had even begun!
> Now... here are the exciting results to this very interesting social experiment!

== Draft Order ==

Chrimi — 1
Creature — 9
Killthestory — 11
MariaR — 13
Dunnstral — 2
gigabyteTroubadour — 2
Skelda — 4
Charloux — 4
Ümläüt — 5
pisskop — 5
Zachstralkita — 6
cytheflyguy — 6
Vedith — 12
Shadow_Step — 12


Please hang tight while Draft PMs are sent out. Please don't send selections before you receive a PM or I will send you a picture of a sad turtle.

If you pick a slot that is taken already, you will receive this PM:

> Golly gosh! You have picked a selection that someone has already picked. And guess what! They were a higher in the draft order.
> Boo hoo! You lose!
> It's okay...
> ... being out there... defenceless... you'll be fine.
> ... probably.

And you will receive your final Vanilla Townie/Mafia Goon role PM with everyone else during the Final Phase.

> EDIT:
> All PMs have been sent! Please send choices by (expired on 2016-07-23 00:45:00).
> Confirmations: 14/14.

EDIT: Congrats to all the winners! All selection PMs have been sent.

This should be useful, there was confirmation that mafia were able to talk pregame so it would be less likely for two mafia to pick the same number in draft (since it makes them less likely to get their abilities) unless they were gambiting

Yes, exactly. And the reward of gambiting for scum is smaller than the reward of shooting to get high on the draft, so that is definitely something to keep in mind.

If we lynch scum and they duplicated, we might get a very likely Town person in the person that they duplicated with. Shadow was the same as Vedith and I highly doubt that two scum would both choose a high number like 12 even if they were doing that, so if we're thinking Shadow is scum Vedith probably isn't.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

so if we're thinking Shadow is scum Vedith probably isn't.

Crap... I want to hear Firebringer's thoughts on this, I like both of them as scum candidates but there's actually things to analyze on Shadow's case.

[Wake1]

Frankly I don't understand the Setup.

[pisskop]

did you read the wiki or op

[Killthestory]

i don't think he read anything

[Wake1]

I did, but still don't really understand it.

[Zachstralkita]

LMAOO the YG Wake replaced in what's good

[Wake1]

I'll sort you and Dunn out eventually.