The Walking Dead Season 1 Finale (GAME OVER)

[KuroiXHF]

BTW, I'm so glad Hebichan isn't backwards. She's just scum.

[Maxous]

From Max: I would like from you instead of defense thoughts about the players in the game, who is scum and why.

alright, i'll take a look at the playerlist

BBT - town. has a clear on DGB anyway
SC - ehh probably town even if he tries patience sometimes
Ank - ank's not really doing anything and is low content. needs to be sorted
Kuroi - probably town honestly. don't think he run such a buss on hebi and hebi's reactions to him didn't seem like partners.
mollie - probably town.
farside - probably town
MariaR - eh, i'd lynch her. Maverick wasn't great and maria is doing nothing despite tons of posting.
DGB - cleared by BBT
MOHIS - 98% town
PV - quite possible scum. went AWOL recently but needs to be sorted.
YAW - still scum. I think it's pretty transparent what they're doing with their votes on Day 2
Magna - I would guess town. would he power-bus hebi? maybe. but it's not something i would worry about unless he's still alive near endgame.
basic - i would lean town but not overly sure. seems genuine enough i guess but would like to hear more
CatDog - probably town. frustration and tunnel on SC feels real.
xkfyu - yeah seems fine. don't have any issue with his posting
wisdom - town, maybe. hard-tunnel makes it hard to have an unbiased assessment.

[MariaR]

Come on Max we're scum partners remember you can't lynch me~

Let's have a cross between each other

(I just realized something that I prob should clarify at some point but it's in regards to my role so.)

[farside22]

Max reads leave me less then impressed. He doesn't even analysis the scum flip when making those reads.

[farside22]

Max reads leave me less then impressed. He doesn't even analysis the scum flip when making those reads.

Well the shade on magna over kuroi about bussing was in regards to herbi, but that about it.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Yeah, that was pretty poor from Maxous.

[farside22]

Spoiler:

Okay, you ATE as town then. I guess that is more factually accurate. Regardless, I have personally mislynched you because of your ATEing.

When I feel like it's tactical, it's scummy.
When I feel like it's sincere, it can make people a townread.

However, it almost always feels tactical- like now

.

can you give me an example?
i'm a bit confused by this

-

regarding SC, I get why people are voting him but i'm not overly convinced. we'll see.

young & witless might be scum white knighting SirCakez

YAW probably would of put more effort into the defense if they were buddies with SC.

This is kind of a mess since I did the reads in the order I looked at ISOs

Maverick looks scum
IPS looks scum (both of these two for posts that look like there was no actual thought put into them and were just scum faking posts instead)
Beeboy null (he's done nothing AI yet)
Maxous looks townish (posts look real, unlike top two people here)
Xkfyu null (same as beeboy)
Kuroi leans awkward town
BBT leans scum (lots of coasty shitposts, not sharing reads, etc)
PV looks town (not his scum meta at all, and I don't think PV is one to adapt to his meta)

So now I have
Town - Maxous, Kuroi, PV, MOHIS
Null - Beeboy, Xkfyu
Scum - BBT, TD, IPS, Maverick

Feel a lot better now readswise

P-edit: I didn't like it, it was hand waving

unvote, vote: Young and Witless

> The SC read isn't about your reasoning. Both your heads hard-defended SC and overly struggled to justify the read.
> What's the point of your questions to MOI?
> Why is Hebichan's interactions with Kuroi disgusting? That's vague and unconvincing

You should read the exchange between YAW and myself where they both state a town read on SC and then fail in being able to justify it.

That is really weird. I missed it before honestly, because townreads are townreads but cakez hasn't been the best player today. At the same time, I haven't been able to see many people justify a townread on Kuroi either, but that is more on them than kuroi... maybe I'm tunneling too hard here...

They are voting on me I guess? I think they made an okay reason there though. If they are scum though, they could easily be trying to hide a cakez scum.
They
UNVOTE:

VOTE: Young and Witless

i'm starting to understand the HC scum-reads now

HC wagon has my seal of approval.

I read max and sc iso and realized there has been little to none interaction with each other or hebi.

I'm thinking there scum together at this point.
I also recall Anka lurked more as scum so he's another I'd see as scum at this point.

Vote: max

[Maxous]

He doesn't even analysis the scum flip when making those reads.

Spoiler:

oh wow, no kill and all.

ehh ok

vote: PeregrineV

i remember not being a fan of his reads

in general

and i don't think he even addressed Hebi or her wagon?
looking at it now: yeah, he had her at null with a brush-off read.

gimme a few minutes and i'll ISO hebi

Okay, you ATE as town then. I guess that is more factually accurate. Regardless, I have personally mislynched you because of your ATEing.

Yeah, umm I can't believe no one understood my frustration on the fact i replaced into a game where i was VT while 4 people replaced into a PR slot and we lynched them because we thought it must have been a scum lurker.

