The Walking Dead Season 1 Finale (GAME OVER)

[MariaR]

I think i'm looking for scumtells more then I am town tells that could be a problem.

[Wisdom]

@something smart

: is there a specific reason you keep asking questions that you don't care what the answer is or if it's answered at all?

i don't see you doing in this previous town games. I actually checked

Oh! Me! Me! Me! I got the answer!

hey look, yet another instance of BBT getting manipulated by Maxous

[Wisdom]

Like, 772 can't be any more loaded

[Xkfyu]

Yeah ok, if we aren't lynching Cakez, I'd be happy with a Maxous lynch.

[Wisdom]

Mollie isn’t getting lynched today. Join the Hebi wagon and lynch scum and I’ll help you out on Mollie tomorrow if she isn’t dead or Mod confirmed overnight.

reminding Magna that this needs to happen

[Wisdom]

I had max/hebichan scum team since I reread something funky.
Example was how max says he could vote hebichan but doesn't.
Mollie also is in this pile of association.
The interaction with mollie was awfyl

oh hey farside has me beat a long time now

never again I am going to be content with skimming D1 again

[Radja]

DrippingGoofball(1st prod) and PeregrineV(1st prod) have been prodded.

[Radja]

Day 2, VC 7

SirCakez (3)

-

CatDog, Xkfyu, pirate mollie

BlueBloodedToffee (3)

-

Basic, Ankamius, Young and Witless

CatDog (2)

-

farside22, KuroiXHF

pirate mollie (2)

-

My Other Head Is Scum, MariaR

Maxous (2)

-

MagnaofIllusion, Wisdom

PeregrineV (1)

-

Maxous

Xkfyu (1)

-

SirCakez

Not Voting (3)

-

BlueBloodedToffee, DrippingGoofball, PeregrineV

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch! Deadline is on September 5th at 10:00 PM(GMT+1) or in (expired on 2016-09-05 22:00:00).

Mod Notes - None

[Wisdom]

Reread finished

Maxous and mollie are scum

Peregrine prolly isn't scum given Maxous trying to paint him as a hebi buddy (also did it to Basic) - but that requires Maxous to flip scum first

Dunno who the fourth is. I need to reexamine the Cakez/CatDog thing sometime because the fourth is probably in there. Anyway not the priority

Let's hang Maxous and mollie.

[Maxous]

i'm still not delighted with them but eh, being the counter to a scum-wagon gets them enough leeway for now
though their BBT push doesn't endear me further.

Well this is where we reach an impasse where I can’t cross a chasm away from you as scum.

You specifically went out of your way yesterday to discuss how your Day 1 reads were not dependent as they were pre-flip. That’s a fine stance to take but you just blindly stuck to a wagon on YAW and gave lip service to the Hebi wagon. And now think people shouldn’t find your behavior suspect especially given the flip?

:shrug:
you can find it suspect if you want, I explained my thought process pretty transparently on both Day 1 and Day 2 here.
i had a scum-read on both slots BEFORE they became big competing wagons which contradicts this idea that I was pushing YAW to protect hebi.
i mean, it's not even as if i was town-reading hebi or putting her null/ avoiding an opinion. I was pretty supportive of the wagon.
I don't think you even have a problem with the logic reasoning on my reads.
The big issue is that I didn't actually vote her...which is whatever?

in fact

counter-question

: if i was so desperate to protect my ninja buddy then why did I highlight her shit vote here in the first place?
this was back when hebi wasn't under a whole lot of pressure

There is nothing wrong with his BBT push. I think BBT fits well into a pool of viable scum reads today based on how he handled the Hebi wagon yesterday. I’ve already explained this. His claim is just that – a claim that I take at face value. Do I think it makes sense from Scum? Probably not but it is not outside the realm of possibility for reasons that I have in the back of my mind that aren’t relevant to today. So your second reason for suspecting them makes little sense to me.

meh, i don't agree. The vote came across like an OMGUS but the real problem i had was the lack of willingness to take BBT's claim into account.
if you want to say, "I think he's lying" or something yeah, fine but YAW tried to completely ignore the claim altogether which struck me as somebody designating a scum-read rather than somebody organically having a scumread and factoring new information into your reads.
it's not as if the claim was an alignment-neutral claim either

[Maxous]

young & witless might be scum white knighting SirCakez

I just realized it was Maxous that got this shit in BBT's head and it's making me dislike him

