I think if he was scum yeah he's bringing unneeded attention to himself while still lurking that seems more towny then scummyIn post 871, Creature wrote:Maybe the difference is that I mentioned that in Wake's Role Madness because there were a lot of lurkers there and I could make myself look better than them there. While GuiltyLion is likely the more lurky player here, but my question is: Wouldn't he try to be himself more active if he's suggesting that?
I think gamma's a good enough player to suppress an early amount of pressure as scum.In post 872, Creature wrote:Thought we agreed that Gamma's reaction earlier the day was towny. What do you think about it?
You have a pointIn post 874, Grapevine wrote:Okay again like. Why do you read people based on playstyle when gamma's playstyle isn't the hardest thing in the world to fake in the first place and why do you shrug off the hardest thing for scum to convincingly fake consistently.
Like look at gamma's reads and there progression.
In particular his scumreads.
Dunn's scum.
Expedience is scum.
Neither of those reads got any movement at all and the baseline reasoning was entirely bad to the point where the solid conviction he has there doesn't seem to stack up. Especially so when you apply that to what his priority is in posting so far.
pedit: @stargazers
You made a good argument to why it's a bad post, but I'm not really seeing what makes it scummy.In post 870, Stargazers wrote:In post 234, Stargazers wrote:I really really hate this post yes you're right spamming is a scum tactic just like making long paragraphs is a scum tactic just like ate is a scum tactic see the point?In post 153, SlySly wrote:Actually, that did answer the question, but I'll elaborate.In post 152, Gamma Emerald wrote:You didn't answer the actual question.In post 150, SlySly wrote:It's more serious than my RVS, but not by a lot.
You've been talking non-stop. Spamming is a scum tactic. I'm not necessarily reading you as scum, but you have a LOT of posts already only 7 pages into a mini.
I'm perfectly fine with being on your wagon right now. Pressure is good and likely to bring info that will help form true reads.
Everything can be used as a scum tactic I would just think you're over thinking into this but it seems like you're lightly pushing and trying to get the vibe of "Gamma isn't town" but not scumreading him yet
Pressure is a thing in games yes but doing it for reads is something I hate because people may not have strong reads right away and just forcing someone to out them via pressure can go south very fast
~Maria
This was my reasoning behind that post but maybe I'm just hitting air~Maria
I think he wanted us to not townread Gamma with the most without him himself saying Gamma is scummy.In post 880, Infinity 324 wrote:You made a good argument to why it's a bad post, but I'm not really seeing what makes it scummy.In post 870, Stargazers wrote:In post 234, Stargazers wrote:I really really hate this post yes you're right spamming is a scum tactic just like making long paragraphs is a scum tactic just like ate is a scum tactic see the point?In post 153, SlySly wrote:Actually, that did answer the question, but I'll elaborate.In post 152, Gamma Emerald wrote:You didn't answer the actual question.In post 150, SlySly wrote:It's more serious than my RVS, but not by a lot.
You've been talking non-stop. Spamming is a scum tactic. I'm not necessarily reading you as scum, but you have a LOT of posts already only 7 pages into a mini.
I'm perfectly fine with being on your wagon right now. Pressure is good and likely to bring info that will help form true reads.
Everything can be used as a scum tactic I would just think you're over thinking into this but it seems like you're lightly pushing and trying to get the vibe of "Gamma isn't town" but not scumreading him yet
Pressure is a thing in games yes but doing it for reads is something I hate because people may not have strong reads right away and just forcing someone to out them via pressure can go south very fast
~Maria
This was my reasoning behind that post but maybe I'm just hitting air~Maria
Gamma's playstyle seems like a dumb thing to fake, I think it would draw negative attention to himself. For example I always get scumread as town, so when I'm scum I don't bother trying to fake my town play. I feel like gamma would be the same wayIn post 874, Grapevine wrote:Why do you read people based on playstyle when gamma's playstyle isn't the hardest thing in the world to fake in the first place
What?
I wasn't voting you for that. I was talking about Infinity being dumb (but not scum) for doing that, and so switched my vote back to youIn post 578, House wrote:And this is bullshit anyways.In post 575, Infinity 324 wrote:But now it could be scum just doing busy work so idk.
Dunn was voting me for calling him a VI so I was rubbing his nose in the fact that it was you doing that.
I know you really want me to be scum but...In post 633, Gamma Emerald wrote:Thinking Expedience and Dunnstral are scum rn.
I don't think it was borderline anything and it definitely wasn't intended like thatIn post 674, PantherPunt wrote:so the subject needs to be killed. I was warning him that it was borderline breachy
lol
I owe him much death for Bloodborne.
Seems normal to me. Definitely not something he turned on for being scum. Worried about the borderline borderline thing as that may have been trying to fake a townslipIn post 754, Infinity 324 wrote:That reminds meIn post 740, PantherPunt wrote:Well then it sounds like a player specific thing then where someone sounds particularly smarter as scum. And doesn't as town. Or, meta, if you will.In post 731, Infinity 324 wrote: Thing is, you can be smart without showing it. Smart scum have motivation to play up their smartness and/or make it more visible.
Maybe if you're wondering about that, you can ask players in the game who have played with me, or check out some completed games.
If anyone has played with panther and knows something about this, speak up
If not, I may or may not look into it in the future
He also said expedience has no original thoughts and copy/pastes how reads and is scum. Now scum lean. But all based on an initial readslistIn post 891, Dunnstral wrote:I don't understand how gamma can say I'm scum every other post but just quotes a post of me voting stargazers as the reason
No I don't have any scumreadsIn post 895, lane0168 wrote:@infinity ,have you got any scum reads yet? Anymore than your wishy washy read on creature?
Your vote seemed like you were trying to be like "oh hey I see you scumread this person vote them not me".In post 890, Dunnstral wrote:@Gamma I really need you to explain your scumread on me. You were asked to before and dodged it
