Open 642 - The Woodshed - Game Over

[PantherPunt]

@drippinggoofball

1346

[PantherPunt]

Alpaca has posted on this site each of the last 4 days he's been absent here

[DrippingGoofball]

OK let's lynch him then

VOTE: Alpaca

[DrippingGoofball]

PP is probably town

[Titus]

Unvote.

If DGB and and Titus wanted to convince me mhsmith was town.

They may have done so with their posting.

Holy fuck. Can we just get a wagon on scum and stay there? Why does vote parking obvious scum convince you they are town?

[PantherPunt]

@drippinggoofball

1346

DrippingGoofball - can you fill me in on the question I ask you in 1346?

request 3 and I'm going to keep asking

[DrippingGoofball]

But they're so complicated and tedious questions LOL

[BTD6_maker]

My Internet should hopefully be better for now. Hopefully.

Anyway, there are two interesting points, both of which happened in Newbie 1700.

Firstly, outing PR reads is the one thing I should not have done. I am not sure what to make of PantherPunt and DGB. I currently Townread both of them. DGB seems like a very confused Townie at the moment.

Secondly, Doctor is a role that SHOULD never be lynched. However, it happens. Indeed, it happened purely because a Newbie hammered without intent. While I do not support No Lynches, this risk must be balanced against the benefits of lynching. This is just a possibility, but staying off-site when a lynch is imminent and near the deadline could be beneficial to scum as intent would have a lower chance of becoming a hammer due to this risk. Ranger probably presumed someone would give intent. Since this is just a possibility (and Ranger was completely off-site) this is unlikely and thus very weak, but worth bringing up.

[Xkfyu]

My Internet should hopefully be better for now. Hopefully.

Anyway, there are two interesting points, both of which happened in Newbie 1700.

Firstly, outing PR reads is the one thing I should not have done. I am not sure what to make of PantherPunt and DGB. I currently Townread both of them. DGB seems like a very confused Townie at the moment.

Secondly, Doctor is a role that SHOULD never be lynched. However, it happens. Indeed, it happened purely because a Newbie hammered without intent. While I do not support No Lynches, this risk must be balanced against the benefits of lynching. This is just a possibility, but staying off-site when a lynch is imminent and near the deadline could be beneficial to scum as intent would have a lower chance of becoming a hammer due to this risk. Ranger probably presumed someone would give intent. Since this is just a possibility (and Ranger was completely off-site) this is unlikely and thus very weak, but worth bringing up.

I have no idea what the point of any of that actually was.

[PantherPunt]

My Internet should hopefully be better for now. Hopefully.

Anyway, there are two interesting points, both of which happened in Newbie 1700.

Firstly, outing PR reads is the one thing I should not have done. I am not sure what to make of PantherPunt and DGB. I currently Townread both of them. DGB seems like a very confused Townie at the moment.

Secondly, Doctor is a role that SHOULD never be lynched. However, it happens. Indeed, it happened purely because a Newbie hammered without intent. While I do not support No Lynches, this risk must be balanced against the benefits of lynching. This is just a possibility, but staying off-site when a lynch is imminent and near the deadline could be beneficial to scum as intent would have a lower chance of becoming a hammer due to this risk. Ranger probably presumed someone would give intent. Since this is just a possibility (and Ranger was completely off-site) this is unlikely and thus very weak, but worth bringing up.

Ya what? Why are you talking about n1700...why are you talking about outing PR reads....why are you talking about whether lynching doctors has happened before or not....how does any of that related to you then talking about Ranger being offsite....why do you say things then say it's unlikely and weak

And what do you think DG is confused about?

[PantherPunt]

But they're so complicated and tedious questions LOL

Here's the simple version.

You townread smith.
You learned what the setup is and then that negated your townread on smith.
Why?

[AlpacaAlpaca]

Ok there has been a lot of posts Which I will catch up on. Sorry I haven't been here my altitude sickness has been really screwing with my head and I have been only able to cocentrate on games with little to no content which is the state of some games I'm in now. When I get back to my hotel later tonight I will read and post

[Titus]

Theory, spamming, and self-doubt.

Call me when we want to lynch mafia.

I'm only voting mhsmith0 or Panther unless to avoid a no lynch.

[mhsmith0]

But they're so complicated and tedious questions LOL

Here's the simple version.

You townread smith.
You learned what the setup is and then that negated your townread on smith.
Why?

I think it's fairly obvious what DGB is getting at. The only question is if she's lying about it.

[innocentvillager]

Apologies, but I will be V/LA until Monday afternoon. I've been ignoring RL duties/exam week but I'll try to still post maybe once or twice at least.

[mhsmith0]

[quote="In post 1362, Titus"]Theory, spamming, and self-doubt.
/quote]

Please clarify what/who you're discussing here.

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: mhsmith0

OK let's do this Titus

[mhsmith0]

VOTE: mhsmith0

OK let's do this Titus

Do you have a read here or is it just "screw it let's get a lynch"?

[PantherPunt]

I think it's fairly obvious what DGB is getting at. The only question is if she's lying about it.

doesn't make much sense to me

[PantherPunt]

Ranger/you/BTD

the "you" here is smith

what made you change from ranger d2 to smith d3

[AlpacaAlpaca]

Ok first things first DGB do you actually have any reads of your own or are you just all about that sheeping

[AlpacaAlpaca]

I think it's fairly obvious what DGB is getting at. The only question is if she's lying about it.

doesn't make much sense to me

Yup
DGB really needs to start reading and answering and making reads for themself *cough *cough
I am really tempted to vote you for really bad play so far but I still like BTD more for scum lucky you

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: mhsmith0

OK let's do this Titus

Do you have a read here or is it just "screw it let's get a lynch"?

One of your recent posts rubs me the wrong way.

I want to see a flip.

[mhsmith0]

I don't suppose you could point out the post and explain your feelings?

[AlpacaAlpaca]

But they're so complicated and tedious questions LOL