Mini 1836: Space Mafia (Game Over)

[MariaR]

Don't believe me then not my problem.

[Xkfyu]

Panther, I think I'm town reading you again...

Should I be concerned?

[PantherPunt]

can you briefly tell me:
what game you played with him as town

Stack the deck

BRUH

we played stack the deck. you were scum. I was town.

[Dunnstral]

Itlepip was there too, as town lol

Different account

[Dunnstral]

I wasn't referring to myself being town in that game

[Dunnstral]

also gonna require the thought process that got you to this one slugger

The same argument gou once used about brushing aside arguments and saying don't see it, except this time they're "too pure" to be scum

Doesn't help that you re calling xkfgu and itlepip scummy

Or have nothing on Zach

[TwoFace]

If toto is town, Panther might be mafia with Zach

or you know, zach could be town and you are tunneling for some unknown reason.

thoughts on massive and gerry please?

[PantherPunt]

Panther, I think I'm town reading you again...

Should I be concerned?

not gonna lie this made me smile

but didn't you say this as scum

[Xkfyu]

Panther, I think I'm town reading you again...

Should I be concerned?

not gonna lie this made me smile

but didn't you say this as scum

Indeed.

[PantherPunt]

also gonna require the thought process that got you to this one slugger

The same argument gou once used about brushing aside arguments and saying don't see it

, except this time they're "too pure" to be scum

Doesn't help that you re calling xkfgu and itlepip scummy

Or have nothing on Zach

trying to see if I follow..
you said "if toto is town, panther scum"

I once made an argument about brushing aside arguments and saying "don't see it"

and you're saying that I called that behavior scummy?

And you are saying that toto is guilty of doing that^?

Except now I'm not calling toto scum for that...I'm saying they're too pure?

Is that the crux of that?

If it's not, can you please try to help me see what you're saying

[PantherPunt]

and oh.... itlepip = florestan

that didn't register at first

that was super weird bc florestan we played in that newbie with was WAY different than the florestan in Stack the Deck. and they were both town

you're saying you see the same game as what...Stack the Deck then? and you're therefore not concerned?

^all @dunn

[Dunnstral]

And you are saying that toto is guilty of doing that^?

You're the one guilty of doing that

[Dunnstral]

that was super weird bc florestan we played in that newbie with was WAY different than the florestan in Stack the Deck. and they were both town

you're saying you see the same game as what...Stack the Deck then? and you're therefore not concerned?

Corection: you're the one who played with them in the newbie; I was dead before they replaced in

In stack the deck I used the differences in posting as a reason to scumread him and would have pushed for a lynch

The difference is that this is their play at the start of a game, rather than replacing in at the end of it

[Nosferatu]

The new guy is weird to me... like he came in and decided to bring something up just out the RVS stage.. Eh... this is confirm bias.. beacuse he replaced simple plan.. but I'm gonna post it because, I think Its crazy but others might disagree.

maybe he brought something up from RVS because he wasn't around to comment on it during RVS

[PantherPunt]

And you are saying that toto is guilty of doing that^?

You're the one guilty of doing that

ok so baby steps...still trying to figure out your thought process.

I'm guilty of: brushing aside an arguement and saying "I don't see it"

and you're saying thats scummy behavior (and I believe driving that with your assertion that I once made that argument)

am I on track now?

[Naomi-Tan]

The new guy is weird to me... like he came in and decided to bring something up just out the RVS stage.. Eh... this is confirm bias.. beacuse he replaced simple plan.. but I'm gonna post it because, I think Its crazy but others might disagree.

1) wasn't RVS.
2)
person A: ##vote:person B - serious vote
person B: why you think I'm scum
person A: I don't think you're scum
person B: *ignores*

I think it's crazy nobody every brought it up at the time.

Tell me more about your thoughts. It sounds like you don't see it as me trying to get clarity around players' thoughts. So do you think I have an agenda to push regarding one or more of the involved players?

Im still concerned about your slot. as simple plan pushed myself and I know i'm town and its the only real thing he did other than lurking. though now I see your point and yeah that is kinda a weird interaction.. the grapes part at least. Its kinda confusing to read and it muddles me up as I can't see anything other than a team interaction for it but im town reading them both which is just super confused!

