Mini Normal 1839 - Game Over!

[Foxbird]

Votecount 1.9

ironstove

(1) - LmkGuy

AlpacaAlpaca

(3) - Nero Cain, Tracer, malpascp

Knighty Knight

(1) - aronagrundy

Tracer

(4) - Saru, ironstove, cmitc1, karnos

LmkGuy

(1) - Lowell

Lowell

(1) - PenguinPower

Not Voting

(2) - AlpacaAlpaca, Knighty Knight

With

13

players eligible to vote, it’s

7

to lynch!

Day 1 will end in

(expired on 2016-10-24 15:08:49).

Mod Notes:

None!

[Knighty Knight]

Also if we're being honest I am a little more active and contributing than others so...

[karnos]

And what do you think of karnos?

That is an open question to everyone.

Karnos is on the scummy side of null. Hasn't posted all too much, but when he does, mainly one liners.
@Karnos: Why do you think Tracer is scum besides what iron said?

I don't. Iron seems fairly towny, following his lead seems like a good plan for now in the absence of any strong scum reads.

[AlpacaAlpaca]

so you don't think that tracer is scummy but your voting her because you don't have any scum reads? If thats the case do you have any other town reads

[AlpacaAlpaca]

@Knight: What do you think of the lurkers. Also you unvote with

[karnos]

so you don't think that tracer is scummy but your voting her because you don't have any scum reads? If thats the case do you have any other town reads

I sure do. I don't see any reason to talk about them right now though.

[cmitc1]

Karnos seems pretty scummy to me

@Tracer: A complete readlist would be nice

@Knight: What do you think of the lurkers. Also you unvote with

Code: Select all

[unvote][/unvote]

Nothing in between the brackets is needed

Cmit just feels newbscum to me but than I look at his previous game and he was town and basically the same he is here so I'll have to think more on that.
@Cmit: An actual readlist from you might be nice as well actually

oh, you went and seen that disaster, qq.

I will work on it now.

[Nero Cain]

vote:Karnos

[karnos]

shoo Nero.

[AlpacaAlpaca]

so you don't think that tracer is scummy but your voting her because you don't have any scum reads? If thats the case do you have any other town reads

I sure do. I don't see any reason to talk about them right now though.

So you don't see any reason to talk about your reads? Or just the Tracer read?

[PenguinPower]

@mod: V/LA until 10/17

[Foxbird]

@mod: V/LA until 10/17

Noted!

[cmitc1]

1. LmkGuy-Im not getting any scum vibes off him, he hasnt been here lately, so i will put him at null for now.-null
2. Saru-is necessary super scummy, but I would like to see more from him.-null/town
3. Nero Cain- not seeing any reason to scumread him-town
4. karnos- Not really seeing much scumreading in his posts, and he seems to have the time to be here to post, so being bussy may not be a valid defense for this?-scum
5. PenguinPower-Id like to see less one liners, but, other than that, i'm not really getting scumvibes-null
6. ironstove- didnt really find a reason to scum read-town
7. malpascp-inavtive slot
8. aronagrundy- I didnt find any reason to scum her-town
9. Lowell-had a great recent post-slight town.
11. AlpacaAlpaca- I didnt find any reason to scumread him-town
12. Knighty Knight-town
13. Tracer-inactive slot, there is nothing in there ._.

[aronagrundy]

Work is running late, ill read up tonight

[LmkGuy]

Hey all was busy yesterday, but just woke up. I have a lan event so i eill post in a few hours once inset up my pc

[karnos]

so you don't think that tracer is scummy but your voting her because you don't have any scum reads? If thats the case do you have any other town reads

I sure do. I don't see any reason to talk about them right now though.

So you don't see any reason to talk about your reads? Or just the Tracer read?

I don't see the need to announce who my "conf town" are, as all it does is give them a list of good nightkill targets. If someone was getting wagoned hard and I thought they were town, I'd speak up. And when the game progresses it'll be nice to compare reads to find the final scum by PoE, but my general philosophy is that sharing all information at all times is anti-town.

