Open 648: Ari's Donner Party Mafia! Game Over! :O

[Bins]

well then no block might actually give us some answers

[gameplay506]

Will read later
Anyway np
Guess who tunneled scum <3

[lane0168]

What answers does it give?

[Io]

OK, so Dunn has to be Town. Almost 100% sure of it. There is a slight chance that he was a Goon, but not a huge one.

Spoiler:

It is 100% impossible for Dunn to be the SK.
Look at the role PM of SK. It says that the first time the SK is attacked, even if attacked by both Vig and Mafia they will survive that night.
Dunn's role could not have possibly been SK.

Now Dunn can be a goon on a few condition. GM could have preformed the kill and hit the SK night 1.
Dunn could also be Goon if he had done the kill and the Vig/SK shot Dunn and Jae.

Fixed that spoiler tag for you!

As for Far's kill.
SK also has a 1-shot roleblock immunity meaning since Dunn was roleblocked night 1 the SK's night 2 kill could not have failed and thus means that Far was stabbed by the Serial Killer unless the SK chose not to kill for one reason or another.
This means the Mafia and Vigilante very likely did not kill night 2.

Dunn being Vig makes a good deal of sense as there was 1 missing kill night 1 and 2 and Dunn was incapacitated both nights.

[Io]

Well messed up that code, oh well.

Never fear!
Ari is here!

[lane0168]

Majiffy, why did you vote game play then vote goodmorning so quickly?

[lane0168]

Before this gets out of hand and goes too far. I did use my roleblock. I'm just not coming out with it yet

[Majiffy]

Because there was a wagon on goodmorning, my preference clearly wasn't happening.

VOTE: Gameplay

[Realeo]

I am going to assume that you accuse Gameplay as sk?

[Majiffy]

No I think Gameplay is the other scum.

[Realeo]

Gameplay have been pushing on cy/GM from get go. Unless you're saying he's bussing him from get go. I mean, well yes, I remembered that you accuse gameplay for stop pushing on cy when the wagon collapses.

I will reread, but I have to admit that it doesn't click.

[Majiffy]

Have fun.

[Io]

Real kind of has a point. But clearly you're the type to reject evidence in favor of gut.

[lane0168]

Because there was a wagon on goodmorning, my preference clearly wasn't happening.

VOTE: Gameplay

You're preference clearly wasn't happening by post 11 of day two, so you just gave up on it cause there was 3 votes in goodmorning? Why are you so quick to give up?

Why are you voting Gameplay?

[lane0168]

I mean, I'm just not getting it. Why did you put a player at l-1 post 11 of day 2 if that wasn't your preference without doing anything to push your preference?

[lane0168]

I'll get to my point. That looks like bussing to me.

I also roleblocked majiffy

[lane0168]

Alpaca also looked like a bus.

[lane0168]

Gameplay if that's a bus its pretty amazing

[Realeo]

Real kind of has a point. But clearly you're the type to reject evidence in favor of gut.

Hey! I present ridiculous number about Cy's xD meta, so I am capable of evidence.

Here's the thing. When you are scum, you are meant to have a strategy. We town do scramble like chicken, but scum are a little bit organized.

Majiffy suggest that gameplay's strategy is to bus cy from a very early point.

If this is a classic mafia v town, gameplay has a lot to gain from bussing cy and I will seriously consider Majiffy's argument.

But this is multiball. Yes, gameplay may get towncred, but he may get killed by sk instead. At this point of the game, I think sk will focus killing town. Mafiasos are sk's enemy, but at the beginning, they are "friends" for making the game quicker.

[Bins]

VOTE: Majiffy

=}

[Realeo]

I throw a hypothesis earlier.

I think the reason JaeReed is dead is scum want to frame Dunnstral, but by magic-o-magic, he got killed by SK or vig. The question, who on D1 scumread Dunnstral?

I have an actual train to catch, so I will try to chime in in train.

[Io]

Real kind of has a point. But clearly you're the type to reject evidence in favor of gut.

Hey! I present ridiculous number about Cy's xD meta, so I am capable of evidence.

Here's the thing. When you are scum, you are meant to have a strategy. We town do scramble like chicken, but scum are a little bit organized.

Majiffy suggest that gameplay's strategy is to bus cy from a very early point.

If this is a classic mafia v town, gameplay has a lot to gain from bussing cy and I will seriously consider Majiffy's argument.

But this is multiball. Yes, gameplay may get towncred, but he may get killed by sk instead. At this point of the game, I think sk will focus killing town. Mafiasos are sk's enemy, but at the beginning, they are "friends" for making the game quicker.

I love how you go on this tangent when I was talking about Maji.

[Realeo]

Thank you xD.

[gameplay506]

Maji I seriously don't know whether you are just dumb or scum.
Also lets just stop with the whole NK theories. They will just confuse us more. Tho Dunn its p obv Dunn was town.
My votes today are Maji/Alpaca and maybe just maybe lo just because she is the other one I am not sure on.

[gameplay506]

VOTE: Maji
Anyway I was doing some partner speculation. I thought it was either paca/far. But since far is dead idk.