Lawyering is a scum tactic, looking for loopholes to escape suspicion.In post 219, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:House...
If I give reasoning to explain that we are not scum together, that means I can't bus him in the first place because only scum bus.
i don't have the time to meta read him at the moment, so sorry??In post 222, Blade Dancer wrote:Contradiction!
If you weren't scared of me because you didn't know me, this implies you take meta into your argument. Yet, you deliberately remain null on McMenno without effort to sort him via his meta.
Then I misread your question?House wrote:Lawyering is a scum tactic, looking for loopholes to escape suspicion.In post 219, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:House...
If I give reasoning to explain that we are not scum together, that means I can't bus him in the first place because only scum bus.
Doesn't work for me.
I said sell me scum (as in, results in a red flip) that doesn't leave me thinking YOU are bussing THEM if you want me drop my suspicion of you.
This crap about Sly won't fly.
Pretty much. Did you realize how he objected to my leading question but said he used the tactic himself.In post 225, House wrote:Lawyering is a scum tactic, looking for loopholes to escape suspicion.In post 219, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:House...
If I give reasoning to explain that we are not scum together, that means I can't bus him in the first place because only scum bus.
Doesn't work for me.
I said sell me scum (as in, results in a red flip) that doesn't leave me thinking YOU are bussing THEM if you want me drop my suspicion of you.
This crap about Sly won't fly.
I'm fine with playing the game my own way tyvmIn post 224, Blade Dancer wrote:Well, you're capable of deflection and fearing what I am up to.In post 221, McMenno wrote:evidently you can'tIn post 207, Blade Dancer wrote:Just like you didn't see House RVSing you as a threat either. We're you hoping for the ignore it and it goes away method of defense?In post 204, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:I don't see you as a threat.In post 202, Blade Dancer wrote:@giga, First, it likely wasn't true. Even if it was a joke,much jokes tend to be used by scum. Usually, after the types of votes McMenno casts though. Attacking players that are a threat then backing off as a joke is fairly commonly a scum move.
Oh and you can actually read McMenno. Pretty easy actually.
or is this a reaction test? in which case what are you trying to accomplish here
Why haven't you tried to sort anyone?
I have no idea who you are talking about.In post 227, Blade Dancer wrote:Pretty much. Did you realize how he objected to my leading question but said he used the tactic himself.In post 225, House wrote:Lawyering is a scum tactic, looking for loopholes to escape suspicion.In post 219, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:House...
If I give reasoning to explain that we are not scum together, that means I can't bus him in the first place because only scum bus.
Doesn't work for me.
I said sell me scum (as in, results in a red flip) that doesn't leave me thinking YOU are bussing THEM if you want me drop my suspicion of you.
This crap about Sly won't fly.
then i think we both (think we) know who they are :/In post 230, Not Chara wrote:shoot. i think i know who Blade Dancer is and it's going to make me incredibly biased even though i'm probably wrong.
Now it's my turn to refer to older posts. As I said in #209, among other posts, sly's bad push on giga in the first few pages implies he was trying to get giga killed, which wouldn't make sense for town!sly to do because it was based on nothing but really strange interpretations of the word "grapevine". It's just too much reaching for a town player to do. Thus, i believe sly is scum. Then, it follows that scum!sly would want to get town killed, as opposed to his own scumbuddy. The posibility of a anti-town 3rd party is there, but as of yet I have no evidence to support it, so the most likely result is that Giga is town. Hence my reads.In post 214, Blade Dancer wrote:@Pepto, There was plenty to say. You said I lacked real reasons for my positions. I show you my reasons. You don't respond to the substance or address the depth of my reads. I asked you why Giga was town as well.
Blade, could you just explain what this easy thing you're using to read McMenno is?In post 231, McMenno wrote:yeah, I know your type
thinking you're sooooo clever for catching people on one little "slip" and tunneling them to death
Can you do it without meta? That's what I was asking for anyway, sorry.In post 237, Not Chara wrote:gigabyte: i don't want to start making alignment guesses based on a player's meta when we aren't even sure it's really them. that's too many assumptions in one.
Because usually, someone not moving a vote to a scumread indicates they're either paranoid of getting kickback for their vote (which usually means scum) or is just really forgetful (which could be either alignment) or is trying to get a strong read before voting (which is usually town)In post 210, Not Chara wrote: i was scumreading House at the time, i did everything to show that but say so explicitly. i was considering moving my vote but between Sly, gigabyte, and zakk, there were a lot of options and i was in the middle of engaging with them.
your fixation on this point about me not voting immediately is strange. it's the standard 'why aren't you voting your scumread' filler question i've seen thrown around in every game i've been in, but for some reason you won't let go of it.
what's your read on me?
town, at the moment. town before i started wondering about their main, and so i don't think that read is biased. but not a strong read.In post 235, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:NC how are you reading Blade right now? Try to fight your bias if you think it's impacting you.
we're all online. what else do you do in mafia besides argue? c=In post 236, Ankamius wrote:How long are you 6 or so going to argue within yourselves?
OK, I seem to be the opposite though. In that I'm townreading them as Blade Dancer alone but scumreading with my guess of their main.In post 240, Not Chara wrote:town, at the moment. town before i started wondering about their main, and so i don't think that read is biased. but not a strong read.
well, yes. don't scumread someone on a guess.In post 242, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:OK, I seem to be the opposite though. In that I'm townreading them as Blade Dancer alone but scumreading with my guess of their main.In post 240, Not Chara wrote:town, at the moment. town before i started wondering about their main, and so i don't think that read is biased. but not a strong read.
Might be better to townread them then, I guess.
His posts.In post 237, Not Chara wrote:Blade, could you just explain what this easy thing you're using to read McMenno is?In post 231, McMenno wrote:yeah, I know your type
thinking you're sooooo clever for catching people on one little "slip" and tunneling them to death
gigabyte: i don't want to start making alignment guesses based on a player's meta when we aren't even sure it's really them. that's too many assumptions in one.
You got thoughts in there?In post 236, Ankamius wrote:How long are you 6 or so going to argue within yourselves?
so should my rvs be something like "oh you have cake in your name... I don't like cake *vote", trying to improve my scumgame hereIn post 244, Blade Dancer wrote:His posts.In post 237, Not Chara wrote:Blade, could you just explain what this easy thing you're using to read McMenno is?In post 231, McMenno wrote:yeah, I know your type
thinking you're sooooo clever for catching people on one little "slip" and tunneling them to death
gigabyte: i don't want to start making alignment guesses based on a player's meta when we aren't even sure it's really them. that's too many assumptions in one.
RVSing based on always scum.
Is my read on him serious?
Sneak vote onto Pepto.
What am I up to?
That's his entire ISO. He's reading but only interested in lurking/defense.
i already asked this. :>In post 246, Blade Dancer wrote:You got thoughts in there?In post 236, Ankamius wrote:How long are you 6 or so going to argue within yourselves?