[karnos]

Sharing town reads gives scum a road map to victory.

[Knighty Knight]

@Alpaca in response to 329.

Malpascp hasn't said anything since page 4 and what he did say wasn't very useful (fair enough given where we were at that time). He pretty much coasted through RVS and stopped posting after voting Alpaca and saying he didn't like Penguins signature which, on that topic, he has a 7-0 as scum, maybe by doing exactly what he is doing rn (unless of course that WL is faked). He hasn't called V/LA so unless he's dead irl, he is probably waiting for people to forget about him, which we did. Possible scum waiting till the iron (not the player) is hot to strike.

Saru also hasn't said anything (besides page 1 RVS) until 197 8 pages later... As for his argument in 316 he is pretty much doing the same thing, his 7 posts except for a few were asking about Iron's code. So Saru has like 2 or 3 posts that had some substance but the thing about Tracer was already an idea at that point, so more like 1 or 2 substantial posts. Still null on Saru, really just hasn't said enough to give me an opinion either way.

Lowell has said barely anything including RVS which, to be fair, he was trying to help out but after that, he went silent except for a post calling my read on Arona "opportunistic" which, after I explained he went back to being silent. Lowell also hasn't really said a whole lot, like... less than anyone else... and with less content as well. So I am going to have to sit null on Lowell as well, have nothing to base an opinion off of.

Tracer, hmmm, I guess the main issue with her is the whole 95 which everyone is already very familiar with. While she has posted a little more on who, there wasn't much why. So as I said and 311 I will be voting Tracer because she hasn't said anything explaining her choices and it is near the end of friday. If she gives me a good reason to unvote her by midnight I might unvote.

But for now

VOTE: Tracer

[Foxbird]

Tracer has requested replacement.
Searching for one now.

[Knighty Knight]

Well, I guess that answers that question...

[ironstove]

Tracer has requested replacement.
Searching for one now.

newb scum cracking under the pressure.

keep this train rolling boys.

[Nero Cain]

What even is the point of an alt account?

it hides peoples mains so they can play differently

[aronagrundy]

All done and these things stuck out to me:

@lowell: why don't you consider the possibility of knight being newbtown (or newb anything at all)? He's clearly labeled as Townie, and you take this into account when looking at me and cmitc. I'm getting more newbtown vibes from knight in his latest posts and I think he can easily read as confused town.

@pp: ok since you're v/la this is part question part statement since you might not be online to answer this over the next couple of days. Looking over the thread basically every time someone mentions that they suspect him, pp kind of freaks out? He's basically responds by discrediting the character of each person that suspects him by either passing them off as scum (me, lowell) and his tone toward tracer is very dismissive toward her in general. Just looking over his posts he seems so overly defensive and right now I think he's my strongest scumread.

Re: tracer, I don't like how she popped back up to just fight with pp a bit and just hint at actual reasons for her presumed scumread. Not sure how to interpret the replacement request but I think it's NAI.

[aronagrundy]

the best example of what I'm talking about with pp is here:

penguin. Reads similar to LmkGuy, but less so. He spent a lot of time early trying to make jokes and prove his winning personality. He's improved, slightly, perhaps, but still seems to post only when there's a light moment he can pounce on. I also don't like how he egged iron on to hammer alpaca early, only to more or less immediately say how the threat wasn't serious.

Wow...this is a complete misrepresentation of what happened. Except for the joking and winning personality. I definitely do/have that.

Coupled with your IronStove read...Heavens to Betsy if you aren't somewhat scummy.

He brings up the "IronStove read" without elaborating on it at all and immediately scumreads him, then votes him. Not taking into account his current V/LA, after RVS he's mostly just shown up whenever someone calls him scum. I know he's V/LA but it's where my gut's at right now.

VOTE: penguin

[Foxbird]

Prodding malpascp and Lowell.