Mini 1821 Badass Women U-Pick Mafia - game over

[pirate mollie]

And don't even think about mafia treestump because there is literally no point in making a mafia treestump because a treestumped mafia will be just forced to troll or prod dodge.

I've yet to see her prove it so

I don't think it needs to be proven tbqh because claiming a treestump is begging to be vigged/lynched.
But if we're wasting a lynch to prove it, hey we lynched scum D1, we can waste a lynch.

we lynched an sk, we did not lynch grpscum. there are no associations to work off of. it isn't the same thing.

I am trying to work out how pie knew luna was an sk. I have been stonewalled.

why are you fucking voting me

[beegirl]

You are a strong willed visitor LOL

[pirate mollie]

Yes, that means I'll visit him again tonight.
And then we'll get our stuff together and lynch mala for great justice.

what consecutive, non actionable targeted role are you claiming

[pirate mollie]

(Also, I would totally vig a claimed treestump in a situation like this.)

(I wld support this)

[Layla]

I think you proving yourself as a treestump is necessary for town to move on.

Also, lynching a SK still means scum lynched.
One of the reason for Pie scumreading Luna as a SK is because she claimed a messanger AND a vig, which are two roles that are very unlikely to be paired together, and on top of that, she claimed that she can use both of the abilities simultaneously, which means... yeah. Only a SK would be capable of vigging and messaging at the same time. Mafia is unlikely to claim vig because well, unless mod put a scum vig, they gotta prove that there's a second kill.

[Layla]

You are a strong willed visitor LOL

with a twist, is what I'm claiming.

[UpTooLate]

Layla why doesn't he just shoot mala?

[pirate mollie]

I think you proving yourself as a treestump is necessary for town to move on.

Also, lynching a SK still means scum lynched.
One of the reason for Pie scumreading Luna as a SK is because she claimed a messanger AND a vig, which are two roles that are very unlikely to be paired together, and on top of that, she claimed that she can use both of the abilities simultaneously, which means... yeah. Only a SK would be capable of vigging and messaging at the same time. Mafia is unlikely to claim vig because well, unless mod put a scum vig, they gotta prove that there's a second kill.

uhm. what?

she flipped messanger AND sk. so I am not following your argument that pie's reason for voting luna is town holds water since you are basing it off of the assumption that luna's claim is not valid when she flipped what pie thought was the most unlikely scenario and that somehow makes him town for it, especially when she is saying that it was based on a specific sk-playstyle going on.

[Layla]

Layla why doesn't he just shoot mala?

It kinda needs to be Skybird.
I'm not in control of that.

[pirate mollie]

plz don't ignore me layla

[Layla]

uhm. what?

she flipped messanger AND sk. so I am not following your argument that pie's reason for voting luna is town holds water since you are basing it off of the assumption that luna's claim is not valid when she flipped what pie thought was the most unlikely scenario and that somehow makes him town for it, especially when she is saying that it was based on a specific sk-playstyle going on.

I mean I don't know the sk-playstyle reason thing too since I never saw it. (For an extra, my entire reason of my Luna townread was compromised of "Luna wouldn't act like this as mafia.")
First she claimed messenger, and then later in the game she claimed vig. And then she claimed that she can use both abilities at the same night. She flipped messenger SK, as pie deduced. Also, I was more of arguing that "her catching SK like that doesn't make her mafia" than "she is town for catching SK like that", if you get what I mean.

[Layla]

P-Edit: I was typing!

[Layla]

Wow, did I really say "compromised"?
I meant "composed of"

[pieguyn]

GIF, how in the hell is it that you get the logic for Luna's role being an obvious SK role *now* and you didn't get it back when I was actually lynching her?

vote: pirate mollie

[pirate mollie]

uhm. what?

she flipped messanger AND sk. so I am not following your argument that pie's reason for voting luna is town holds water since you are basing it off of the assumption that luna's claim is not valid when she flipped what pie thought was the most unlikely scenario and that somehow makes him town for it, especially when she is saying that it was based on a specific sk-playstyle going on.

I mean I don't know the sk-playstyle reason thing too since I never saw it. (For an extra, my entire reason of my Luna townread was compromised of "Luna wouldn't act like this as mafia.")
First she claimed messenger, and then later in the game she claimed vig. And then she claimed that she can use both abilities at the same night. She flipped messenger SK, as pie deduced. Also, I was more of arguing that "her catching SK like that doesn't make her mafia" than "she is town for catching SK like that", if you get what I mean.

what you said was that pie deduced she was sk because the messenger sk role was unlikely, which is what she flipped.

since you are positing that pie is not scum cos "her catching SK like that doesn't make her mafia" then what are you basing your town read on her on?

[pirate mollie]

GIF, how in the hell is it that you get the logic for Luna's role being an obvious SK role *now* and you didn't get it back when I was actually lynching her?

vote: pirate mollie

^^^^ wants to remove my vote by the way

[Layla]

GIF, how in the hell is it that you get the logic for Luna's role being an obvious SK role *now* and you didn't get it back when I was actually lynching her?

vote: pirate mollie

I was being a total tsundere about it. If I didn't get it and still held on Luna being 100% town, I wouldn't have voted her ever. Even though the ultimate thing that got me to believe the existence of SK was my PoE list wanting itself to shrink to two names.

[Malakittens]

Ugh I don't want to lynch Mollie either /:

I don't really understand why we aren't lynching in the two idiotic vig claimsz

[Malakittens]

Mollie Piegirl is town please.
Piegirl Mollie is town super please.

[UpTooLate]

Because Ari is town and people have written off yume as just a shit player.

[Layla]

what you said was that pie deduced she was sk because the messenger sk role was unlikely, which is what she flipped.

since you are positing that pie is not scum cos "her catching SK like that doesn't make her mafia" then what are you basing your town read on her on?

Nononono, I said that she deduced that she was SK because what she claimed was a very SK-ish role, not because it was unlikely.
My base on pie townread?

Hehe
Ehehehehe
EheuhuehuehueahuHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAH

...

It's a company secret.

[Malakittens]

I really don't agree with Ari being town, but I dont agree with Yume being town either. I'm conflicted, which is really shitty

[Malakittens]

Oh and gif is probably town just fucking mislead.

[UpTooLate]

Mala have you even read the game?

[Layla]

But honestly, literally the 99% times of how i read pie is just glance at her posts and decide if she's town or not.
I am dead serious, and it has been working quite well.