@something smart

: is there a specific reason you keep asking questions that you don't care what the answer is or if it's answered at all?

i don't see you doing in this previous town games. I actually checked

Oh! Me! Me! Me! I got the answer!

hey look, yet another instance of BBT getting manipulated by Maxous

you're way over-thinking this

[Wisdom]

nah

[Wisdom]

Your posts are manipulative in order to get people to get on YAW and leave hebi alone

[KuroiXHF]

Talk to me about them, I'm in the process of rereading D1

I'm training someone at work so all I can do at this very second is to tell you who I scumread:
pirate mollie
MariaR - slightly
CatDog
Maxous
PeregrineV - slightly

Alright, I can explain a bit on my scum reads.

Pirate Mollie - It's pretty obvious. She's reaching. She reminds me nothing of the town Mollie I've played with.
Catdog - I haven't liked a damn thing that they've voted, although I feel itching to switch to someone else.
MariaR - Not even comfortable in her own clothes and she's throwing scum tells, but it could just be her. Her old slot-fill hasn't pinged me super hard.
Maxous - I'm really thrown off by his posts.
PeregrineV - All I have is that his silence seems to be something he's consistently done as scum, so I'm actually quite suspicious.

[MariaR]

I expect some giant ass paragraph and I get THIS ^^^^ zzzz

[MariaR]

Well to be fair it's more then I've done so I can't really speak.

[KuroiXHF]

I expect some giant ass paragraph and I get THIS ^^^^ zzzz

I'm not giving an entire case about all my scum. I'm just giving a brief reason why I suspect my scum reads.

[MariaR]

Fair enough.

[DrippingGoofball]

argh prod dodge I have a meeting tonight

[pirate mollie]

Ok … at least I know where to proceed from at this point.

what is your read on him?

I thought his cross posting with you looked townish but wis has never misread me, the only time he thought that I was scum when I wasn't he was scum. it is 1 of the handful of times I got mislynched and it was cos he shoved my wagon through much like how he is in this gamer. he was lynched the next day round but kuroi went on to win the game. he really really feels like scum here.

[pirate mollie]

Or, you know, BBT lied. Why isn’t that possibility on your radar at all? I mean it seems less likely but shouldn’t be dismissed.

Why does BBT come out and fakeclaim that while under no pressure whatsoever?

why wld I soft claim on d1 under no pressure? especially when I am not known for fake claiming claim as scum?

your read on me feels fake as shit.

[pirate mollie]

Why does BBT come out and fakeclaim that while under no pressure whatsoever?

Why does he pre-emptively as Town come out and "clear" DGB when DGB was under no pressure whatsoever at that point either? It's a non-starter question as it makes sense as neither alignment.

how does it make sense as either alignment?

I think bbt is town.

[pirate mollie]

VOTE: Mollie The spat between Mollie and Kuroi looks very forced and Mollies comes across as arrogant, with fluff questions that aren't doing anything to advance the game. Kuroi's reaction on the otherhand is pretty similar to how I imagine I would react and so I'm tentatively listing Kuroi as town.

I also like BBT's point about YAW, but I like my vote better on Mollie.

they aren't fluff questions.

like your interpretation is forced cos you are having to make shit up about what you THINK that I am saying instead of just asking me, "hey mollie, what was the point of that question" god I fucking hate this game sometimes.

Also this is awful

Much like Sircakez recently, mollie here dubs an attack on her forced because it's unthinkable that Maverick just expressed his interpretation of mollie's actions

I actually like Maverick's couple of posts here

this is fake as shit wis.

if wis flips scum maria is town cos it looks like he is trying to groom her. mav's posts were terrible.

[Wisdom]

Ok … at least I know where to proceed from at this point.

what is your read on him?

I thought his cross posting with you looked townish but wis has never misread me, the only time he thought that I was scum when I wasn't he was scum. it is 1 of the handful of times I got mislynched and it was cos he shoved my wagon through much like how he is in this gamer. he was lynched the next day round but kuroi went on to win the game. he really really feels like scum here.

lol now im scum again?

[pirate mollie]

Also I like how mollie takes zero issue with hebi's bullshit vote on her while pushing Kuroi - compare with her reaction to Maverick voting her or Cakez voting her recently

I know mav and cake boy. I have played a few games with them both. they shld know better.