[PantherPunt]

Im still concerned about your slot. as simple plan pushed myself and I know i'm town and its the only real thing he did other than lurking. though now I see your point and yeah that is kinda a weird interaction.. the grapes part at least. Its kinda confusing to read and it muddles me up as I can't see anything other than a team interaction for it but im town reading them both which is just super confused!

so to recap:
you were weired out and suspicious of my slot bc I brought up old stuff
now you see my point
you are still suspicious of my slot but it's bc of simple plan and not me

did you voice that suspicion before? or are you airing it out now for the first time?
is there a slot you're more concered with than mine? two? three?
who are you wholly unwilling to vote for today based on your read on them?

[Naomi-Tan]

Okay guys.. time is nearly Up and as we havn't made any movement to a united town lynch I would like to make a purposal.

Right now lets take all the 12 players and order them from each of our perspectives from green to red. Then we lynch the person who has the highest amount of people red reading them. like think we each give them a number between 1-12 with 12 being most red and 1 being least red. and then add up the numbers and as green we lynch the person with the highest over all number. Its not perfect.. but I don't think we are going to get a united front before the end of tomorrow.

[TwoFace]

Okay guys.. time is nearly Up and as we havn't made any movement to a united town lynch I would like to make a purposal.

Right now lets take all the 12 players and order them from each of our perspectives from green to red. Then we lynch the person who has the highest amount of people red reading them. like think we each give them a number between 1-12 with 12 being most red and 1 being least red. and then add up the numbers and as green we lynch the person with the highest over all number. Its not perfect.. but I don't think we are going to get a united front before the end of tomorrow.

Ew no

[PantherPunt]

wow just iso'd naomi

unwilling to touch today without even reading

[PantherPunt]

Okay guys.. time is nearly Up and as we havn't made any movement to a united town lynch I would like to make a purposal.

Right now lets take all the 12 players and order them from each of our perspectives from green to red. Then we lynch the person who has the highest amount of people red reading them. like think we each give them a number between 1-12 with 12 being most red and 1 being least red. and then add up the numbers and as green we lynch the person with the highest over all number. Its not perfect.. but I don't think we are going to get a united front before the end of tomorrow.

Ew no

welcome to the thread with panther in it.
hope to hear more thoughts from you

[Naomi-Tan]

Im still concerned about your slot. as simple plan pushed myself and I know i'm town and its the only real thing he did other than lurking. though now I see your point and yeah that is kinda a weird interaction.. the grapes part at least. Its kinda confusing to read and it muddles me up as I can't see anything other than a team interaction for it but im town reading them both which is just super confused!

so to recap:
you were weired out and suspicious of my slot bc I brought up old stuff
now you see my point
you are still suspicious of my slot but it's bc of simple plan and not me

did you voice that suspicion before? or are you airing it out now for the first time?
is there a slot you're more concered with than mine? two? three?
who are you wholly unwilling to vote for today based on your read on them?

I did voice the suspicion before. but didn't vote for it.
Yeah I find X the most suspicious. Your just kinda naggley in my mind and I think its mostly confirm bias
I think i'm unwilling to vote for Zach and Maria. Maybe Grapes. I feel that the Zach train is entirely bad but I think everyone is aware of my Green!Zach read Unfortunately I know one mafia member is definitely not on my radar and it might be two of them.. as I only feel firm on X.. everyone else hasn't been too suspicious for me :s

[Dunnstral]

And you are saying that toto is guilty of doing that^?

You're the one guilty of doing that

ok so baby steps...still trying to figure out your thought process.

I'm guilty of: brushing aside an arguement and saying "I don't see it"

and you're saying thats scummy behavior (and I believe driving that with your assertion that I once made that argument)

am I on track now?

Yes, except you didn't brush aside an argument, you brushed aside general notions near the beginning that toto is scum

[TwoFace]

Thanks for the welcome but I've already posted on the thread after you posted. I've also already posted my thoughts on the game. I tried to get you extra time so you could read and catch-up but you didn't want it.

[Dunnstral]

thoughts on massive and gerry please?

Also how dare you have the nerve, the AUDACITY to ask me what I think of them while voting me for being a "compromise lynch" with 4 days on deadline and 3 votes on me, and then not trying to figure the game out from there