Newbie 1731 | Under the Sea | Endgame

[Plotinus]

Official Vote Count 1.06

This is deep sea fish is shaped like a whale but it only grows to be 40cm long.

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Killthestory

(L-3):

narcoticcrab,

XnadrojX, kagesong

Irrational Agent

(L-3): lalaladucks, Killthestory

Bellaphant

(L-4): DeathRowKitty

Kagesong

(L-4): Bellaphant

lalaladucks

(L-4): Libellule

Not Voting

(2): Irrational Agent, narcoticcrab

M

o

d

n

o

t

e

s

:

K

e

e

p

i

t

f

u

n

!

B

e

l

l

a

p

h

a

n

t

i

s

V

/

L

A

u

n

t

i

l

S

a

t

u

r

d

a

y

.

I

r

r

a

t

i

o

n

a

l

A

g

e

n

t

i

s

t

h

e

n

e

w

c

a

r

a

m

e

l

i

s

a

!

I

r

r

a

t

i

o

n

a

l

A

g

e

n

t

i

s

V

/

L

A

u

n

t

i

l

t

h

e

e

n

d

o

f

t

h

e

w

e

e

k

e

n

d

.

D

e

a

d

l

i

n

e

:

(expired on 2016-08-21 14:00:00)

.

[Irrational Agent]

OK, so, this is my first game on this site, but not the first game of forum mafia. But you guys aren't especially active. So, here's what I think:

@Bellaphant

: nullread. She hasn't been especially active. Since she's currently on VLA, I think I could wait and see. Besides, she's IC, so other things being equal, I'm less inclined to lynch her on day 1.

@DeathRowKitty

: slight townlean. All she did was try to "apply pressure" on everyone (which is townish), then went silent (which might be townish, but might also be just scumlurking)

@kagesong

: likely town, especially post 139.

@KillTheStory

: scumlean. Look, I've read a couple of games on this site and there were people like this who flipped town, sometimes even town PR. Maybe you're really taking your "teaching" mission seriously. But man... you're being weird! And when called out, start explaining theory, talking about your own meta... And what's up with these reads:

One of {Narco, Xnad} is scum. Kage is town. Melissa actively null. Libellule town. The two SEs and one IC have done close to nothing which is surprising, but I read DRK the towniest out of all of them.

Why is Libellule town? And your vote against Xnad seems very OMGUS. And can you explain them?

@lalaladucks

: neutral to slight scumlean. All you've done is actively lurk, agree with @KTS's weird reads and vote for my slot. But I have to say, your reason in #124 does look like safe townplay. Yet, the wiki says mafia often tries to lynch inactive persons.

@Libellule

: neutral to slight scumlean. She hasn't been very active, but the tendency to randomly change votes is concerning. Yet she isn't jumping on wagons, so maybe she's trying to play like DRK.

@narcoticcrab

: I'm putting scumlean here. Looks like newbscum. Tunneling, supporting a wagon, capitalizing on noobishness. But this made me giggle:

@mod can you correct stuped to stupid

@XnadrojX

: looks like town trying to play safe.

So, what to do? Nobody is voting for crab. Maybe if I vote for him, he'll start saying something interesting.

VOTE: narcoticcrab

F

i

x

e

d

b

r

o

k

e

n

p

o

s

t

t

a

g

s

.

-

-

P

[Irrational Agent]

>And can you explain them?

By that I meant you didn't provide any explanation in your post.

[Irrational Agent]

And your vote against Xnad seems very OMGUS

And by "vote" I mean "disposition".

[Irrational Agent]

Although upon re-reading @crab's ISO, he reads more townish, especially post 165. So I'll UNVOTE: for now and wait.

I

f

i

x

e

d

t

h

e

p

o

s

t

t

a

g

.

Y

o

u

d

i

d

[

p

o

s

t

=

#

1

6

5

]

p

o

s

t

1

6

5

[

/

p

o

s

t

]

.

Y

o

u

n

e

e

d

e

d

t

o

d

o

[

p

o

s

t

]

1

6

5

[

/

p

o

s

t

]

o

r

[

p

o

s

t

=

1

6

5

]

p

o

s

t

1

6

5

[

/

p

o

s

t

]

.

-

-

P

[kagesong]

@Agent Welcome to the game and to MS.

Thank you for wording my thoughts on KTS better than I could. Though I start to read less scummy later in exchanges. But, that's based kind of on other peoples' reactions more than is own play.

I tend to avoid reads on actilurking, mostly because it can be used for several reasons.

I lean scum on Bellaphant, mainly for the same reason as drk points out in #30 (sorry I don't know how to link it.

I actually lean a little scum on you because of Caram's (not done right) vote in #28, then subsequent disappearance.

Lala just comes off as a difficult read for me.

I have to agree with a scum read on Crab. He seems to be trying to buddy with various people, or make hard enemies of people that have been accused.

[XnadrojX]

Ok, at this stage of the game, i think i can form a few weak reads. I am absolutely shit at scumhunting/townhunting or forming reads in general so hopefully, by the time the game moves on to a more critical stage, my reads then will be more plausible, educated, rational and accurate than what i have now. Mostly the people I can at least form an opinion on are the people whom I interact with within the game.