That was just like, blew my mind.

~Nullbringer

You're being overly defensive for someone I'm calling town, like, calm down man.

just in case i had doubts about firebringer/vedith being town this makes them very town.
hebi was clearly trying to appease them

I do have to agree with Cakez. He super lurked when I was scum with him in ME.

Got me lynched cause he even lurked in our QT and never verified my fakeclaim.

So him being active here is a pretty decent indicator since I think hes mostly allergic to playing scum.

hmmmm, i think this gives town-points to SC
i don't see her using this shitty basic activity tell to defend a scum-partner under a lot of pressure.
it was a good way to avoid SC's wagon without actually giving a defense of him.

her fight with Kuroi does give him some town-points also. not so much the arguments themselves but hebi kept jabbing at him in a manner which seemed like she was legit angry at town catching her for "bad reasons"

yeah, i've gotten conflicted on catdog now.

I was fairly solidly town-reading them but their vote on hebi really rings alarm bells.

we'll see

[farside22]

One post by scum on another player doesn't = town.
You of all players know that.

[farside22]

Please tell me max how sc gets a free pass to blatantly not discuss the herbi wagon and he is a town read based on one fucking post from scum.

[MariaR]

All aboard the Max wagon choo choo!

[MariaR]

I have a bias tr on farside for having the same 2 sr's as me (Max and Cake)

[farside22]

I have a bias tr on farside for having the same 2 sr's as me (Max and Cake)

Now only if you stopped trying to push people's buttons, I'd consider you my in game mason partner.

[MariaR]

I can't be the only one who finds it stupid that Max's only defend is him quoting his very little interaction with hebi like saying "Bussing and talking with partners isn't a thing!"

Pedit: AWWWW PLEASE I'LL BE NICE

[Maxous]

eh, it's not as if my SC read is

entirely

based off that one post.
just that the manner of the post would indicate a negative connection in my opinion.
i'm not really gonna bat for SC with a town-case because why bother at this stage? and it's not as if he's my strongest town-read but if i had to call it, i would say he's town

[MariaR]

So Max's scum pool is me Peregrin who I didn't even know was in this game and YAW? Alright.

[MagnaofIllusion]

What is it you want answering Magna?

Here I’ve isolated it so you can see clearly my issues / question –

I mean, I felt good yesterday that we had two scum wagons as leading wagons.

See this makes no sense …

Young and Witless (5) - BlueBloodedToffee, Xkfyu, Maxous, pirate mollie, hebichan
hebichan (4) - KuroiXHF, Young and Witless, MagnaofIllusion, Wisdom
SirCakez (3) - CatDog, My Other Head Is Scum, TiphaineDeath

I don’t see it as viable for the game-state to be here as it is and for scum wagons to be on both YAW and Hebi and for the wagon on Cakez to just fall away while the other grow if you are stating he is Town and both the others are scum. Especially given the heat he is getting today. It doesn’t make sense for Hebi to be power-bussed over Cakez given her role. And if you are floating that Cakez is also scum I have the same problem I had with Maxous floating that possibility Day 1.

Care to explain why you think this?

[MagnaofIllusion]

Prodded- I'm here.

That's some whelming content right there ...

[Maxous]

So Max's scum pool is me Peregrin who I didn't even know was in this game and YAW? Alright.

+ ankamius

[MariaR]

I want to put YAW on hard town since I sr everyone on his wagon @ 5 votes between BBT but then again 4 scum all voting 1 person seems unlikely so I'm prob wrong on 1 read on that.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I don't understand your issue Magna.

[Wisdom]

Maxous needs rope

[Radja]

Day 2, VC 9

Maxous (6)

-

MagnaofIllusion, Wisdom, Young and Witless, SirCakez, MariaR, farside22

SirCakez (4)

-

CatDog, Xkfyu, pirate mollie, BlueBloodedToffee

pirate mollie (2)

-

My Other Head Is Scum, KuroiXHF

BlueBloodedToffee (1)

-

Ankamius

Young and Witless (1)

-

Maxous

Not Voting (3)

-

DrippingGoofball, PeregrineV, Basic

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch! Deadline is on September 5th at 10:00 PM(GMT+1) or in (expired on 2016-09-05 22:00:00).

Mod Notes - None

[Xkfyu]

Maxous needs rope

So does Cakez though.

[Young and Witless]

I think Wisdom and MoI are town. I have no idea about mollie, I guess I'm okay tabling that for a few days.
Kuroi and Cakez are tough... I could see Cakez as a Maxous partner, but Kuroi's reads are actually pretty good.
I think there's exactly one scum in <Maxous, MariaR>.

No idea where Creature's head is at.

@everyone voting SirCakez: do you see him as a potential partner to Maxous? If so, why not vote Maxous?

@Maxous: what do you think we're doing with our vote?
-smart