Libellule1: Neutral IMO, he is rather lurkish but he seems to be helpful or maybe that could be me being bias due to his "Xna is credible and probably innocent" post

kagesong: Seems actively pushing on KTS, originally had a scumlean on her/him, but after ISOing her posts, searching up all the mafia terminology, listening to everyone's opinion and seeing how she tries to push the game forward (maybe a bit too hard), I think I'm a bit more willing to see her as neutral leaning slightly to scum for her push. But as KTS mentioned, it could be due to her "Tunneling" which apparently means she/he is holding on very firmly to her/his beliefs, so I'll read her deeper later in the game when we can gather more information.

Irrational Agent: Just replaced in for caramelisa, who was pretty much unreadable due to disappearing.

narcotticcrab

: I could not see anything wrong with what he was posting but then suddenly the jump from "KTS ain't contributing" to a "KTS is possibly Townie" was a pretty major leap IMO so slight scumlean as a pretty major leap IMO so slight scumlean.

lalaladucks: Quite a bit of fluffposting. Not really helping the game move along. Hasn't done anything particular to note. Neutral bordering on scumlean.

DeathRowKitty

: Appears to be a bit inactive, but IMO he/she seems to be contributing so yeah slight townlean.

Killthestory

: Read my ISO

Bellaphant

: V/LA so a bit hard to read, but for now a slight townlean, has not done anything particularly scummy and pushing the game forward and other townish stuff etc.

[kagesong]

I'm sorry I can't quite read your statement about me seriously. I'm a 26 year old male, lol. Very feminine and not in the least offended, so no worries. Just very very amused.

[Irrational Agent]

sorry I don't know how to link it

I just noticed I can't either. All links in my post lead to completely different threads from long ago. I was doing [⁠post=#POST_NUMBER]...[⁠/post]

I

w

e

n

t

b

a

c

k

a

n

d

f

i

x

e

d

i

t

f

o

r

y

o

u

a

n

d

p

u

t

a

n

e

x

p

l

a

n

a

t

i

o

n

o

f

h

o

w

t

h

e

t

a

g

s

w

o

r

k

i

n

.

-

-

P

[Irrational Agent]

I went back and fixed it for you and put an explanation of how the tags work in. --P

Thank you! Could you please fix #176? Although if it's too much, don't bother.

D

o

n

e

!

I

t

o

n

l

y

t

a

k

e

s

a

s

e

c

o

n

d

;

i

t

'

s

n

o

t

a

b

o

t

h

e

r

.

-

-

P

[XnadrojX]

More detailed post later, but for now, not much has been said, @Kagesong sorry did not know you're male, noted.

[Killthestory]

lol all the newbies scumreading me.

is an se or ic scumreading me? that could be a real indication of my alignment :^)

[Irrational Agent]

lol all the newbies scumreading me.

is an se or ic scumreading me? that could be a real indication of my alignment :^)

Look, if you're really town trying an innovative playstyle, it just isn't working that well.

VOTE: Killthestory

[Killthestory]

this isn't an innovative playstyle. this is my playstyle, and it works well when people know me. i play anti-meta until it isn't anti-meta, but new players will never understand my playstyle. veterans don't either.

lol edgy.

[Irrational Agent]

it works well when people know me (...) new players will never understand my playstyle. veterans don't either.

Well, who understands it, then?

[Killthestory]

nobody.

but the veterans know to leave me alone because i catch scum like i catch my bitches bois osi s

[Irrational Agent]

[Killthestory]

your confused because you'er confused.

[XnadrojX]

We ARE confused, can you be less confusing please

[Killthestory]

or am i the true confused one here

[kagesong]

I really just want to re-emphasize this post. No matter what. I simply do not find KTS beneficial. And I am not all that new to the game, or this site.

[kagesong]

More detailed post later, but for now, not much has been said, @Kagesong sorry did not know you're male, noted.

No worries. It may be helpful to note the pronoun preference under the avatar. A lot of people don't seem to realize they exist though. As I said, zero offense was taken. However, some people get real on edge about it.

[lalaladucks]

i'm kind of worried froggybaby is scum :< come play hangman with me & plz stop thread-avoiding meow meow meow~

I simply do not find KTS beneficial.

eh i kinda like him! probably one of the more entertaining ones of the bunch here. also he's apparently not actually a twelvie so that's a plus.

i laughed

I am absolutely shit at scumhunting/townhunting or forming reads in general

ooh me too, wanna be friends?

lalaladucks: Quite a bit of fluffposting. Not really helping the game move along. Hasn't done anything particular to note. Neutral bordering on scum lean.

this really just reads to me as an echo of

@lalaladucks

: neutral to slight scumlean. All you've done is actively lurk, agree with @KTS's weird reads and vote for my slot. But I have to say, your reason in #124 does look like safe townplay. Yet, the wiki says mafia often tries to lynch inactive persons.

& that looks a bit scummy of you, xnad. are you just tryna look busy? "oh look at me making reads on people + doing things!"
i wonder if you really haven't got any original thoughts about me!

tbh i haven't yet properly read through the reads on other people so. not sure how similar those are to irrational's

[lalaladucks]

ok from how this is goin i think KTS is possibly townie but im not sure just his demeinor seems a lil off but it could be culture changes between where we could be im not real sure what is going on so im gonna begin to watch and read more closely but im gonna unvote and watch how this goes cause im just not sure who is what right now and i dont want to vote rong person

UNVOTE: Killthestory

it doesn't matter if you're voting the wrong person if they're still a few votes away from being lynched! you're being overly cautious
i say follow your <3, it'll tell you who the dirty scums are. and vote them. and if you have a change of <3 just change your vote, ezpz

[lalaladucks]

@ploti: me gusta mucho tu color de mod